Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple
914 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 744-0491
Customers' Favorites
Half Half and Half
Goodfellas Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
The Bootlegger
Lunch Special
Cheese Bread
Cheese Pizza
Extra Sauce
Pesto Bread
Breadstick
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The pepperoni was good. Can’t say it’s the best pizza I’ve ever had, but it’s so far been the best NY style I’ve had since moving back to Indianapolis. The inside is really tiny, we wanted to eat inside but wanted a whole pie so we had to borrow the establishment’s counter to hold the box. 3 of us ate a slice there and it just seemed cramped, so I would recommend carry out only from this place, but it’s definitely worth a stop if you’re in the mood for pizza.
We come here whenever we're just wanting a slice of pizza and it's late at night. Used to love their pizza. The quality has changed, though, like maybe the dough? It's just not the same and it's not an improvement.
You May Also Like
Union Jack Pub - 921 Broad Ripple Ave
![]()
Pubs, Pizza, British, Vegan, Vegetarian
Thieves - 915 Broad Ripple Ave
![]()
Bar, Cocktail Bar
Sushi Bar - 911 Broad Ripple Ave
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian
UPDATE:If Tony isn't there...leave. Last 3 orders have all been...