Bagel Fair
1300 E 86th St #19, Indianapolis
(317) 846-0950
Customers' Favorites
Jalapeno and Cream Cheese Bagels
Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread
Jalapeño Cayenne Bagel
Jalapeno Cayenne Bagels
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Everything Bagel
Lox Cream Cheese
Salami Sandwich
Blueberry Bagel
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
So amazing this establishment has been operating now for 50 years. I member going here shortly after it opened as a kid with my mom. The inside has changed but not the food or the service. Best bagels ever. Every time I have a bagel somewhere else they never compare to Bagel Fair.
The new Bagel Dog sandwich offering is really a terrific value and a delicious sandwich! It is a very good sized all-beef hotdog wrapped in a bagel and served hot. They already have the best bagels in town. Now, they have one of the best sandwiches in town.
I went to Bagel Fair today for the first time. I was very impressed by the variety of bagels and cream cheeses available! I bought 15 bagels of various kinds, and the ones I have tried so far have been delicious! They are everything that a bagel SHOULD be! Dense and chewy, but tender, not tough. Absolutely delightful!
My favorite so far is their jalapeno bagel, with jalapeno cream cheese--fantastic combination!
I highly recommend Bagel Fair, if you are looking...
My favorite so far is their jalapeno bagel, with jalapeno cream cheese--fantastic combination!
I highly recommend Bagel Fair, if you are looking...