J's Lobster & Fish Market

906 Carrollton Ave #370, Indianapolis
(855) 562-7655

Recent Reviews

Jerri S.

NOT cheap, but yummy food with large servings! They are located in Garage Food Hall @ Bottleworks, so everyone can select their own genre of food.

William Turner

Gave me one piece of lobster for a hot honey fried lobster roll ($24). I asked if they could give me more and if not I would like a refund. The lady told me absolutely not to both. The other options may be good here but do NOT order the hot honey fried lobster roll.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

R G

It's my first time visiting Indiana. After 8 hours of driving , I was looking forward to grub on something. This place definitely hit the spot! Food quality and service were phenomenal and friendly.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Will T.

Do NOT order the Hot Honey Fried lobster special ($24)! They give you one piece of lobster that fills no more than a quarter of a lobster roll bun. If you ask for more, they tell you sorry that's all that's included and if you ask for a refund they don't give it to you.

Tyler Gordon

$30 … tried it and not doing this place again lol

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Shawn H.

Clam Chowder and Hush Puppies were solid for Midwest option. Would come back, didn't try other options

Lona D.

My daughter and I stopped in the Garage to grab some dinner. She and I both got the Works Roll. It came with a side of chips and a small thing of slaw. Yes, it was pricey, but it was so good and so full of seafood. I was full the rest of the night. The service was pretty fast, just long enough to prepare the roll, and friendly. There was plenty of seating and they keep the common area clean. Plenty of paid parking outside. I'll be back for that roll!

Katherine A.

My granddaughter and I had lunch at this popular little seafood stand inside The Garage Food Hall today. I had a bowl of the clam chowder and she had the kid's mac and cheese meal with French fries (yes, carbs with a side of carbs). Our clerk was friendly and the food came out quickly. The kid's meal was awesome. The fries tasted fresh cut and delicious. They were hot with a delicate spice. Great fries. My cup of clam chowder was not hot. So I took it back and they happily heated it up. The chowder was thick and creamy with lots of clams. The chowder was served with oyster crackers. As a seafood lover, I'll be back.

Michele V.

Did you say-clam chowder. Cold, cold day so perfect for some chowdah. It was pretty good, but missing some chewy clams (needed more). Fish sandwich was hot and crispy. Tartar sauce was tangy and sweet. Very very tasty treat. Worth the price of $26.42 for 1 person??? Not sure.

Nicole Means

What we ordered was okay. I will definitely try more of the menu. I really enjoyed the hot honey lobster, just not the pickles. The default chips that come with the meal are unnecessary, or at least choose 1 type to serve. The crab in the nachos were cold & too many peppers (which were soggy). Lobster Rangoon was not the best but the side sauce helped a bit. I love seafood, so I will give another try at something else, but overall it has my attention.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Cami Stanley

Recently visited J’s Lobster truck. I waited 1 hour and 30 minutes for my food (this is not an exaggeration. Got there at 6pm. Got my food at 7:30pm). Paid $24 for one lobster roll. The food itself was actually very tasty, but left me still hungry. For $24, the lobster roll did not fill me up at all. The portions weren’t worth the wait or the money. My friend got the lobster Mac n cheese. It’s just buttered noddles with cheese sauce poured on top. It was a liquid, soup consistency. Not at all a “true” Mac n cheese, just soupy noodles. I left disappointed.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

PoPo Time (Josh)

If you want good fries then this is the place to be.I had the lobster roll and the rest of my wife’s blue crab roll. I can tell you I have had better and wouldn’t order it again. The coleslaw was warm and bland. I will definitely not eat here

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 4

Miste Kirkendall

Got a lobster roll to take to my son and they package it so it wouldn’t be nasty when I got it home. It was amazing. Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll

Suzanne Mann

Had a lobster roll, fried fish sandwich and mac & cheese with lobster at the Food Truck in Bloomington tonight. Not special.Lobster was previously frozen so dry and stringy, portion of lobster was skimpy on both sandwich and particularly on Mac & Cheese, not as pictured on website, hardly filling. I'm a Maine native, standards are based on experience. If you're a Midwesterner and have never had lobster, try it, it scores a C.Waiting in line to order and waiting in line for order pick-up took an hour.I was determined to give this a try, once and done.

Food: 2

Service: 4

Luba Simms

The food was terrible. I got the lobster roll and it was over cooked and looked like tuna meat and they gave me old chips they were soggy. For $20 something I will not recommend at all.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More