Bagel Fair

1300 E 86th St #19, Indianapolis
(317) 846-0950

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Jalapeno and Cream Cheese Bagels
Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread
Jalapeno Cayenne Bagels
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Lox Cream Cheese
Everything Bagel
Egg and Cheese
Blueberry Bagel
Egg & Cheese

Menu

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+15 photos
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+14 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I went to Bagel Fair today for the first time. I was very impressed by the variety of bagels and cream cheeses available! I bought 15 bagels of various kinds, and the ones I have tried so far have been delicious! They are everything that a bagel SHOULD be! Dense and chewy, but tender, not tough. Absolutely delightful!
My favorite so far is their jalapeno bagel, with jalapeno cream cheese--fantastic combination!
I highly recommend Bagel Fair, if you are looking...
July 2025
Went here for the first time this morning. I had their lox and cream cheese bagel sandwich and it was delicious! Best bagel I've had in Indy, by far. The place was packed but the service was so quick (and friendly!) that I was still in and out in less than 10 minutes. The pricing also seemed incredibly fair. On par with big bagel chains but a far superior product.
October 2024
Got some bagels from here while on a trip through Indiana. This place is delicious, the veggie cream cheese is totally NY style and I got an extra bagel for the next morning! Salt bagel sliced not toasted with veggie cream cheese is the best ?
September 2024

More Reviews

Bagel Fair

1300 E 86th St #19, Indianapolis, IN 46240
(317) 846-0950