I ordered a pumpkin cake for my sons 7th birthday on Halloween. Mama P is amazing. She maintained contact with me the whole time with everything. Any questions I had she answered and she made me feel like family. The cake was a huge hit. The actual white cake part was delicious and moist. I had just enough with 1 extra piece for me left over. I will always go with Mama P.
Interviewer
Gave a few short instructions and the cake was exactly as I pictured it! It was a beautiful cake made in less than a week's notice and I was extremely happy with the results.
Morgan Donovan
I love eating here. Service is typically great. Food is similar to a cafe in Indianapolis I liked.
Suan Cmu
VeganSuch a good experience on a short notice! I ordered a vegan cake for my son’s birthday and I knew it was such short notice, Mama p exceeded my expectations and made a beautiful cake that everyone couldn’t get enough of! I cant believe she made it like I dreamed of and more! The new store isn’t open yet, so I met her in front of the store, the cake was delicious, and got home in excellent shape. I recommend Mama P for her professionalism, kindness and delicious vegan cake and desserts! I will order another cake in all my family’s upcoming birthdays! I tried attaching pictures but couldn’t :/
Kaitlyn Christian
Best vegan birthday cake I have come across in Indy!
Brittany Baird
This was by far the best cake we’ve had! It was beautiful and delicious! I lived in a different state and she was so accommodating and helpful, excellent customer service. Thank you Mama P for making my sons birthday a hit!
Denise Taylor
Delicious, beautiful cakes. She's talented and professional.
Kim Saunders
I had the great fortune of ordering a caramel cake for my husband‘s birthday from Mama P‘s it was absolutely amazing all my guests enjoyed it and we will definitely be back for more goodies!!! Thank you so much
Reezad. Masmas
I just loved all of their Cupcakes and cookies.Very Delicious!!!!!!
Maria K.
I'm not sure if this is the same Mama p. Bakery that the reviews are talking about. Maybe it moved somewhere else bc the Mama p I went to yesterday. On Georgetown Rd ...was an all Mexican shop. There was no cake slices only a few in the cases and no wedding, or birthday cake. EVERYTHING!!! Was in Spanish The Lady even said to me (.I Don't Speak No English!!! ) I have Nothing against Mexicans or there establishment. But if you're going to advertise tell your customers The Truth.
This place has very tasty treats and the owner is so friendly! Beautiful cakes on display
angelina e
I believe this is the number 1 bakery in the city, she even has you covered if you are vegan. Mama P does custom cakes and was warm and friendly over the phone. She made us a vegan ice cream cake with 4 layers. It was impressively tall and so pretty. I wish I had taken a photo but we forgot because we were too excited to eat it. The cake part was marble and it was THE BEST marble cake I've ever had in my life. Usually marble cake isn't chocolatey enough but this one was the perfect blend of chocolate and vanilla flavors. Even my husband who is a pie man couldn't stop eating it. The shop is very cute and clean as well. The gentleman working there and his daughter were both super nice and did everything possible to be helpful. I am a difficult customer and I only give 5 star reviews if a place really stands out. Go have some cookies or try some cake, you won't be disappointed.
Greg Clark
I special ordered 2 sweet potato pies for a cookout. Mama P could not have been any nicer or any more accommodating. The pies were a huge hit. Probably the best I've ever had. Two thumbs up from me!
B & L Robinson
Thank you Mama P's for making my mom's birthday so wonderful! That lemon meringue pie brought a smile to her face that I haven't seen in a long time. I will be back!!!
I ordered a pumpkin cake for my sons 7th birthday on Halloween. Mama P is amazing. She maintained contact with me the whole time with everything. Any questions I had she answered and she made me feel like family. The cake was a huge hit. The actual white cake part was delicious and moist. I had just enough with 1 extra piece for me left over. I will always go with Mama P.
Gave a few short instructions and the cake was exactly as I pictured it! It was a beautiful cake made in less than a week's notice and I was extremely happy with the results.
I love eating here. Service is typically great. Food is similar to a cafe in Indianapolis I liked.
VeganSuch a good experience on a short notice! I ordered a vegan cake for my son’s birthday and I knew it was such short notice, Mama p exceeded my expectations and made a beautiful cake that everyone couldn’t get enough of! I cant believe she made it like I dreamed of and more! The new store isn’t open yet, so I met her in front of the store, the cake was delicious, and got home in excellent shape. I recommend Mama P for her professionalism, kindness and delicious vegan cake and desserts! I will order another cake in all my family’s upcoming birthdays! I tried attaching pictures but couldn’t :/
Best vegan birthday cake I have come across in Indy!
This was by far the best cake we’ve had! It was beautiful and delicious! I lived in a different state and she was so accommodating and helpful, excellent customer service. Thank you Mama P for making my sons birthday a hit!
Delicious, beautiful cakes. She's talented and professional.
I had the great fortune of ordering a caramel cake for my husband‘s birthday from Mama P‘s it was absolutely amazing all my guests enjoyed it and we will definitely be back for more goodies!!! Thank you so much
I just loved all of their Cupcakes and cookies.Very Delicious!!!!!!
I'm not sure if this is the same Mama p. Bakery that the reviews are talking about. Maybe it moved somewhere else bc the Mama p I went to yesterday. On Georgetown Rd ...was an all Mexican shop. There was no cake slices only a few in the cases and no wedding, or birthday cake. EVERYTHING!!! Was in Spanish The Lady even said to me (.I Don't Speak No English!!! ) I have Nothing against Mexicans or there establishment. But if you're going to advertise tell your customers The Truth.
Restaurantji Recommends
Tastes great
This place has very tasty treats and the owner is so friendly! Beautiful cakes on display
I believe this is the number 1 bakery in the city, she even has you covered if you are vegan. Mama P does custom cakes and was warm and friendly over the phone. She made us a vegan ice cream cake with 4 layers. It was impressively tall and so pretty. I wish I had taken a photo but we forgot because we were too excited to eat it. The cake part was marble and it was THE BEST marble cake I've ever had in my life. Usually marble cake isn't chocolatey enough but this one was the perfect blend of chocolate and vanilla flavors. Even my husband who is a pie man couldn't stop eating it. The shop is very cute and clean as well. The gentleman working there and his daughter were both super nice and did everything possible to be helpful. I am a difficult customer and I only give 5 star reviews if a place really stands out. Go have some cookies or try some cake, you won't be disappointed.
I special ordered 2 sweet potato pies for a cookout. Mama P could not have been any nicer or any more accommodating. The pies were a huge hit. Probably the best I've ever had. Two thumbs up from me!
Thank you Mama P's for making my mom's birthday so wonderful! That lemon meringue pie brought a smile to her face that I haven't seen in a long time. I will be back!!!