Restaurants in Greencastle

“The Whisk is a wonderful place to gather with family and friends! Their bourbon collection is impressive and the owner is a great guy. I look forward to coming back again and again!”

“First time here,Valentines dinner. Great food and wonderful service! Amanda was great!”

“we usually come for my birthday because the food is so amazing, this year we made a reservation for our 5 year anniversary. let's just say they went all out! flowers on the table our names on the menus and a glass of wine, along with amazing service and great food these are more reasons we will keep telling people this is the place to go. 5 🌟”

“we were passing through Greencastle today and stopped by this BBQ truck based on reviews. you know you're in the right place when you pull in and the mouth starts watering from the perfect smoke smell. amazing Q..rib tips outrageous good...loaded Mac and Cheese topped with one of the best brisket I've had in a long time. he gave us a BBQ sauce flight to try 😋 very kind..ended up getting the Tenderloin Thursday special (killer tenderloin) comes with waffle fries that were fresh, light and crisp. coleslaw was refreshing and not over sauced...baked beans were sweet rich and comforting. incredible meal and and gem of a find. happy to travel an hour to eat here and will keep an eye on festival events that he's at. YES, HE'S THAT GOOD!!!”

“Attended the Mother’s Day brunch and everything was delicious! Service was amazing. Will definitely be back.”

“They are always so kind to me at the bodega, it doesn’t even matter who is working, I know they’ll always be nice to me”

“What a great stop at Putnam County airport! The service was prompt and the menu is decent, offering something for everyone—from breakfast items to sandwiches, salads, and burgers. The atmosphere is unique, especially the nice outdoor seating area where you can relax and watch the runway activity. We recommend this restaurant and we'll come back soon!”

“Literally the best tacos ever!!!! Everything is so fresh all the time. The fact that you can basically make your own tacos is amazing. They have something for everyone including my picky kids.lol chicken and rice for them and tacos 🌮 for me! The Horchata is made from scratch!!!”

“We had our rehearsal dinner at Lost Hollow Beer Co. for about 50 guests, and the experience was incredible from start to finish. They handled our larger group so well and offered a thoughtfully curated limited menu with options that worked for everyone. The service truly stood out—every staff member was kind, attentive, and helpful throughout the night. Even with the extra rush from First Friday in Greencastle, they went above and beyond to keep drinks filled and checked in on us regularly. When the food was taking a bit longer (completely understandable given how busy it was), they even brought out a complimentary plate of nachos, which was such a thoughtful touch. Highly recommend the s’mores beignets, pub nachos, and the blackberry lemon shakeup—they were all amazing. The ambience was also perfect, with live music and a great overall vibe that made the night feel really special. We’re so grateful to the team for being accommodating, responsive, and genuinely kind to us and our guests. Would absolutely love to come back again!”

“Don Julio is a monthly visit for us highly recommend! Great drinks food is amazing and the staff makes you feel so welcomed! Will always be our #1 place to go.”

“Between the lobster Rangoon, tonkotsu broth, or even a hibachi selection, it’s hard to pick a favorite. We love coming to Tokyo!”

“Breadsticks and Pizza had great flavor. Better than most. However the breadsticks were under cooked. I'm assuming because they were grouped together in 5's. Fat part of the pizza crust was under cooked by a few mins. Manager was very receptive and understood my concerns. We will come back for sure. Just slightly disappointing”

“Tried out today and will be back! Great customer service, great food. If you love breakfast give it a try.”

“We loved the college pub/sports bar vibes at Moore's! I only tried the Seafood Dip (which was tasty!) since I wasn't that hungry, but the Hangover Tenderloin, Ultimate PB&J, and Cuban caught my attention - I'll be back with a bigger appetite to try those!”

“Waitress was polite and on top of things. I ordered the Rib Eye it was cooked to temp. had a wonderful flavor and tender. Baked potato was just right and the cabbage soup had a wonderful flavor.”

“A great variety of flavors! I haven't found one yet that I didn't love! The helping size is very generous, and the service is exceptional and friendly.”

“Absolutely amazing ice cream shop! The owner, Jhon, is super friendly and makes the place feel welcoming every time I go. Their flurry is seriously one of the best I’ve had — creamy, flavorful, and loaded with toppings. On top of that, the service is incredibly fast even when it’s busy. You can tell they care about their customers and quality. Definitely one of my favorite spots and I’ll keep coming back!”

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings”

“This place has such a huge variety of different foods to choose from! Best place in Greencastle to eat at! Always such friendly waitress and clean place to go! Nice to eat outside as well. Highly recommend this place! 10/10”

“What an amazing space! The layout and decor are super cool, and the view from the upstairs dining area is second to none. I didn't get a chance to try the coffee drinks, but we did try a glazed yeast donut and sausage/egg/cheese breakfast sandwich on brioche - both were delicious! Lots of great items for take out as well, definitely check this spot out!”

“This is a good buffet for Chinese food, especially if you're looking for high-quality protein! I found 4 varieties of meats, including a really nice honey mustard salmon that perfectly satisfied my protein needs. I also enjoyed a lot of fresh fruit, making this the perfect buffet for me. With a decent variety and options like ice cream for dessert, I would recommend this highly.”

“Love this place Love working at this place Can't believe we had so many ppl for the 1$ subs”

“Tucked a little out of sight, this mom and pop Chinese food place is going to cook you some decent food. I find I need a bit extra soy sauce since I don't think they use MSG, which is a 50/50 good/bad, in my opinion. They were never rude, understood my questions easily and without repeating, and they did not have a long wait time before bringing the food out. The seating area was as you'd expect in a hole-in-the-wall. Only a handful of tables but ample seating for a medium sized group or family. Prices were very reasonable with a lot of mealy for 8$ and the average stomach could get two meals out of it. Solid 4 stars.”

“100% worth the wait every time! Love pizza king and their staff they do an amazing job!”

“The night shift crew there is amazing! Very fast and efficient and made my food how I wanted it. I got a BMT with everything other than black olives along with 2 other sandwiches and the food was really good. Halen, Blake, and Phil are some great sandwich artist! Recommend going to this Subway! Thank you guys.”

“Other than the lengthy phone ordering process, I’m really happy with my experience from this location. Excellent quality and flavor. Some of the best delivery pizza I’ve had, and they didn’t mess up my order. Even my delivery driver was nice!”

“Come for the amazing food! The bacon tacos was amazing—easily the highlight of the meal, and the rest of the food was also great. The staff were nice, creating a very welcoming atmosphere. Just a word of caution: avoid seating very close to the door during cold weather, as it was very cold there! Otherwise, this is a very great place to eat.”