I would give this place at least a 5* rating! We traveled over a half hour to try it out and was not disappointed! The food was excellent! The crab cakes, salad, pizza and wine were delicious! And the service couldn't have been better. Great atmosphere and friendly people. To top it off, my husband left his phone there and when I called, they offered to meet me half way to deliver it! Thank you to the owner for doing just that. That's going above and beyond for your customers! We will be going back very soon!
Molly Tyler
Very yummy. And service was incredible!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free
Holly Hudson
Nicely decorated, comfortable feel. The food was homemade. However, we ordered rolls which the server brought out charred. I was shocked they would serve them like that. They did make new when we asked if this was typical. The server didn't check water or pick up dishes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Cindy Cook
Took my mom to Wise Guys for lunch. We had salad and the Sacrilege pizza. The pizza was cooked to perfection, and the salad was crisp and refreshing! Everything on the menu sounded wonderful! We will be beck to try more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jewels T.
First time eating here! It was a real treat for someone who eats allot of fast food! However sausage was to spicy so I hads to pick it off, pizza was still fantastic regardless and so was service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beany
If I could give a zero I would. DO NOT GO HERE WORST SERVICE AND WORST FOOD IVE HAD IN MY LIFE. I took my mom for her birthday the food was absolutely disgusting the doe was uncooked the portilo roll was extremely sour my stomach is still rolling and my mom got the chicken fetichini and it was dry and the chicken was hard. And when I went back in after dropping them off they only gave me a refund for one thing and wasn't exactly polite about it went as far as going over to another customer and asking them and then pointing at me like i couldnt see. The service absolutely sucked I didn't get a single refill the food was placed down and we weren't even asked how it was they never came back to check on us. When it came time to pay I had to go to the bar to ask how to pay and was told to go sit down they will get someone and then was told they were sorry about it no one not once asked how the food was. And for 2 people bread sticks that was doey and food that was extremely dry it was 50 dollars it wasn't worth 5 it tasted like a 5 year old cooked it. They said they gave me a refund of 15 but according to my account it pulled an additional 15 as of right now if that's what cleares I will be going back and hopefully trying to get it fixed i will update as soon as i know for sure. It was my mom's birthday we went there because we've heard somewhat good things absolutely never again. Even my mom who has always always tipped really well said I shouldn't have tipped the waitress at all.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ken Brown
Parking: We went thru heritage days didn't have full menu midway was outside front door parking was a mess but couldn't ask for better food and service staff was excellent
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Dons Lasagna, Classic Italian House Salad
Mark Wittekind Sr
Clean, newly remodeled, good food, reasonable prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Barbara Burnett
First and last time I ate at wiseguys. A friend from out of town came to visit and I took her there, that’s why I did not make statements when they. That was the saddest excuse for a lunch that I’ve ever had. It was sadly prepared and not at all what chicken Alfredo and a salad should look like. The noodles were just butter noodles that were dry with a few pieces of chicken on it and the salad that was sitting on a parchment tray was saturated and almost un eatable. I ended up paying the 25 something for the two of us as I was trying to avoid a fast food restaurant. It was noon and no one was there so I don’t know what the excuse was for such poor food prep.?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Matthew Earhart
So with Social media, the hype of Oley's has made it impossible to get a table without a long wait on a thurs-sat night. Great to see for the good people at Oleys and well deserved, but can be frustrating for us OG customers who have been supporting them for years... With that said, I'd encourage you to drive 17 minutes further into Huntington to check out Wise Guys!! Right there on the same level of high quality, Italian cuisine from wood fired pizzas to pastas and Grinders! Everything we had was absolutely delicious (Whipped Ricotta app, Spaghetti w/Meatballs, Pizza, the Grinder Salad and a slice of good ol' fashioned yellow cake with chocolate icing for desert)! Full bar as well and the cocktails were great! The hospitality of the staff was welcoming and proud to be a part of this restaurant, I even got a tour of the kitchen and wood-fire pizza oven! These folks are using all fresh ingredients, cutting their own meats for pizzas. Still so much on the menu I am looking forward to trying...Wise Guys will surly satisfy any Italian food lovers craving! Support this local restaurant!
