Gordons Milkshake Bar

865 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 453-1360

Recent Reviews

Sort by
William Schwecke

Solid Spot to hit up after a nice dinner on mass ave.
Shakes are insane, so save room or share it.
Service was good. Staff is nice.
Thanks Aden

William Glaser

good shakes

Jayanna

Aden is very helpful, he was a nice gentleman and helped us pick chooses we was first time customers :) yall should come check the place out lots of different options & And the workers are very nice !!! 10/10 recommendations!! Very clean and organized in here :) even a place to sit inside !:)

Anthony Pan

Good spot with good prices for cold treats. Got ice cream cones tonight, will be back for milkshakes soon enough.

Madison Wilson

Great milkshakes!

Chelsea

The Chocolaterie Milkshake 0/10
I'm not a person who wastes food, but I could not eat this. It literally tasted like plastic and I couldn't even taste the ice cream itself. The cake was dry and also had a plastic taste to it. I can't believe we had to spend $13 just to throw it away. Super disappointed..

Jo Anderson

We had a weird day where all our plans fell through and were looking for a stop on our way home. I wanted a milkshake and my husband needed food. My mint shake was AMAZING! He got a combo with a vanilla shake and a loaded hot dog.

Anne Hardwick

Delicious milkshakes with friendly service. We tried the Camp Fire S'mores and Peanut Butter Brownie. Yum!

Dequincy Bibbs

If you want some good ice cream this is the spot, stop in and cool off your day

Liza Poor

this is an amazing little ice cream shop definitely some of the best ice cream i’ve had 10/10 would recommend checking it out if you’re in the area

Zac Crawford

This place has a very unique menu

Seth Burns

Great milkshakes with a good selection of choices.

dana h

The milkshakes are good. But for $13 each, the service needs to better. Staff was rude, seemed like they didn’t want to be there, and our milkshakes took a long time.

Heather Kasten

My daughter and I were looking for a unique place to get desert this evening. We found Gordon's Milkshake Bar where the milkshakes are thick, delicious, and topped with a whole slice of pie and topped with whipped cream then sprinkled with cookie crumbs!! It looks so pretty we had a hard time destroying it to eat it! But such a delicious treat!!
I customized mine Vanilla shake with peanut butter mixed in and New York Cheesecake on top and my daughter had the Cookies and Cream milkshake with Cookie Cream Pie on top!! YUMMY 😋🤤
Service was great as well!!!

Michele Zielinski

Not good. My family loves milk shakes. We ordered 3 shakes. They all looked good but they all had this odd fishy taste. The chocolate was the worst of them. When we asked the server, she said they were made with oat milk. Where does it say that on the menu?!?!?First, we didn’t specify we wanted oat milk and second, I’ve had oat milk yogurt and ice cream - it didn’t taste anything like these milkshakes. We spent almost $40 and had to throw them away. Disappointed.

Loading...