HotBox Pizza

5220 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis
(317) 661-3398

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer Souder

It was my daughter’s birthday 2/6/2026 and we were having a family celebration. She ordered online for pick up, the order was 3 pizzas and bread sticks. Said it would be ready in 20 minutes so when she got there, they said her order was never processed and to wait. She waited inside the building for an additional HOUR continuously asking for updates before an employee suggested she just cancel her order. No sorry. No how can we make this right. Absolutely no consideration for a paying customer. Not only was that horrible customer service, it upset her on her birthday and we had a house full of hungry family ( 5 of whom are kids age 12-2, who were very hungry and cranky)
She supposedly will get a refund, she is a first responder as well, who helps this community and this happens. Now four local families will never return to this pizza establishment and we will advise others to not eat there as well. Apparently they very incompetent and cannot handle servicing our community!

Service: 1

C Matthews

Love their breadsticks with cheese, they have the best buttermilk ranch dressing, their salads are always super fresh. And their pizza is wonderful.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stacia Jordan

BEST BREADSTICKS IN THE STATE! REMINDS ME SO MUCH OF VP GAS STATION BREADSTICKS IF ANYONE REMEMBERS OR LOVED THOSE!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cameron Norton

Hotbox on Southport Rd is my go to pizza spot, great service and great food every single time! I will be loyal to this pizza spot as long as I live in the area. All other pizza shops to don’t compare to this one. 1 million out of 10 experience every time I come in. Thank you guys 🙏🏼

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad, Stix, Breadstix, Spicy Pepperoni, Pepperoni Pizza, Fall Pie, Heavy Veggie Pie, Summer Pie, Half Veggie Half Chicken Alfredo on Thin Crust, Breadsticks with Cheese Sauce, Wings, Porky the Pie X-Large 16

Lindsey Cherry

I ordered pizza on 10/25. There was a staple in my pizza. Luckily I didn’t swallow it. I noticed something sharp in my mouth and pulled out the staple. When I called on 10/26 to explain what happened I didn’t even receive an apology. I was told that it was “probably” an accident. I hope it was an accident! The person on the phone didn’t seem to care at all. I will never order from this location again. Unacceptable!

Food: 1

Service: 1

Kennedey Freeman

We love their pizza and bread sticks but wonder why the rewards aren't valid at their greenwood or Southport locations? We recently moved and those are the closest to us now.

Peggy Sahm

Carry out

Food: 5

Glenda Foster

Made me the wrong pizza, no biggie it happens. This location went above and beyond apologizing and making it right! Appreciate the great service and food is always amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jewell Ronnice

No sauce so just bread and cheese for $18 never again will I go here WHERE IS THE SAUCE? Is it in the room with us

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Nickcola Dickey

Work had given me a coupon for a free large pizza. Never been here so we went in person to order. Very clean atmosphere with employees who greet you with a smile. We ordered carry out but there is seating available to dine in. We ordered spicy pepperoni and our 17 year old said it is very tasty. We also ordered a large veggie pizza which is also delicious with a luscious amount of veggies. Crust on this pizza is not one you will leave on your plate. The employees were attentive and informative when we asked how long it would take. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie Barnes

Different but pretty good little spicy for me, but pizza was nice and hot

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Victor S

Their popeye pizza is our house favorite. The staff is usually teens in pajama pants and headphones, but dont let that drive you away. These friendly teens have their pizza game tight.
Definitely will order with them again, two thumbs up.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

kaitlyn wilson

This was my first time going to Hot Box Pizza and it definitely won’t be my last! All the workers were extremely friendly and had great customer service. They made the whole experience wonderful! The food was also incredible and had great flavor! 10/10 recommend this place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cameron Taylor

HotBox Pizza always hits the spot. My go-to order might sound a little unusual: BBQ sauce instead of red, with chicken, pepperoni, and crumbled sausage. But it’s insanely good. The sweet and smoky BBQ with all that savory meat just works so well together.

And the brownie? Absolute perfection. Gooey, rich, and easily one of the best desserts you can get anywhere, not just for a pizza place.

Highly recommend trying both if you haven’t already.

Food: 5

Shayiona Bryant

Food is always hot and ready and it comes out pretty quick and they’re very respectful!

Loading...