Incredibly average Italian food. Both pizzas completely burnt around edge of crust yet sloppy in the middle. Manicotti crispy on top after it's trip under the salamander with very little sauce or cheese on top. Too hard to cut with a butter knife and eat out of a casserole dish... and very chewy. Life became easier because the portion was so small. Chicken parm swam in the deep fryer too long. Seemed like there was an international sauce shortage for all involved.
All of this absurdity would have never happened if my wife told me what she saw when I merely heard it. We were a four walking in at opening with two other deuces and a six-top this past Saturday. I turned after the "crash" to see a cook that seemed upset that he just dropped something. My wife had full eye contact as he glared, shook his head in disgust at the crowd walking in, and literally THREW a stack of plates on the counter. She didn't say anything to me because her parents had been waiting for dinner and she knew I would have turned and left, probably after words.
Trade out the snowflake that has no idea where his paycheck comes from for someone with passion before he ruins your biz. You open at 4:30 on Saturday, there may be a small crowd when the doors open. Besides the dude pouting from the kitchen, the rest of your staff (minus our waitress, who was very friendly and on top of things) had all the personality of airport security when we were walking through the door.
Highlight of the experience was the killer twist on a Caesar salad. I would drive back for that.
Good flavors. Poor execution. Staff needs some work. One person needs voted off the island.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
Romi Plath
First time here, & we will definitely be back! Food & service were all top notch - even with another party of 30 being served at the same time that we were there. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eli garber
Walked in got sat down pretty quick and waited 15 minutes and no waitress even took our drink order so we just left
Service: 1
Jon Dielman
Great pizza and bread sticks. Service is awesome. Definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jerimiah meyer
I recently found this restaurant and love it. The atmosphere is great and spacious. I like the fact that you don't feel crowded while dining. The food is great, and the wood fired taste is unbeatable. I have had several different styles of pizza, and I haven't been let down at all. The fresh ingredients and quick service makes this place a must for me and the wifes date night. I highly recommend dining at Wise guys Downtown. From the appetizer to dessert, you'll enjoy it all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian House Salad, Toasted Ravioli
I would give this place at least a 5* rating! We traveled over a half hour to try it out and was not disappointed! The food was excellent! The crab cakes, salad, pizza and wine were delicious! And the service couldn't have been better. Great atmosphere and friendly people. To top it off, my husband left his phone there and when I called, they offered to meet me half way to deliver it! Thank you to the owner for doing just that. That's going above and beyond for your customers! We will be going back very soon!
Very yummy. And service was incredible!
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free
Nicely decorated, comfortable feel. The food was homemade. However, we ordered rolls which the server brought out charred. I was shocked they would serve them like that. They did make new when we asked if this was typical. The server didn't check water or pick up dishes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2
Took my mom to Wise Guys for lunch. We had salad and the Sacrilege pizza. The pizza was cooked to perfection, and the salad was crisp and refreshing! Everything on the menu sounded wonderful! We will be beck to try more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time eating here! It was a real treat for someone who eats allot of fast food! However sausage was to spicy so I hads to pick it off, pizza was still fantastic regardless and so was service!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If I could give a zero I would. DO NOT GO HERE WORST SERVICE AND WORST FOOD IVE HAD IN MY LIFE. I took my mom for her birthday the food was absolutely disgusting the doe was uncooked the portilo roll was extremely sour my stomach is still rolling and my mom got the chicken fetichini and it was dry and the chicken was hard. And when I went back in after dropping them off they only gave me a refund for one thing and wasn't exactly polite about it went as far as going over to another customer and asking them and then pointing at me like i couldnt see. The service absolutely sucked I didn't get a single refill the food was placed down and we weren't even asked how it was they never came back to check on us. When it came time to pay I had to go to the bar to ask how to pay and was told to go sit down they will get someone and then was told they were sorry about it no one not once asked how the food was. And for 2 people bread sticks that was doey and food that was extremely dry it was 50 dollars it wasn't worth 5 it tasted like a 5 year old cooked it. They said they gave me a refund of 15 but according to my account it pulled an additional 15 as of right now if that's what cleares I will be going back and hopefully trying to get it fixed i will update as soon as i know for sure.
