Colonial Tavern

4343 Madison Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 783-2553

Recent Reviews

Lane Hatcher

This is my normal Sunday Monday night karaoke bar, and the service has always been impeccable. The food has always been very good. The DJ has always been nice but tonight DJ apparently had issues with the only black person in the bar first he said to me to not touch the microphone because it’s broken and has a short, a few minutes later, I see a white guy handling the microphone before I perform, and I asked didn’t you say the microphone was broken and he explained oh yeah, that guy used to work here. He knows how to hold the microphone after my performance I sat quietly and watched my name goes from next in line Over and over again as he pushed everyone in front of me until I went and asked him why is this happening?. to say I’m disappointed would be an understatement. If it wasn’t for the fact that they are so dead on Sunday and Mondays, I wouldn’t go. After experiencing what I experienced this evening..

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lyric Hatcher

The place is cool and I love the karaoke but I wouldn’t trust them with your debit or credit card. Just pay cash because they charged my tab and a random person tab (which wasn’t a small amount) and my money has been locked for 4 days! I’ve also had other issues paying with card so they lost my trust when it comes to this.

Dj Dj

Excellent staff. Fun karaoke with my homies, and good looking OT grad school students from U of I.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Catalina Altomonte

Cupcake is just the best. Was here for Valentines dinner pre game and ended up coming back after dinner for more drinks - our bartender Cupcake prepared special Jell-O shots too

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Christina K N.

Awesome Drink prices, Friendly Staff, karaoke seven days a week, Great place to have Birthday parties, Anniversary's,

Will Braxton

Fun night of singing who could ask for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Doug Lackey

Great little gem on Indy's South side!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kam Casey

DJ T BONE PLEASE STOP PLAYING 2 SONGS BETWEEN EVERY SINGER WE CAME HERE FOR KARAOKE NOT TYGA SONGS.

Megs Denise

Love the safe, fun, and diverse atmosphere! Always greeted by name when visiting. All the staff is very welcoming. Always served in a timely manner no matter how busy they are. If you have yet to stop in, I highly recommend doing so. It’s s an enjoyable experience you’ll return to!

Delbert Tapscott

Both female Bar tenders are rude and I catch them tipping there selves and demanding tips and it’s with out permission serves isn’t best food is nasty and security isn’t the best there rude to I had better time at other bars not to mention the bar tenders are very non experienced at making drinks and both female bartender’s also look like drug addicted it seems like they will hire anyone to work there for sure

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Amber Gray

I was in there last night with a group of friends, which we go quite often but last night the bartenders wouldn't serve us. then the bouncers start punching and pushing on one of my friends, he didn't do anything wrong just tried to make a order.they called the police on us for no reason. I will never go back there. they are racist against Hispanics.

Megan Braun

I was there with a group of friends last night. bouncers beat one of my friends up for no reason ! broke his necklace and I'm pretty sure they found it and kept it !! called the police for no reason ! we are in there just about every weekend and spend lots of money !! take your money some where else that isn't racist against Mexicans !!!

Stephen Luckett

This place has always been inviting and comfortable to me and

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Helma Parten

We came on Saturday. Service was great, the waitress visited often and made sure we had drinks all night.The KJ was good too, but, way too long of breaks between singers, and OH MY GOD, THE MUSIC BETWEEN SINGERS WAS SO LOUD AND TREBLY IT PHYSICALLY HURT!I spoke to a bunch of groups of people who left because they couldn't stand the volume. I understand loud so everyone can hear, but when you can't hear each other talk and your ears are in pain and ringing its way too much. Tone down that volume and you have a good place for karaoke.

Atmosphere: 2

Service: 5

Tim Gebler

Love love love my colonial inn staff you guys are the best had a great time tonight thanks Dannie Terrence and megs you guys are the best thanks lorie and dane for having the best staff I am now a great karaoke singer so much

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More