Our server was nice, but everything else about dining here was a bad experience. Hostess had a miserable attitude. Food and drinks weren't good. We won't be back unless someone else is paying the bill.
Carly Frazier
New to the area so I have been trying all the different places to eat. I have to say Lost Hollow Beer Co is hands down the best restaurant I’ve tried in Greencastle to date. I had their fried pickles and bone in wings. Both were the best I’ve had anywhere. The service was great and loved the atmosphere as well.
Tanner Branham
Best beer for miles. Service is attentive without being overbearing. You won’t regret stopping in!
Thomas Perkins
Great food with better beer. The building was originally the Packard dealership in Greencastle.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American Burger
Mike Swisher
Great location and space. Love to take our dogs and sit on the covered patio after a hike. Had an amazing hazy IPA. Really tasty and, at 5.5 ABV, it was not too strong. Had this crazy cheesy burger with cheese curds and beer cheese (I think there was one more type of cheese on there too). I would suggest adding pickles or tomatoes, as the cheese is super rich. My son had a chicken and cheese quesadilla that was super thick and filling. Service is always good and very friendly. Located just off the town square. So, you can walk around town and end up here. Need to support this gem so they stay around for a long time. I plan to whenever we're in the area.
Parking: Always lots of parking available when we go usually right in front of the place at lunch on a weekend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbara Juengling
Stopped for lunch and had the double smash burger (All-American) and fries. Burger was outstanding! Fast and friendly service. Want to go back when I can sample some brew!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie White Feltner
Perfect for morning coffee hang outs or an evening meet up with friends. Love the atmosphere, food, beverages and staff. Highly recommend
Brandon West
Never had better wings in my life and the beer is immaculate, I’ve got the one luv brut for months and I’ve never had any complaints. The flavor profile is different then any other brut I’ve had,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shane Smoot
Home town feel great good and great people. Recommendations Wing Wednesday or the quesadilla. Ohh and they smash burgers are pretty good…can’t go wrong with any menu option.
Rotten salad, very little on the menu, for a premium price. We will not be back. My husband and I both left, went straight home and had GI issues.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Loretta Killackey
So DISAPPOINTED. MENU ONLINE was different then menu in brewery. Wanted plain old wings they cost them in spices coating. That was out. Got fish was okay fried were warm and some kind of side salad that tasted God AWFUL....
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
James Case
This was our first time here and our waitress suggested fish and chips she said that on this particular day fish and chips were at a discount. So we ordered and the food was good but coleslaw wasn't good, and we also had an appetizer. Our total bill with tip came to 72.00$. With a supposed discount. Wasn't worth it.
Amanda Dorsett
We stopped in for Wing Wednesday and will be back. The adult chicken nuggets are great! We also enjoy that they offer alternative seltzer options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
Holly Stout
The atmosphere was wonderful. The music was great. The Food was amazing. Kids had a blast and the Smores table side blew their minds. They thought that was spectacular!
Kid-friendliness: Kids had an absolute blast
Wheelchair accessibility: Partner had no issues getting in and they had a table all ready for him
Great burgers! Get the flight!
Our server was nice, but everything else about dining here was a bad experience. Hostess had a miserable attitude. Food and drinks weren't good. We won't be back unless someone else is paying the bill.
New to the area so I have been trying all the different places to eat. I have to say Lost Hollow Beer Co is hands down the best restaurant I’ve tried in Greencastle to date. I had their fried pickles and bone in wings. Both were the best I’ve had anywhere. The service was great and loved the atmosphere as well.
Best beer for miles. Service is attentive without being overbearing. You won’t regret stopping in!
Great food with better beer. The building was originally the Packard dealership in Greencastle.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American Burger
Great location and space. Love to take our dogs and sit on the covered patio after a hike. Had an amazing hazy IPA. Really tasty and, at 5.5 ABV, it was not too strong. Had this crazy cheesy burger with cheese curds and beer cheese (I think there was one more type of cheese on there too). I would suggest adding pickles or tomatoes, as the cheese is super rich. My son had a chicken and cheese quesadilla that was super thick and filling. Service is always good and very friendly. Located just off the town square. So, you can walk around town and end up here. Need to support this gem so they stay around for a long time. I plan to whenever we're in the area.
Parking: Always lots of parking available when we go usually right in front of the place at lunch on a weekend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped for lunch and had the double smash burger (All-American) and fries. Burger was outstanding! Fast and friendly service. Want to go back when I can sample some brew!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perfect for morning coffee hang outs or an evening meet up with friends. Love the atmosphere, food, beverages and staff. Highly recommend
Never had better wings in my life and the beer is immaculate, I’ve got the one luv brut for months and I’ve never had any complaints. The flavor profile is different then any other brut I’ve had,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Home town feel great good and great people. Recommendations Wing Wednesday or the quesadilla. Ohh and they smash burgers are pretty good…can’t go wrong with any menu option.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Rotten salad, very little on the menu, for a premium price. We will not be back. My husband and I both left, went straight home and had GI issues.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
So DISAPPOINTED. MENU ONLINE was different then menu in brewery. Wanted plain old wings they cost them in spices coating. That was out. Got fish was okay fried were warm and some kind of side salad that tasted God AWFUL....
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
This was our first time here and our waitress suggested fish and chips she said that on this particular day fish and chips were at a discount. So we ordered and the food was good but coleslaw wasn't good, and we also had an appetizer. Our total bill with tip came to 72.00$. With a supposed discount. Wasn't worth it.
We stopped in for Wing Wednesday and will be back. The adult chicken nuggets are great! We also enjoy that they offer alternative seltzer options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings
The atmosphere was wonderful. The music was great. The Food was amazing. Kids had a blast and the Smores table side blew their minds. They thought that was spectacular!
Kid-friendliness: Kids had an absolute blast
Wheelchair accessibility: Partner had no issues getting in and they had a table all ready for him
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fish and Chips
Loading...