My fiance and I came in after a doctors appointment and it was AMAZING we got a Wilbur's Ham and a Old School Mr. Turkey. I'm a picky eater and my fiance is particular about his sandwiches and we were not disappointed. Location is close to the interstate to get us back home and it was easy on the wallet as well. If you are in the area and want to get some good grub this is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Turkey Dressed Old School
maguette m.
Went for the first time after seeing on facebook! I can eat here almost everyday! So good and staff is absolutely amazing!!!
Misty Welch
Got the hot ham & cheese plus a Philly steak. Simply amazing. We drove all the way from BLOOMINGTON & it was well worth it! My husband and son, whom is in a wheelchair, went in. Everyone was extremely respectful and accommodating to our son. Thanks for a great experience!
Nice breeze rolling through. Sandwich was excellent and the brownie was even better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownies
Philip A.
Best sandwich in Indy by far! The staff is very nice and it's just overall a great place to grab lunch!
Kim Everidge
Taste NOTHING like it use too! Totally different now that new owners took over! Overpriced and nasty!
Kalista Q
Great food Great service
kathy Logue
Just not the same as it was before. Always got hot ham and cheese sub. But know it just doesn't taste the same even if get the old
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Jeremiah Marshall
Take a risk! This place is wonderful! Don’t know what you want? Get the hoagie! Fountain red cream soda is served here too!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free options
Had a three day weekend and decided to spend it in Indy. We had some restaurants set in stone for the weekend, but had not settled on Friday's meal. Was kinda craving Mexican. Kinda craving a good sub. Not a chain sub. A good ol' freshly baked, freshly made sub. So we did some research and found Greiner's. It's the oldest sub shop in Indy. Pulling into the parking lot, we were a little doubtful. It's clean looking but... nothing fancy. I've found out that's where you tend to find the best food. So... in we went. The line wasn't extremely long when we entered, but there are so many options on the menu that it does take some time to order and get your food. Don't get me wrong. They don't mess around. They know what they are doing and the food is well put together. The man behind the counter was larger than life. 6'7" and a personality that added flavor of its own. A mother in front of us asked what was on a certain salad. He told her. She asked the difference between that salad and another. He replied "no meat!" She pondered a moment and... ordered a sub. In a VERY good natured way, he roasted her! "You mean to tell me you asked all of those questions about salads only to order a sub?!?" Her husband was laughing, she was laughing. He ended their transaction saying he just couldn't pass up the opportunity. It was all in good fun. Being shy, I knew I wasn't going to ask questions! Ha! I opted for the 8" Hot Toddy while spouse ordered the 8" Philly Cheesesteak. Then we saw they had cheese fries. We stupidly ordered two orders. The Hot Toddy has capicola, turkey, ham, pepperoni, with chipotle sauce slathered on one side of the bun and mayo on the other, cheddar cheese, jalapeño cheese, lettuce, tomato (ordered mine without), banana peppers, with salt and a light drizzle of olive oil. I added fresh jalapeños. The Philly Cheesesteak had steak and cheese with your choice of toppings. Both are toasted. Let me tell you... we struck gold! Hands down the best sub I've ever had. So full of meat that it began to push through the underside. I couldn't get enough. The flavors are perfect! Everything stands out. It's hard to put into words how great the Hot Toddy is! Spouse loved the cheesesteak sandwich, but one bite of my sub and we both decided we will be back for the Hot Toddy. The question is 8" or 16"?? The loaded cheese fries were huge! Came with liquid cheddar cheese, shredded cheddar cheese, bacon and a dollop of sour cream. They were delicious. But... our stomachs were begging for mercy and we couldn't get them all down. This place is small, but it packs a huge punch! We left so impressed and excited to go back. ASAP! Would HIGHLY recommend!!! You won't regret it!
Dal Way
My folks and I drove from Fortville and Tipton to try out Grieners for the first time it was fantastic! The entire staff was great, especially the manager, Lisa! She was hyper friendly and welcoming and had great energy!Our subs were HUGE and delicious! The meats and cheeses are cut thick and piled on!All around a great experience and well worth the drive to get there! Thank you Lisa, we had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownies, Mr Turkey Dressed Old School
Joe Winegard
The staff is courteous and helpful. The loaded fries are off the hook!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
kevin hoovler
Food was made to order and was spot on. Staff made it even better with their interaction and humor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak
Dal W.
My folks and I traveled from Fortville and Tipton to try out Greiner's today. The subs were huge and delicious! The meats and cheeses were cut thick and really piled on!! All of the staff were crazy friendly, but especially Lisa who was extra welcoming and seemed to really love feeding her guests! It's a small, quaint place with a very personable staff and fantastic food! Completely worth the drive!
