Their beer is fantastic, and their food is amazing! Get the Camp Hollow Burger! Wonderful staff, great atmosphere! A great place to unwind, enjoy a libation, and listen to some great live music. I highly recommend Lost Hollow!
pat vanbuskirk
Good beer and generous food portions
Christopher Campbell
Unacceptable business practices! We had reservations for our class get-together for several weeks, with classmates coming from out of town, hotel rooms, and B&B’s booked; it’s 2 days before our event, and I was just contacted and informed that we could not keep our reservation because they are hosting a “private” event…ours’ was private as well!!!😡Now, on one of the busiest weekends in Greencastle ( DePauw alumni) I have to scramble to find us a venue!! Never going back to Lost Hollow, and do not recommend for any groups!… By the way,, our group has been there before, and they were very well taken care of!.. which makes this an even bigger disappointment. Having been in restaurant management for several years, this is NOT how you treat guests!
C. Campbell
Aloysia R
Wonderful selection of great beers and delicious food in an inviting venue. We can't wait to come back!
Jen Hamerlinck
Drinks are good. The smash burgers and onion straws are phenomenal. The berry Bleu salad was good but it was pre-made and some of the lettuce was older. Next time I'll get a burger.
Alexis Weidman
Cool place! Live music going, plenty of room on the patio and indoors. Good atmosphere overall. Got my order to go. Ordered the shawarma and smores beignets. Both very tasty and large portion sizes. Would definitely order extra of the dill sauce for shawarma! With all that being said, the price point is a little high. Would definitely consider coming back, but only on special occasions. Thanks!
Sherri Lynn
Stopped in here after a hike in DePaul Park...excellent choice! We had the smashburger/fries and chicken shwarma/housemate chips (surprisingly....very crispy with a little kick...superb!). More than we could finish! Staff very friendly and service was quick. They do brew their own beers...we didn't try today but several others were and the taps appear to be as awesome as the food. This was a win in our book...we will be back!
J S
Wonderful place! The beer is phenomenal and they make ridiculous burgers! Definitely a worthwhile place to go and spend time at!
Jordan Powell
Excellent beer and great chill patio with the dogs. Service was excellent.
Troy Flick
Great food the popper burger was top notch. Good beer selection. Duke is vary good
Great list of rotating beers and food! Try the chicken shawarma, wings, or the corn dog when they’ve got them
Jeremy Galloway
The wings here are absolutely fantastic. They are the best I’ve had in a very long time. Highly recommend. (No pictures as they were delicious and gone before there was a chance to take a picture). 🤤
Dave McAfee
My group enjoyed the atmosphere and service. I would come back for drinks and the live music.
The food is very disappointing and not worth the price. -Shawarma
Andy Cigars
Delicious food, great beer and phenomenal service! Ate outside and enjoyed the patio for dinner. If you are a fan of Irish stouts and their’s is on tap, try it! The beignets for dessert were the perfect end to a great meal of their tasty smashed burgers. Staff is attentive, helpful and welcoming. Highly recommended!
Steve Martz
Great place! The staff is wonderful and the food is amazing!
Their beer is fantastic, and their food is amazing! Get the Camp Hollow Burger! Wonderful staff, great atmosphere! A great place to unwind, enjoy a libation, and listen to some great live music. I highly recommend Lost Hollow!
Good beer and generous food portions
Unacceptable business practices! We had reservations for our class get-together for several weeks, with classmates coming from out of town, hotel rooms, and B&B’s booked; it’s 2 days before our event, and I was just contacted and informed that we could not keep our reservation because they are hosting a “private” event…ours’ was private as well!!!😡Now, on one of the busiest weekends in Greencastle ( DePauw alumni) I have to scramble to find us a venue!!
Never going back to Lost Hollow, and do not recommend for any groups!… By the way,, our group has been there before, and they were very well taken care of!.. which makes this an even bigger disappointment.
Having been in restaurant management for several years, this is NOT how you treat guests!
C. Campbell
Wonderful selection of great beers and delicious food in an inviting venue. We can't wait to come back!
Drinks are good. The smash burgers and onion straws are phenomenal. The berry Bleu salad was good but it was pre-made and some of the lettuce was older. Next time I'll get a burger.
Cool place! Live music going, plenty of room on the patio and indoors. Good atmosphere overall. Got my order to go. Ordered the shawarma and smores beignets. Both very tasty and large portion sizes. Would definitely order extra of the dill sauce for shawarma!
With all that being said, the price point is a little high. Would definitely consider coming back, but only on special occasions. Thanks!
Stopped in here after a hike in DePaul Park...excellent choice! We had the smashburger/fries and chicken shwarma/housemate chips (surprisingly....very crispy with a little kick...superb!). More than we could finish! Staff very friendly and service was quick. They do brew their own beers...we didn't try today but several others were and the taps appear to be as awesome as the food. This was a win in our book...we will be back!
Wonderful place! The beer is phenomenal and they make ridiculous burgers! Definitely a worthwhile place to go and spend time at!
Excellent beer and great chill patio with the dogs. Service was excellent.
Great food the popper burger was top notch. Good beer selection. Duke is vary good
Restaurantji Recommends
Great list of rotating beers and food! Try the chicken shawarma, wings, or the corn dog when they’ve got them
The wings here are absolutely fantastic. They are the best I’ve had in a very long time. Highly recommend. (No pictures as they were delicious and gone before there was a chance to take a picture). 🤤
My group enjoyed the atmosphere and service. I would come back for drinks and the live music.
The food is very disappointing and not worth the price. -Shawarma
Delicious food, great beer and phenomenal service! Ate outside and enjoyed the patio for dinner. If you are a fan of Irish stouts and their’s is on tap, try it! The beignets for dessert were the perfect end to a great meal of their tasty smashed burgers. Staff is attentive, helpful and welcoming. Highly recommended!
Great place! The staff is wonderful and the food is amazing!
Loading...