Just had my first baby and the young guy behind the counter Alex, aside from having a wonderful, exceedingly positive and friendly demeanor, actually took the time to notice that I was wearing a hospital badge and congratulated me on my wife for having our baby today.
We’re talking about a kid who can’t be more than 18 or 19, taking the time to tell me, a perfect stranger that he thought I was gonna be a great father. It absolutely blew me away. Pizza looks like a fresh hot pie from New York City.
I even broke my “no tipping for pick up orders” rule bc he made such an impression on me. Perfect end to the best day of my life. 5 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karis Shelburne
Very good while on vacation we decided to stop in here and it was definitely a great choice staff was incredibly friendly and pizza was delicious! This would definitely be our weekly pizza choice if we were local 100/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Gray
Wow. This is an amazing pizza shop. People are so friendly, the pizza is amazing. I can tell that they take their time building your pizza. Toppings are perfectly placed. Cheese and sauce are spot on. It is a thinner pizza, not a deep dish, but if you’re looking for a pizza that is fresh and honest, give them a try.
Eva Rodriguez
Today was my first time that I went with my children after a baseball game.....the excellent service...the OMG pizzas...exactly how we ate it in Brooklyn NY....a delicious cheesecake.. .I plan to return with a great group of friends...100% recommended!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donald Garrett Sr
This was my first time at this pizza place and the people are very nice and polite the pizza is the best.We will definitely be going back.You have to try this place. 10
Lunch special was tasty. Really liked the salad with all of the toppings and ranch. Affordable at $9.99 for a big slice, salad and a drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
gerberbabymom78
…my kids saw this place during our afternoon drive home and asked to stop and try- not only is the staff super friendly, the food is superb!! best pizza I’ve had in indy so far!! the crust is not too thin and not too thick- has that authentic taste!! now on the way home, they always ask to stop- what a wonderful gem we have found ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lien Bui
I’m not a pizza person but I love their pizza, and calzones!! Husband and son always ask to have it anytime they can lol. Recommended to whole family and everyone loves it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
4 Legal
Outstanding! Coming from a pizza snob. So much flavor. The crust is incredible. We will go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elodie Caucheteux
en dehors d un accueil toujours chaleureux des pizzas excellente et un tarif plus qu abordable !
The new York pizza is the worst pizza I've ever had. Paper thin, hard as a rock, sauce was bland and lacking, cheese must not come on pizza here. For the price, plus a delivery fee, plus a tip for the rude driver combined with a 50 minute wait to get a lukewarm pizza, I'm not a happy customer. Whoever is writing reviews must be getting paid or have no idea what pizza should be. I'm guessing friends or relatives. I've had better pizza from the freezer. 35 bucks down the drain.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Andrew Mason
I don't think this place is worth it's hype, went in on Saturday at 2pm. Window and website says pizza by the slice. Went in and there was one person inside eating. Two cold slices of pizza to choose from and they were all dried up and crusty looking. I asked if more pizza was coming out he said the weekend are dead but will take 10 min to make and 10" and up size pizza. We just wanted a slice. I'm sorry but we won't return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Mark Enderle
We were nicely greeted when we first arrived, and a conversation continued all through the transaction of our carry out order. Very nice people. Now, about the large New York Style pepperoni pizza that we ordered. The pizza lacked any taste at all. The sauce and cheese were very bland and the crust was hard and not chewy. A New York style pizza one should be able to fold the slice in half without the crust breaking in half and it should be chewy and not very crunchy. I was not pleased with what I ordered, but settled for it anyway and ate it, as we were traveling across country and it was food in our belly. The reviews fooled me on this place. Nice people, but the pizza is not that good at all.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Sam Kreigh
No flop! And crisp undercarriage. Dave Portnoy would be proud… I recommend you try them out.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lida Constanza Aldana
The best pizza ?in Indy, the staff are very friendly and the place is very clean! ?? #IndyPizza #FriendlyStaff #
Just had my first baby and the young guy behind the counter Alex, aside from having a wonderful, exceedingly positive and friendly demeanor, actually took the time to notice that I was wearing a hospital badge and congratulated me on my wife for having our baby today.
