The Counter Ice Cream & Italian Ice
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Ice Cream
Rainbow Sprinkles
Banana Split
PB&J
Menu
Photos
+27 photos
+26 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Just the fact there is an ice cream shop that has enough compassion and willingness to offer vegans in the area an option is awesome. Lots of options for toppings and coffee too! Glad to see this is here and hope they thrive.
Updated from previous review on 2025-05-13
Lovely little ice cream spot with window service and outdoor picnic table seating against the backdrop of a gorgeous mural. The menu is impressive and the ice cream is so creamy and delicious— l almost always get the coffee ice cream with hot fudge and it’s beyond delish! Such a sweet summer spot in quaint downtown Highland, Indiana, and Maria’s Mexican place next door is also a winner!
Everything was very tasty. Just need more seating. But I understand they have purchased a nicer location directly across the street so they should great!
Wheelchair accessibility: Both places have wheelchair access.
Wheelchair accessibility: Both places have wheelchair access.
You May Also Like
Maria's Buena Cocina - 2936 B, Highway Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Jose's Family Restaurant - 2934 Highway Ave
![]()
Peruvian, Italian
Dan's Pierogies, L.L.C. - 2945 Jewett Ave
![]()
Polish, European, Vegetarian