Is it possible to give fewer than 1 star? I went to this location. was the ONLY one at the counter and the multiple employees never acknowledged me at all. The another customer came in and she was greeted and served immediately. I tried to ignore the slight but then when another customer came in behind her and was served next--While I continued to stand at the counter, it was too much. I left. I'm not easily missed as I was the only customer of color at the store but apparently today I was invisible. I do not recommend this place as other reviews have mentioned staff as the problem and I can concur, staff is the problem. Find another Amelia's or go to Whole Foods when I get great service every time I go.
Service: 1
Nancy Smith
Awesome bakery that also sells pretty good coffee! The bakery items are excellent - haven't tried any of the breads yet, but something tells me they will be yumny! Amelia's also sells otger edible treats which I will peruse next time I'm there. Cool seating area aa well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Mamlin
I wasn't going to say anything because I thought it might be just me, but I agree 100% with the previous review about the guy behind the counter being annoyed that I was there, and I even dared to ask a question about the coffee... I like the products you sell, but next time I walk in and see him I'll walk right back out.
Jacob Cantrell
I've been a fan of Amelia's for several years now, so was ecstatic to have a new store open downtown at the Stutz! Their pastries are all next level, recently tried the stuffed french toast (pictured) that was incredible. Also a huge fan of the curry danish and the ham & cheese biscuit. The coffee service is also great and recently they've had more specialty latte options that have all been delicious. Also can't miss their unique gelato flavors in the warmer season!Also love that all of the Amelia's locations are open 8-8, making them my go-to for an evening coffee run or study session!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jared M. Herbert
Amazing service, fresh bread daily, and hand-fashioned coffees—all within a proudly local Indianapolis bakery & café. I cannot recommend Amelia’s Bakery & Café more!Wheelchair accessibility: Accessible for those with wheelchairs.
Their coffee is sooo good here! I also got a chocolate chip cookie. It was really rich. Personally I prefer a chewier chocolate chip but it was still really tasty.
Vince Edwards
Fantastic bakery with sourdough breads and laminated pastries that are not too be missed..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Payal P.
RUN DON'T WALK! This croissant is the perfect midday snack or on-the-go breakfast! I wish I remembered the name but it is a pillowy soft croissant with a flaky crust, topped with Swiss cheese, everything bagel seasoning and parsley - perfect item for a vegetarian or cheese-lover! Just absolutely gorgeous and mouth watering. This item was so flavorful with the salty Swiss cheese and who doesn't love everything bagel seasoning. I was too excited to try it right after purchasing but I bet it would be a base for an egg sammie. This might be my new weekly go-to treat! A must try!! Amelia's has lots of great other options too from buttermilk biscuits to sweet pastries to fresh baked breads to take home to daily sandwich specials. Staff is always so kind when I visit and helpful in answering questions for someone like me who is indecisive! Amelia's also doubles as a great study spot and pit stop for some unique grocery items!
Joseph D.
On our way to a long wedding and was starving. Remember this had opened as we were passing the Stutz building. Ran in, had great quick service and the delicious food as both the other locations.
Prasad Nair
The pastries and Croissants are always delicious. I like the Cranberry Walnut bread as well.
This place is awesome. Service is always great. I've been here multiple times and every pastry or beverage I get is excellent. Seating is minimal but I've always found a spot to do homework. The environment is awesome, and I'm glad I don't live closer because I'd spend all my money here. Definetly worth it to go grab a coffee and study for a while, or walk around the area. You can't go wrong trying this place.
Matt Andrews
Listen, if we as a city can't support this absolute gem of a spot, we definitely don't deserve nice things. For the love of all that's holy, please do us all a favor and stop in for the capicola twist and a coffee.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Katie Bailey
Love Amelia’s products. Felt like the guy working there was annoyed to have customers. Kinda awkward. Customer service is important.
Is it possible to give fewer than 1 star? I went to this location. was the ONLY one at the counter and the multiple employees never acknowledged me at all. The another customer came in and she was greeted and served immediately. I tried to ignore the slight but then when another customer came in behind her and was served next--While I continued to stand at the counter, it was too much. I left. I'm not easily missed as I was the only customer of color at the store but apparently today I was invisible. I do not recommend this place as other reviews have mentioned staff as the problem and I can concur, staff is the problem. Find another Amelia's or go to Whole Foods when I get great service every time I go.
Service: 1
Awesome bakery that also sells pretty good coffee! The bakery items are excellent - haven't tried any of the breads yet, but something tells me they will be yumny! Amelia's also sells otger edible treats which I will peruse next time I'm there. Cool seating area aa well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wasn't going to say anything because I thought it might be just me, but I agree 100% with the previous review about the guy behind the counter being annoyed that I was there, and I even dared to ask a question about the coffee... I like the products you sell, but next time I walk in and see him I'll walk right back out.
I've been a fan of Amelia's for several years now, so was ecstatic to have a new store open downtown at the Stutz! Their pastries are all next level, recently tried the stuffed french toast (pictured) that was incredible. Also a huge fan of the curry danish and the ham & cheese biscuit. The coffee service is also great and recently they've had more specialty latte options that have all been delicious. Also can't miss their unique gelato flavors in the warmer season!Also love that all of the Amelia's locations are open 8-8, making them my go-to for an evening coffee run or study session!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Amazing service, fresh bread daily, and hand-fashioned coffees—all within a proudly local Indianapolis bakery & café. I cannot recommend Amelia’s Bakery & Café more!Wheelchair accessibility: Accessible for those with wheelchairs.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Croissantand Chocolate Croissants
Their coffee is sooo good here! I also got a chocolate chip cookie. It was really rich. Personally I prefer a chewier chocolate chip but it was still really tasty.
Fantastic bakery with sourdough breads and laminated pastries that are not too be missed..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
RUN DON'T WALK! This croissant is the perfect midday snack or on-the-go breakfast! I wish I remembered the name but it is a pillowy soft croissant with a flaky crust, topped with Swiss cheese, everything bagel seasoning and parsley - perfect item for a vegetarian or cheese-lover! Just absolutely gorgeous and mouth watering. This item was so flavorful with the salty Swiss cheese and who doesn't love everything bagel seasoning. I was too excited to try it right after purchasing but I bet it would be a base for an egg sammie. This might be my new weekly go-to treat! A must try!! Amelia's has lots of great other options too from buttermilk biscuits to sweet pastries to fresh baked breads to take home to daily sandwich specials. Staff is always so kind when I visit and helpful in answering questions for someone like me who is indecisive! Amelia's also doubles as a great study spot and pit stop for some unique grocery items!
On our way to a long wedding and was starving. Remember this had opened as we were passing the Stutz building. Ran in, had great quick service and the delicious food as both the other locations.
The pastries and Croissants are always delicious. I like the Cranberry Walnut bread as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Croissantand Chocolate Croissants
Restaurantji Recommends
Best baked pasteries I’ve had in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is awesome. Service is always great. I've been here multiple times and every pastry or beverage I get is excellent. Seating is minimal but I've always found a spot to do homework. The environment is awesome, and I'm glad I don't live closer because I'd spend all my money here. Definetly worth it to go grab a coffee and study for a while, or walk around the area. You can't go wrong trying this place.
Listen, if we as a city can't support this absolute gem of a spot, we definitely don't deserve nice things. For the love of all that's holy, please do us all a favor and stop in for the capicola twist and a coffee.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love Amelia’s products. Felt like the guy working there was annoyed to have customers. Kinda awkward. Customer service is important.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 2
Discount for IU Health employees too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5