We’re talking about a kid who can’t be more than 18 or 19, taking the time to tell me, a perfect stranger that he thought I was gonna be a great father. It absolutely blew me away. Pizza looks like a fresh hot pie from New York City.
I even broke my “no tipping for pick up orders” rule bc he made such an impression on me. Perfect end to the best day of my life. 5 stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good while on vacation we decided to stop in here and it was definitely a great choice staff was incredibly friendly and pizza was delicious! This would definitely be our weekly pizza choice if we were local 100/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow. This is an amazing pizza shop. People are so friendly, the pizza is amazing. I can tell that they take their time building your pizza. Toppings are perfectly placed. Cheese and sauce are spot on. It is a thinner pizza, not a deep dish, but if you’re looking for a pizza that is fresh and honest, give them a try.
Today was my first time that I went with my children after a baseball game.....the excellent service...the OMG pizzas...exactly how we ate it in Brooklyn NY....a delicious cheesecake.. .I plan to return with a great group of friends...100% recommended!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was my first time at this pizza place and the people are very nice and polite the pizza is the best.We will definitely be going back.You have to try this place. 10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Filled Breadsticks, Stuffed Pizza, Chicken Chef’S Salad
Lunch special was tasty. Really liked the salad with all of the toppings and ranch. Affordable at $9.99 for a big slice, salad and a drink.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
…my kids saw this place during our afternoon drive home and asked to stop and try- not only is the staff super friendly, the food is superb!! best pizza I’ve had in indy so far!! the crust is not too thin and not too thick- has that authentic taste!! now on the way home, they always ask to stop- what a wonderful gem we have found ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’m not a pizza person but I love their pizza, and calzones!! Husband and son always ask to have it anytime they can lol.
Recommended to whole family and everyone loves it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding! Coming from a pizza snob. So much flavor. The crust is incredible. We will go back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
en dehors d un accueil toujours chaleureux des pizzas excellente et un tarif plus qu abordable !
Restaurantji Recommends
The new York pizza is the worst pizza I've ever had. Paper thin, hard as a rock, sauce was bland and lacking, cheese must not come on pizza here. For the price, plus a delivery fee, plus a tip for the rude driver combined with a 50 minute wait to get a lukewarm pizza, I'm not a happy customer. Whoever is writing reviews must be getting paid or have no idea what pizza should be. I'm guessing friends or relatives. I've had better pizza from the freezer. 35 bucks down the drain.
Food: 1
Service: 2
I don't think this place is worth it's hype, went in on Saturday at 2pm. Window and website says pizza by the slice. Went in and there was one person inside eating. Two cold slices of pizza to choose from and they were all dried up and crusty looking. I asked if more pizza was coming out he said the weekend are dead but will take 10 min to make and 10" and up size pizza. We just wanted a slice. I'm sorry but we won't return.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We were nicely greeted when we first arrived, and a conversation continued all through the transaction of our carry out order. Very nice people.
Now, about the large New York Style pepperoni pizza that we ordered.
The pizza lacked any taste at all. The sauce and cheese were very bland and the crust was hard and not chewy.
A New York style pizza one should be able to fold the slice in half without the crust breaking in half and it should be chewy and not very crunchy.
I was not pleased with what I ordered, but settled for it anyway and ate it, as we were traveling across country and it was food in our belly.
The reviews fooled me on this place.
Nice people, but the pizza is not that good at all.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
No flop! And crisp undercarriage. Dave Portnoy would be proud… I recommend you try them out.
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza ?in Indy, the staff are very friendly and the place is very clean! ?? #IndyPizza #FriendlyStaff #
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Choco Flan, Pepperoni Breadsticks Cheese, Greek Pizza
Loading...