J's Lobster & Fish Market

906 Carrollton Ave #370, Indianapolis
(855) 562-7655

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Juspunjabi11

Horrible. Just moved here from Connecticut and our seafood is a world of a difference than this. Understand it says New England; but this is not New England. Got the shits after eating this horrible Lobster

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Aryanna Wilson

The only meat found in the lobster roll purchased from their food truck was imitation. The shrimp was bland and the only seasoning found could be referred to as a dusting of more nothingness.

Food: 1

Megan Schmeerbauch

Lobster bisque was just orange water- with ONE piece if crab. For $14. So so so terrible!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Tina Shipe

Ordered the blue crab roll. The roll was just the crab, no mayo, lettuce, or butter. So dry!!! I should have taken back, but for $22, I got dry crab, old chips, and a tiny slaw.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Lanie W. Carter

I don’t know how this place could get less than 5 stars. I’ve had a bunch of lobster in my life and this was some of the best I’ve ever had. So good we came back again the next day bc I wanted it again. Highly recommend the lobster roll.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cathy Zhao

I had my first fake lobster roll here in my life. There was only two tiny pieces of meat were from lobster. The rest was mushed stuff, like the fake crab meat made from fish?

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Elizabeth S

Quality has really gone down. I ordered the crab Mac and cheese. There used to be a lot of seafood in the Mac and cheese but now you have to search for it. Noddles aren't as cheesy or spiced as they used to be. Really disappointed because I drove across town for this.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Matt Moermond

Staff was fantastic, lobster roll tasted microwaved. Had a weird texture to it and still had random cold spots.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Polly Hoffman

I ordered the blue crab roll and my boyfriend got the hot honey fried lobster roll. His was just okay, at least edible, but mine was absolutely awful. I'm from Maryland, and whatever that was, it was not crab. It had a bizarre, artificial taste that was so off-putting I had to scrape it out of the roll entirely. I ended up just eating the bread, chips, and coleslaw. The total for this meal, with tip, was $57 What a joke!
If you’re trying to decide where to eat in this food court, I highly recommend looking up reviews first. I usually do, but skipped it this time and seriously regretted it. Do yourself a favor and choose wisely. Skip this place!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

L Brooks

I do not recommend.
The fish sandwich was really bad, you can do better at home with some frozen fish. I have had the lobster roll in the past and it does not meet expectations for the price. Definitely not worth the trip. Considering the location and foot traffic here, you would expect better food. They really need to revisit the menu selection and improve on quality of food.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Haylee Jane Monteiro

I was really intrigued by all the lobster items over here and husband really wanted to try the Lobster Mac & Cheese so that's what we got.

The mac and cheese itself was quite creamy and cheesy, but I wasn't a fan of how the lobster went with it.
But I think that's just me the topic of seafood related pastas.
Husband definitely enjoyed this though!

Food: 4

Service: 5

Jennifer Thornburg

I had the crab cakes. They tasted fishy and had no flavor. I couldn't finish them. The hush puppies tasted pretty good, but we're overcooked on the outside.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Tokin Phyr

Lobster grilled cheese had no flavor but butter from the bread. Barely any cheese, and the lobster was bland. Fries were soggy, even though it was fresh, hushpuppies were burnt and dry. I hate cole slaw and it was ok... so slight bonus for that. But when asked if i could swap the cole slaw, the lady said no. Worst $40 I spent on a lunch. Won't recommend or send anyone this way.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Josette MPÇ

I got the Works Roll with fries. For $45 it was ok. My cold sandwich was put on top of hot fries in a plastic container. It took me about 20 min to get home. Bread was soggy by the time I got to it. I couldn't tell if it was really toasted but it was buttery.
Shrimp & lobster on sandwich were good but crab was bland. There was no Old Bay seasoning (or any other seasoning). Sandwich also had too much mayo. Bread was the only thing with flavor.

Price did NOT match quality.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Swayze S.

Made a $100 mistake eating at this food truck at Daniel’s Vineyard yesterday. $24 for a tiny, stringy, borderline inedible lobster rolls. Pieces of shell in the sandwich too. The lobster Mac and cheese was dry and tasetless. This place is a JOKE for what they are charging vs. what they are serving. Will never eat it again, you have been warned!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Loading...