Fat Man's BBQ

Maaaaaaan… I wish I would’ve looked at the reviews for these turkey tips before I ordered. They are correct. The sauce is good.. the meat was not. 😭😭😭😭

Food: 1

Service: 4

I got the small tip and it is terrible if you ask me the meat was tough, the sauce wasn’t that good either. I’m use to tips begin tender and getting your money for a small tip I tried it and I won’t be back god bless.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ordered here and delivery times were changed 6 times. Called them and then order was canceled. Kept blaming it on Uber eats and I was using door dash. Totally unprofessional, food is sub par. Prices are ridiculous for quality. Hit and miss on taste. Turkey tips are always burnt and hard. Drivers wait forever for orders and those little servings of size.Spend your hard earned dollars elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Quick to respond ,good food ,good taste

Got the burnt ends with potato salad, Mac and cheese, and a grape lemonade. Burnt ends were tender, even the fat was melt-in-your-mouth, and the mixed sauce was delicious. Mac and potato salad were also very good. I told myself if the grape lemonade was just grape kool-aid and lemonade mixed, I would still love it and I DID. I will definitely go back here next time I'm craving bbq.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place got some ribs they look good but they taste real porky I taste some brisket and the brisket was real thick and big old chunks of pieces it was nasty and I think they microwave all their stuff and warm it up it's not fresh

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 3

Best food in town
Love it!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Side of greens tasty. Main course:Turkey tips were unseasoned and dried out. Turkey tips seemed to have been cooked the day prior. I don’t think they were grilled maybe boiled however the sauce that it was paired with was delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

This BBQ spot is a hidden gem! 💯 The Turkey ribs are the best I've ever tried before. I highly recommend this business establishment! ♥️
I wish they had a location on the Northeast side of INDY. That's how great their food is! Watch out now BBQ Heaven! 😂

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I gave fat man's bbq a three because the cashier was mean for no reason. The food wasn't all that great...

I ordered off door dash yesterday the ribs were on point tender moist all the way to the bone but I feel this was not a large. Baked beans was good also but it need ground beef and onions and peppers… The Mac and cheese was horrible I don’t know what they did but it’s trash I cold not even give it away..,,

Food: 3

Was told about this place from a few family members. The first time I went, ok, I love the decorations in this joint! It's fun and I like the music. Now, I ordered the small rib tips, two sides (that are rather small. A bit larger would be nice) and asked for mixed sauce. I get home, all excited about this new place. The ribs were tough as hell (reminded me of King Ribs) and they had put mild sauce on it. I told my dad and he said I probably got the tail end of the weekend stuff because I was in on an early weekday, maybe on a Monday. So on that note, I decided to try again.

I went in, excited and happy as normal, got the same order, told the young man the first time I was in, the meat was tough as hell and that they put the wrong sauce on. I asked for hot this time. Now, I get home and the small tips were soooooo good!! NOTHING like the first visit, BUT again, they didn't listen and gave me MILD sauce. Really? Y'all, PLEASE pay attention. If you didn't hear correctly, ask again. I'm spending good money, and the order still isn't right.

So, I'll try ONE more time. After that, I'm done, lol. I tried. I do love the vibe in there, but I need my orders correct. Who wants to come back after they get home, get settled, and realize their order is wrong.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Their hot sauce with the ribtips was top notch. I recommend ordering online.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

THE MEATS! THE SIDES!! We tried the ribs, turkey leg, Mac n cheese, yams, baked beans, and Cole slaw. EVERYTHING was AMAZING! With that said, I'd love to hook you up with a recipe for your banana pudding. 10000/10 would recommend.

Food: 5

I had the taste for some greens so I ordered a turkey tip dinner with greens and potato salad. The potato salad and greens were ok the tips were not tender at all. Sauce has nice flavor but the tips were very tough