It was my mom's birthday we went there because we've heard somewhat good things absolutely never again. Even my mom who has always always tipped really well said I shouldn't have tipped the waitress at all.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Parking: We went thru heritage days didn't have full menu midway was outside front door parking was a mess but couldn't ask for better food and service staff was excellent
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Dons Lasagna, Classic Italian House Salad
Clean, newly remodeled, good food, reasonable prices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
First and last time I ate at wiseguys. A friend from out of town came to visit and I took her there, that’s why I did not make statements when they. That was the saddest excuse for a lunch that I’ve ever had. It was sadly prepared and not at all what chicken Alfredo and a salad should look like. The noodles were just butter noodles that were dry with a few pieces of chicken on it and the salad that was sitting on a parchment tray was saturated and almost un eatable. I ended up paying the 25 something for the two of us as I was trying to avoid a fast food restaurant. It was noon and no one was there so I don’t know what the excuse was for such poor food prep.?
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
So with Social media, the hype of Oley's has made it impossible to get a table without a long wait on a thurs-sat night. Great to see for the good people at Oleys and well deserved, but can be frustrating for us OG customers who have been supporting them for years... With that said, I'd encourage you to drive 17 minutes further into Huntington to check out Wise Guys!! Right there on the same level of high quality, Italian cuisine from wood fired pizzas to pastas and Grinders! Everything we had was absolutely delicious (Whipped Ricotta app, Spaghetti w/Meatballs, Pizza, the Grinder Salad and a slice of good ol' fashioned yellow cake with chocolate icing for desert)! Full bar as well and the cocktails were great! The hospitality of the staff was welcoming and proud to be a part of this restaurant, I even got a tour of the kitchen and wood-fire pizza oven! These folks are using all fresh ingredients, cutting their own meats for pizzas. Still so much on the menu I am looking forward to trying...Wise Guys will surly satisfy any Italian food lovers craving! Support this local restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti & Meatballs
Restaurantji Recommends
Incredibly average Italian food. Both pizzas completely burnt around edge of crust yet sloppy in the middle. Manicotti crispy on top after it's trip under the salamander with very little sauce or cheese on top. Too hard to cut with a butter knife and eat out of a casserole dish... and very chewy. Life became easier because the portion was so small. Chicken parm swam in the deep fryer too long. Seemed like there was an international sauce shortage for all involved.
All of this absurdity would have never happened if my wife told me what she saw when I merely heard it. We were a four walking in at opening with two other deuces and a six-top this past Saturday. I turned after the "crash" to see a cook that seemed upset that he just dropped something. My wife had full eye contact as he glared, shook his head in disgust at the crowd walking in, and literally THREW a stack of plates on the counter. She didn't say anything to me because her parents had been waiting for dinner and she knew I would have turned and left, probably after words.
Trade out the snowflake that has no idea where his paycheck comes from for someone with passion before he ruins your biz. You open at 4:30 on Saturday, there may be a small crowd when the doors open. Besides the dude pouting from the kitchen, the rest of your staff (minus our waitress, who was very friendly and on top of things) had all the personality of airport security when we were walking through the door.
Highlight of the experience was the killer twist on a Caesar salad. I would drive back for that.
Good flavors. Poor execution. Staff needs some work. One person needs voted off the island.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 3
First time here, & we will definitely be back! Food & service were all top notch - even with another party of 30 being served at the same time that we were there. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Walked in got sat down pretty quick and waited 15 minutes and no waitress even took our drink order so we just left
Service: 1
Great pizza and bread sticks. Service is awesome. Definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I recently found this restaurant and love it. The atmosphere is great and spacious. I like the fact that you don't feel crowded while dining. The food is great, and the wood fired taste is unbeatable. I have had several different styles of pizza, and I haven't been let down at all. The fresh ingredients and quick service makes this place a must for me and the wifes date night. I highly recommend dining at Wise guys Downtown. From the appetizer to dessert, you'll enjoy it all.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian House Salad, Toasted Ravioli
Loading...