Jimmy John's

5550 W 86th St #101, Indianapolis
(317) 337-9183

Recent Reviews

Michael Twyford

Ordered drive thru pick-up, decided to go inside and grab the order. It was already ready to go and the staff was friendly and fun to chat with!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Thinny Chips

A OT

I ordered 1 sandwich .... with 1 instruction. No Mayo. I was the only customer. They had multiple employees. They couldn't handle the task. I was excited to have a Jimmy John's across the street from my hotel these next 8 weeks. Sad face.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

edward fulton

Good food, that came fast. Not to much lettuce this time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Dee Chat

All I gotta say is BEN was awesome!! As I am a OTR TRUCK DRIVER this man went above and beyond for me. Might not mean much.. but BEN THANK YOU BROTHER FOR making a bomb sandwich and telling me about the rewards program.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Diana S.

Stay away from this place it's the worst, the employees laugh in your face when you ask for something extra on your sandwich. They think that we weren't going to pay for extra toppings. Those ppl are rude.

John Wan

Solid food place. Delivery made it expensive as it cost an additional $4 fee on top of tips. Hunter's club sandwich itself was great. I like that it was highly customizable and could add a lot of extras for free.Dietary restrictions: Fully customizable menu and ingredients.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Club Tuna, Avocado Spread, Totally Tuna, Tuna Salad, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Roast Beef

Imari Powell

Everyone in here is always so nice and entertaining lol lots of personality at this

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maria Torres Fasano

You deserve to be happy we are all humans , are frustrated because of a Break-up then you can use this to attract that happiness into your life. It brings back your lover, and help solve broken marriages. Life is too short to be unhappy. Think about that . You deserve utmost happiness and love. Note: this is totally harmless and have no side effects.this is the solution Whats-App +2347059387282 E-mail: [email protected]

Mande Watkins

Changed my drink at the window, and the server was super kind about it even though I had anxiety about asking lol

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chris Conway

Why do I get sick every time I eat here?The taste isn’t bad, and is not a bad sub overall. I use to think JJ was top 5 at one point, then I had DiBella’s subs, Jersey, Mike’s, PennStation, and Sub 8. Wow was I mistaken.Chain food done poorly. Is the meat frozen? Do they use old meat? Why does the bacon always taste like rubber? I would rather you be freaky slow with high quality food then freak fast to my mouth then out my a**. ?The bread is ? and is why they got two stars. The chips are good also.Won’t be back.

Christopher Conway

Why do I get sick every time I eat here?The taste isn’t bad, and is not a bad sub overall. I use to think JJ was top 5 at one point, then I had DiBella’s subs, Jersey, Mike’s, PennStation, and Sub 8. Wow was I mistaken.Chain food done poorly. Is the meat frozen? Do they use old meat? Why does the bacon always taste like rubber? I would rather you be freaky slow with high quality food then freak fast to my mouth then out my a**. ?The bread is ? and is why they got two stars. The chips are good also.Won’t be back.

Tammy Barillas

Attaching The sandwiches I received this evening. Called and spoke with a very defensive manager. I just didn't want to pay for this, was willing to return sandwiches. He argued that he made the sandwiches himself and before sending photos he mentioned that he could “see with the turkey Tom why I would say that”…? which is even worse in my opinion. Why send it off for delivery then? He would not give me anyone’s names or emails to contact so here I am, sharing them for him so he can hopefully see them.

Tammy E.

The sandwiches I received. Is this a joke? Called and spoke with a very defensive manager. I just didn't want to pay for this, I was willing to return sandwiches. He would not give me a contact for a direct report and argued that he made the sandwiches himself. Which is even worse in my opinion.

Robert Lappin

Staff here are awesome! I like not having to make a bunch of decisions :-) ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

robert bruder

Freaky Fast. Great sandwich bread.

Load More