Brenda's Cakes

6313 Rockville Rd, Indianapolis
(317) 244-1241

Recent Reviews

Abigail M.

I ordered a cake for my daughter's second birthday , it was perfect! The design, flavor, texture, everything. This was my first time using brenda's cakes but i will be recommending to everyone. They were accommodating and the cake looked identical to the picture . Everyone at the party mentioned how good it tasted as well. I will be using brenda's cake from here on out!

Sadiya A.

I ordered a cake for a colleague's going away party as it was her favorite. I placed an order from their website, sent in a description and pictures of what we wanted on the cake and it turned out pretty as well as delicious! The communication was quick and friendly within a couple of days of responses. We did a half sheet, half white and half chocolate, it was very tasty and had the perfect amount of sweet. Pickup was quick, although it being right on Rockville Rd with heavy traffic it was a bit tricky but made it out okay from the parking lot as it is a tiny lot. I would definitely order again for my own events!

Casey Dietrich

Amazing and professional Baker and Cake Decorator. I love this place and WILL come back every birthday.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Fattic

The only place my wife will go to for cakes. Hours of operation varies.

Gena Kambouris

One of the best cakes I have had the pleasure of eating. Not only was the cake moist and tender and just perfect, Brenda went above and beyond to accommodate me. I cannot recommend her enough!!! Oh, and the sugar cream frosting... Divine

Destiny S.

Since November I've had 3 cakes made by Brenda and I absolutely love every cake she's made! They're beautiful, they taste delicious and stay soft for awhile; unlike others I've have before.I've sent Brenda a picture of a cake I wanted and she's made it EXACTLY how it was in the photo. I've given her an idea of how I wanted a cake and she created it how I pictured, she's just naturally gifted.Brenda's also very punctual, she let's you know how everything works off bat. How payment is taken, what forms of payment she takes (credit and/ or card), when you need to be at the shop to pick up the cake and so on.In the shop she has seasonal cakes, wedding cakes, birthday cakes, her pro-folio of different cakes she's done (and can do) from past vendors and events. The accessories you can add to the cakes etc.

Samantha Pittman

I got my daughter's birthday cake from here. The cake its self was good not the best i ever had but it was good. The buttercream icing was a bit off putting while we enjoyed the sweetness it tasted like it had an added spice in there and we werent a fan of. They were late getting it done. My cake was supposed to be ready at 8 but they had accidentally put it down for 10. They did stop everything and get my cake ready, i think i had to wait 15 mins, not too bad.

Man 1000

My first time at this bakery was last month for a coworker's bday party. This $45 8" strawberry cake with butter cream frosting tasted great and it was decorated perfectly. I'll definitely give this place another visit.

JayDee Twin

I use them 5-6 times a year. Customer service is awesome, cakes not only look great but also taste great. Highly recommend.

Helen Ukeh

Thank you Brenda for an amazing cake. My daughter loved it. The design was superb. Good job!

Tierra T

If i had the option to not rate, i wouldn’t. The communication is horrible. I had a cake tasting scheduled one week and had to set a new appointment due to the lack of communication (two different workers not communicating with one another ) as well as not having the cakes ready on original schedule . On the new scheduled day of cake tasting, due to the lack of communication i thought it would be best to call due to avoid issues JUST to find out someone changed the time without consulting me. Very disappointed and i made the decision to fully cancel for what is called unprofessional on their end.If you do not want to stress or To avoid anxiety for your big day … say NO to this place. Hopes this help

Leia Shrout

Brenda's did our wedding cake and it was beautiful! The flavors of each tier were amazing! We did white cake/lemon curd, chocolate cake/seedless raspberry, marble/Bavarian cream. I'm not a chocolate cake fan but that seedless raspberry made it to die for! I can't wait for our anniversary to eat the top tier....even at a year old I'm sure it'll still be good. The process was easy & Brenda was helpful throughout the whole thing. I gave her my vision, emailed a few pictures, and dropped off some silk flowers and she took it from there. Delivery was on time and set up without any issues as well. I would absolutely recommend giving this place a try and I'll definitely be back for future celebrations.

Allison Rodriguez

Brenda's cakes made the cake for my gender reveal party tonight. Everyone loved the cake, it was delicious!!! Pricing is very fair. It was also very easy to get the gender information to her so that it could be a secret for everyone.

Tammie Curry

Absolutely delicious!!!!!!Thank you Brenda’s Cakes ?

Steph R

I had my quinceañera cake made my Brenda's. I loved it! We scheduled a cake testing before ordering it. My cake was beautiful! I didn't have to stress about picking it up! they delivered to the venue. It had a waterfall and was pretty big! They had a couple different cakes with different flavors.I highly recommend to anyone

Load More