The Counter Ice Cream & Italian Ice
2933 Highway Ave, Highland
(219) 513-8684
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Ice Cream
Rainbow Sprinkles
Banana Split
PB&J
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I'm giving 4 stars because usually I get great ice cream. However, I went the other day and got an ice cream sandwich. The cookies were ROCK hard and on the verge of being straight up burnt. 🥲Very dark brown and had that bitter burnt taste. I didn't notice it at first because the one on top wasn't AS dark, but the bottom one was terrible. I figured they'd still be kind of chewy but nope, cracker dry. I would suggest throwing those away and baking...
Me and my daughter third time visiting this ice cream shop I must say service was fast and the ice cream is excellent. We will Continue to visit throughout the summer I highly recommend
Love going to the counter with friends and family!! The staff are always nice and helpful when I don’t know what I want haha! They offer so much and the portions are great. My favorite sweet treat spot! :)
You May Also Like
Jose's Family Restaurant - 2934 Highway Ave
![]()
Peruvian, Italian
Maria's Buena Cocina - Highway Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Dan's Pierogies, L.L.C. - 2945 Jewett Ave
![]()
Polish, European, Vegetarian