Goodfellas Pizzeria - Broad Ripple
914 Broad Ripple Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 744-0491
Customers' Favorites
Half Half and Half
Goodfellas Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
The Bootlegger
Lunch Special
Cheese Bread
Cheese Pizza
Extra Sauce
Pesto Bread
Breadstick
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We visited from out of town 2 weekends ago. One of the best experiences I’ve ever had in a small restaurant. Amazing food! Extraordinary staff members who were some of the most pleasant staff I’ve encountered in the food industry in a long time. 5 stars all the way!!
This location is incredibly small. The food is amazing. The man today put 3 pieces of pizza and a breadstick with 3 cheese sauces in 1 small box, making it incredibly messy and hard to eat in the car.
Food is always a 5.
Need to expand customer section of this store.
Customer service today was a 3.
Food is always a 5.
Need to expand customer section of this store.
Customer service today was a 3.
This is a decent place to go if you’re craving a slice a pizza. I’m new to Indiana. I’m an Italian American from NY so I have high standards for pizza. In NY there a “mom and pop” owned pizzerias all over. Here, it’s all franchises so you have to take your expectations. I like how large the slices are, the cheese is fine, but the sauce is a bit tart for my liking. I prefer a s sweet tomato sauce! The pizzeria itself appeared clean and the worker was friendly, so I’d...
You May Also Like
Union Jack Pub - 921 Broad Ripple Ave
![]()
Pubs, Pizza, British, Vegan, Vegetarian
Thieves - 915 Broad Ripple Ave
![]()
Bar, Cocktail Bar
Sushi Bar - 911 Broad Ripple Ave
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian