Alexiva bakery

2142 N Mitthoefer Rd, Indianapolis
(317) 377-4687

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Vivian

Came in, got some donuts, the ladies helped me understand how it works. Beautiful baked goods. It was delicious. Grab a tray and some tongs and snag some super good donuts of other pastries.. even cakes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tiffany Brown

We got 6 different things and everything we bought was incredible! Great selection of baked goods and cakes and a friendly staff, we will definitely go again!

Food: 5

Service: 5

doe joe

They were able to accommodate a short notice cupcake order with excellent service and a delicious product at great value. My daughter's birthday was great because of them and I plan on returning to them again soon for my son's birthday

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kimirly Black

OMG what a find!!! So glad we swung by and decided to go with a locally owned bakery on the Eastside. Alexiva definitely has returning customer in us. Their empanada de crema is to die for! Can't wait to pick up my son's birthday cupcakes next week! I bet they'll be just as amazing!

Update: Through no fault of their own, their oven broke down in the middle of baking the morning of our cupcake order pickup.
They handled it very well and substituted the cupcakes for a different item they were able to bake that morning. 12 whole empanada de cremas!!! I was even more thrilled and excited about sharing my birthday goodies with my children and family!
I highly recommend!

Update!
We ordered a small birthday cake. Chocolate with Nutella filling and buttercream frosting. It was TO DIE FOR!!!! The cake was superb and moist, the filling was even more delicious than expected, the frosting wasn't too sweet just perfect! Thank you!!!!

Update!
My mom surprised me with an amazing tres Leche for Valentine's Day! Yummy 😋

Update!
OMG they went above and beyond again! This time Zach's cake was a chocolate Leche with mocha frosting and a caramel center. It is to die for!

Ximena Ruiz

I went for a couple of treats it was a amazing experience they had a great service it was very clean the bread lasted me a long time which if you go to other places it only lasts a day or two I really recommend this place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Fruit Tart, Tres Leches Cake, Cupcake, Mini Tartaletas, Tiramisu, Custom Bday Cake, Carrot Cake, Baguette

Michael Krauthamer

Delightfully Delicious!! I found this awesome Mexican bakery hidden at 21st and Mitthoeffer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jace H. (Pretty Boi)

The baked goods are delicious and super reasonably priced. The people working there are really nice too, and the shop is super clean. This is 100% becoming our go to bakery.

Update 10/4/23: It's been almost a year and I'm so happy I discovered this place. I am still going back regularly and trying the different stuffy they have. The Tirimisu and Canolis are especially fantastic. If I could give more than 5 stars I would as I've never had bad service or bad quality items

Victoria Merida

9/13/23 I had another days old concha with my coffee this morning. It still tasted fresher than any other bakery on the east side! And they made my birthday cake in July. I thought my husband got too much, but that sht disappeared in days!

She makes the best conchas EVER. They're so soft they last more than a day, not like the other places where the concha is a crouton that evening. I ate my last concha 3 days after I bought it!

Keisha Ricketts

I love this place. They have friendly staff and their treats are soooo fresh and good. I have had a custom cake and 12 cupcakes done as well for a birthday party. Beautifully designed, matched my vision and great on cost. My absolute favorites are the tres leches cake, the cake pops (both in the fridges) and the chocolate pastry cake thing with filling in the case (it looks like a hostess ding dong). Please visit, you won't be disappointed, their selection is amazing!

Angela Gunder

Awesome value ! To die for ..Tres Leches !!
Best I've ever had !!

Cheyanne Flannery

Amazing tres leches !! Wow ! Good price too !

Becky Chapman

The 5 different baked goods we purchased this morning were so stale we had to throw them away. We were so disappointed.

Steve Moody

I stopped in yesterday to get some bread for Cuban sandwiches. The woman who helped me was so friendly and went through the entire display explaining what each item was. I ended up with a white bread and a spicy jalapeño cream cheese bread. The spicy bread was soooooooo good! I can’t wait to try the white bread. The only issue was I gained 5 pounds just looking at all the awesome baked items. I’ll devote be back!

Nolan K

Everything is so tasty! And they're super great, friendly people! Love this place.

Alissa Pierle

We tried this bakery for the first time this evening. They were very affordable. The staff was very friendly! The store was very clean and well-organized. The strawberry cheesecake was great! The flan was not the best we have had, but still very tasty. We cannot wait to try the other items we purchased!

Loading...