N&
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
My fiance and I came in after a doctors appointment and it was AMAZING we got a Wilbur's Ham and a Old School Mr. Turkey. I'm a picky eater and my fiance is particular about his sandwiches and we were not disappointed. Location is close to the interstate to get us back home and it was easy on the wallet as well. If you are in the area and want to get some good grub this is it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mr Turkey Dressed Old School
Went for the first time after seeing on facebook! I can eat here almost everyday! So good and staff is absolutely amazing!!!
Got the hot ham & cheese plus a Philly steak. Simply amazing. We drove all the way from BLOOMINGTON & it was well worth it! My husband and son, whom is in a wheelchair, went in. Everyone was extremely respectful and accommodating to our son. Thanks for a great experience!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Brownie, Philly Cheese Steak
Nice breeze rolling through. Sandwich was excellent and the brownie was even better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownies
Best sandwich in Indy by far! The staff is very nice and it's just overall a great place to grab lunch!
Taste NOTHING like it use too! Totally different now that new owners took over! Overpriced and nasty!
Great food Great service
Just not the same as it was before. Always got hot ham and cheese sub. But know it just doesn't taste the same even if get the old
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Take a risk! This place is wonderful! Don’t know what you want? Get the hoagie! Fountain red cream soda is served here too!Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Had a three day weekend and decided to spend it in Indy. We had some restaurants set in stone for the weekend, but had not settled on Friday's meal. Was kinda craving Mexican. Kinda craving a good sub. Not a chain sub. A good ol' freshly baked, freshly made sub. So we did some research and found Greiner's. It's the oldest sub shop in Indy. Pulling into the parking lot, we were a little doubtful. It's clean looking but... nothing fancy. I've found out that's where you tend to find the best food. So... in we went. The line wasn't extremely long when we entered, but there are so many options on the menu that it does take some time to order and get your food. Don't get me wrong. They don't mess around. They know what they are doing and the food is well put together. The man behind the counter was larger than life. 6'7" and a personality that added flavor of its own. A mother in front of us asked what was on a certain salad. He told her. She asked the difference between that salad and another. He replied "no meat!" She pondered a moment and... ordered a sub. In a VERY good natured way, he roasted her! "You mean to tell me you asked all of those questions about salads only to order a sub?!?" Her husband was laughing, she was laughing. He ended their transaction saying he just couldn't pass up the opportunity. It was all in good fun. Being shy, I knew I wasn't going to ask questions! Ha! I opted for the 8" Hot Toddy while spouse ordered the 8" Philly Cheesesteak. Then we saw they had cheese fries. We stupidly ordered two orders. The Hot Toddy has capicola, turkey, ham, pepperoni, with chipotle sauce slathered on one side of the bun and mayo on the other, cheddar cheese, jalapeño cheese, lettuce, tomato (ordered mine without), banana peppers, with salt and a light drizzle of olive oil. I added fresh jalapeños. The Philly Cheesesteak had steak and cheese with your choice of toppings. Both are toasted. Let me tell you... we struck gold! Hands down the best sub I've ever had. So full of meat that it began to push through the underside. I couldn't get enough. The flavors are perfect! Everything stands out. It's hard to put into words how great the Hot Toddy is! Spouse loved the cheesesteak sandwich, but one bite of my sub and we both decided we will be back for the Hot Toddy. The question is 8" or 16"?? The loaded cheese fries were huge! Came with liquid cheddar cheese, shredded cheddar cheese, bacon and a dollop of sour cream. They were delicious. But... our stomachs were begging for mercy and we couldn't get them all down. This place is small, but it packs a huge punch! We left so impressed and excited to go back. ASAP! Would HIGHLY recommend!!! You won't regret it!
My folks and I drove from Fortville and Tipton to try out Grieners for the first time it was fantastic! The entire staff was great, especially the manager, Lisa! She was hyper friendly and welcoming and had great energy!Our subs were HUGE and delicious! The meats and cheeses are cut thick and piled on!All around a great experience and well worth the drive to get there! Thank you Lisa, we had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brownies, Mr Turkey Dressed Old School
The staff is courteous and helpful. The loaded fries are off the hook!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was made to order and was spot on. Staff made it even better with their interaction and humor.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak
My folks and I traveled from Fortville and Tipton to try out Greiner's today. The subs were huge and delicious! The meats and cheeses were cut thick and really piled on!! All of the staff were crazy friendly, but especially Lisa who was extra welcoming and seemed to really love feeding her guests! It's a small, quaint place with a very personable staff and fantastic food! Completely worth the drive!