Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple

Where to begin? You already know,the pizza is awesome. We are lucky enough to have Tony and his crew in Broadripple. We had a pizza that we were not happy with and Tony went out of his way to make things right. He personally greeted us and even made our pizza. It was perfect. Great pizza,great service, great experience. If you're not eating Goodfellas,there is a void in your life.

UPDATE:If Tony isn't there...leave. Last 3 orders have all been meh. The young light skin guy is nice but be majes a terrible pie. The young lady with the tattoos, super nice...makes a crap pie. Make sure Tony is there and I give them a 5,but the young/evening crew...zero.

Great food, great service with a very chill staff. This is the spot to go to if you want a slice and great company!

The pepperoni was good. Can’t say it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it’s so far been the best NY style I’ve had since moving back to Indianapolis. The inside is really tiny, we wanted to eat inside but wanted a whole pie so we had to borrow the establishment’s counter to hold the box. 3 of us ate a slice there and it just seemed cramped, so I would recommend carry out only from this place, but it’s definitely worth a stop if you’re in the mood for pizza.

Get The Vinny 🤤

We come here whenever we're just wanting a slice of pizza and it's late at night. Used to love their pizza. The quality has changed, though, like maybe the dough? It's just not the same and it's not an improvement.

Love coming here for a slice. The staff is always friendly, and Andrew the general manager always makes the best pies for lunch specials!

Andrew is amazing every time I come in! Killer calzones!

Breadsticks were sooooooooooo good

We visited from out of town 2 weekends ago. One of the best experiences I’ve ever had in a small restaurant. Amazing food! Extraordinary staff members who were some of the most pleasant staff I’ve encountered in the food industry in a long time. 5 stars all the way!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Enchanted

This location is incredibly small. The food is amazing. The man today put 3 pieces of pizza and a breadstick with 3 cheese sauces in 1 small box, making it incredibly messy and hard to eat in the car.
Food is always a 5.
Need to expand customer section of this store.
Customer service today was a 3.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

This is a decent place to go if you’re craving a slice a pizza. I’m new to Indiana. I’m an Italian American from NY so I have high standards for pizza. In NY there a “mom and pop” owned pizzerias all over. Here, it’s all franchises so you have to take your expectations. I like how large the slices are, the cheese is fine, but the sauce is a bit tart for my liking. I prefer a s sweet tomato sauce! The pizzeria itself appeared clean and the worker was friendly, so I’d visit again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice

Some of the best New York style pizza you can find in Indiana. Only thing I wish they had was a bigger seating area

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Pizza

It's the big foldable slices, already made they reheat them. Not enough cheese but pretty decent. The breadsticks are like 18 inches long. Open late.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Slice

You got to check out the specialty pies period they are unbelievable if you go in on Mondays half price as well. Try The Bootlegger and add crumbled sausage, trust me

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5