Lick Ice Cream Indy

I rarely hate ice cream, but how can you produce Key Lime pie that is flavorless unless you're making it badly? I threw it out before I left the garage...

blueberry lavender changed my life

Lick icecream is worth the hype. It’s one of the shops located inside The Garage.
I tried their Munchies and Raspberry cheesecake flavours. Raspberry was heavenly.
The texture is so rich and creamy, doing justice to the price being charged.
I look forward to try more of their flavours

Decent price, good quantity, nice flavors

The affogato is soooo good! Perfect afternoon pick me up.

Been going to Lick about 2 years some great ice cream , but recently went there said i wanted “cookie butter” instead of cookie dough. Went back to get the right one i wanted and had to pay once again .. ima regular & i tip sometimes and on top of the expensive pint prices , i think she could have given me the right one & not charge me an extra $12 … lost a customer 👍🏽

I don't remember the flavors I tried, but there was 1 that stood out above the rest. It was a very unique combo, that I haven't seen at other shops. Also, great location!

Buttery Goodness
The Honey Butter Pecan ice cream was an absolute treat. Smooth and buttery with crunchy, caramelized pecans—it felt like a cozy, autumn dessert.

I've been a long time customer and I'm always surprised by all the unique flavors they come up with. The blueberry corn cookie is amazing! I try to get an ice cream cake for my husband's birthday every year. It's the best ice cream we've ever had and it's the best in Indy.

Their brown butter cookie dough ice cream is the best ice cream we have EVER HAD

Freaking yummy ice cream, at a great price. I got dairy free just because I liked the flavor option and it was actually so good!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vegan Rocky Road

I always look forward to visiting this shop to explore their creative and unique flavors. The staff is patient and allows us to take our time sampling different options. The latest flavor I tried, Earl Gray Peppermint, was absolutely delightful! Highly recommend stopping by to see what new flavors they’ve come up with!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sprinkles to die for! Super nice staff. The owner was even working the evening I went with my family and she gave me sprinkles with my ice cream and I am not exaggerating when I say the sprinkles were magical and made my day. Will definitely be back next time we're in town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

They got my order wrong. The vegan marshmallow tastes like chalk. It is way over priced too.should have gone to the grocery store and bought Ben and Jerry’s.would have gotten more for the price too.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Environment was welcoming and the associate was patient - thank you. I really enjoyed the Brown Butter Cookie Dough. The other flavor in the cup was the vegan Cookie Butter.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cups & Cones