Brenda's Cakes

6313 Rockville Rd, Indianapolis
(317) 244-1241

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Maria Zeno

I called and left multiple messages, for a call back as no one answers the phone, in order to set up an appointment. Never got a call, needless to say I would never recommend this place. Thank god I was not in a crunch to need a cake for my daughters birthday. I went else where and got a quick response with amazing service. Horrible customer service.

Tee Jay

This place is absolutely amazing! The owner Ms. Brenda is always kind ,friendly, and very professional. Cakes are always moist and icing is perfect! Banana is my favorite flavor. Decorations never disappoint. If you haven't tried it, you're definitely missing out.

Mary Brandon

The service was awesome. We didn’t feel pressured at all, and she suggested the size we would need.

Our wedding cake was awesome! The fairy glitter was a subtle but elegant touch! I normally don’t like fondant, but her’s was absolutely delicious! The butter cream frosting is the best I ever had!

Steph Duda

Ordered a red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting for my kid’s birthday. It is absolutely delicious! He’s a 16 yo boy so he didn’t want anything too fancy. They did a great job! The frosting melts in your mouth and the cake is moist and flavorful. Thank you so much!

alli cat

I ordered a gender reveal cake. She was really helpful and nice. I had an envelope that I dropped off with the gender inside. I said I wanted white on the outside, and blue or pink on the inside. I thought that she would just make the icing the appropriate color and that the cake itself would be white. The cake ended up being strawberry. Which really sucks because me and my husband both hate strawberry cake. This is the first time I have ever ordered from her but not the first time I ever had her cakes. Her cakes are really tasty I'm just disappointed because I spent 40 bucks on a cake that no one is going to eat. I am sure it's half my fault for not being specific but I also feel like it's kind of crazy to put in a flavored cake for someone with out running it by them. And I'm curious if it was a boy, is there blueberry cake?

Derrick D

Brenda's is absolutely amazing. We have gotten several different cakes from birthdays to promotions, and they have never let us down. Every design we've gotten has been unique and special to us, and they are perfect every time!

Brooke Faulkner

Very poor communication. Ended up going with a different company. Disappointed!

Service: 2

Navy Lynch

Brenda is an incredible baker! She made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding and they were a HUGE hit! Super reasonably priced and really high quality, she did all the flavors we wanted and added fruit compotes that were delicious. Very easy to work with and could not recommend more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mikaylah Stumbo

Brenda's has done both our wedding cake and our baby gender reveal cake over the last 5 years. Their cake quality is wonderful and they are very accommodating to helping you pick put the perfect flavor combo. The gender reveal cake was a super last minute request, but they were able to take our results and pull together a cake within 2 hours! Highly recommend them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Esty Molina

I am very happy with the cakes done by Brenda and Sarah and the staff! Ladies, you are amazing 🤩 you have a wonderful customer service and go above and beyond to make sure you make the customers feel heard. I can not express how happy I am with my cakes. They definitely go the extra mile. We Totally recommend. Pictures in the comments

Casey Dietrich

Amazing and professional Baker and Cake Decorator. I love this place and WILL come back every birthday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Fattic

The only place my wife will go to for cakes. Hours of operation varies.

Gena Kambouris

One of the best cakes I have had the pleasure of eating. Not only was the cake moist and tender and just perfect, Brenda went above and beyond to accommodate me. I cannot recommend her enough!!! Oh, and the sugar cream frosting... Divine

Tony clark

Order was ready on time. Staff was friendly and helpful

Aderonke

One of the best place to order events cake.....

Loading...