This is our favorite brunch spot when we come to Indy and we will make sure to stop here every single time we are out in the area. When we went earlier this month, to celebrate our five-year wedding anniversary, we came for brunch. This time we were able to sit at the counter/bar - which we loved to watch the chefs in their element and still being cozy/intimate while eating. We started with the beignets - soo delicious, my husband said they were slightly undercooked but I say he's crazy and they were perfect. I wish I could remember exactly what we got to eat - the menu has changed since we went and it's no longer on there, but it was so delicious. My husband had some kind of smashburger and it was so savory while I had the red highlighted breakfast special for the week and it was SOO good. Even our drinks were delicious - my husband got some kind of iced mint coffee (he is NOT a coffee fan) and he loved it, while I got the toasted caramel latte iced and boy was it sooo delicious. Our server Jess W did such a great job, especially on a chaotic Saturday morning, while being so busy she was very attentive and thorough with a smile on her face. We already cannot wait to come back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mateo Gebon
I got in early one Sunday morning and gave Milktooth a try. It’s a very popular place, and finding parking can be hard. The staff was professional, and I was able to sit down at the bar right away. The menu changes quite often, so I’m not 100% what I got anymore. The latte was good, but the Indian-inspired biscuits and gravy was delicious. I think it was something like a saag paneer style gravy over the biscuits with an egg on top. The flavor was great, and it was just filling enough. The place has a bright, kind of retro atmosphere, and they pack a decent number of tables into the place. It still fills up fast though, so be prepared. It’s worth a wait if you’re a fan of nice breakfasts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karl Grossniklaus
Fantastic place to eat. There is never a single bad item on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris b
Quality has gone down…
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Blake Freeland
Favorite brunch in Indy. Best vibes, people and food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shelby Robertson
Love Milktooth. The food is amazing and I'm going to miss the breakfast options. The saag paneer biscuits and gravy? Oh my GOSH. You'll definitely have a wait if you don't show up a little before they open but they are so quick to get your food out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexandra Trumbo
UNIQUE and tasty you’ve got to stop by
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brianna Hendrix
I ordered the chilaquiles and thought the food was just okay. The portion size seemed a little small, and I wish there were more side options or options for the meal to come with a side. I thought the food was slightly overpriced. The service was great and the atmosphere is fun and inviting. I am interested to see what this place is like after the new rebrand. I would try again, but would probably wait for a menu that appeals more to my taste buds.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Saif
This place is everything the world says it is. I rolled in just before 3pm on a Monday and they accommodated me. Got some oysters, a spiced chai waffle and a few drinks. I had a Turbo something IPA which was alright and an Indianapolis Brewing Company lager, another alright beer. The spiced chai is everything it said it was. Oysters were fresh and didn't cause any health issues. I appreciated my time and the Hoosier hospitality I received.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Geriann Denecke
Took forever to be seated. Place is WAY too loud, like a night club in Vegas. Service was poor, slow and just not friendly. The bathrooms stunk and both toilet lids were left up- I am a woman I don’t think I should have to have to deal with that- I’m assuming they’re gender neutral bathrooms, so it makes sense with their atmosphere and semi trashy/gross atmosphere. Latte was disgusting. Zero flavor. Food 2/10. Was so excited to finally try this place and I was extremely disappointed. I had to shout at the person next to me just to talk/ hear them.
Was extremely disappointed. Everyone in Indy hypes this place up and was so excited being a foodie myself. I was so under impressed and it started from the start when just sitting down. We waited about 30 minutes on a Sunday, which is expected for late morning brunch. What I was so upset about was that we were directly sat with other people. No warning or asking us, “hey is it ok if we seat you with others?” NOTHING! That really not only made us feel weird and the couple we were sitting with also, who were unaware. Wasn’t even like a partition or anything, directly sitting at the same table with not much room, elbow to elbow. What upset both our group and the other couple was there was tables opening. I feel like for the cost we paid, could have said “hey would you like to move or anything like that… nothing.”
Next, the coffee was unexciting and had a weird orange taste for a caramel coffee latte. When brought up to our waitress, it seemed like I was being a burden asking if there was orange in the coffee and had to look back at the menu to make sure I didn’t miss it.
Now the food was ok. Portions are small and not worth the price in my opinion. For two people with one food item each and a coffee plus tip built in, be ready to spend about $60-70 total. In my opinion, not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Tamara McClure
Everything was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kat Paulsen
Amazing food and service. Really one of the best restaurants!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlie Ward
Very good as usual as well as the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brent Yao
We came here because a travel YouTuber raved about this place. Let's start with the good... The presentation and unique menu items are definitely a plus. It was a beautiful day so we decided to sit outside.
My wife had the smash burger and iced matcha magic with lavender. I had the pastrami hash with an iced honey buzz latte.
The food was okay. The smash burger had an odd combination of flavors and did not impress. It came with a pretty tasty side of fries.
The pastrami hash included an egg, potatoes, carrots, onions, and mustard. It was nice but not something I would write home about.
Overall, the portion sizes for the drinks and food were mediocre for the price. The food quality was very high however there is an included 20% gratuity which I am very much against. Maybe I'm missing something but I don't get why this place is so expensive.
This is our favorite brunch spot when we come to Indy and we will make sure to stop here every single time we are out in the area. When we went earlier this month, to celebrate our five-year wedding anniversary, we came for brunch. This time we were able to sit at the counter/bar - which we loved to watch the chefs in their element and still being cozy/intimate while eating. We started with the beignets - soo delicious, my husband said they were slightly undercooked but I say he's crazy and they were perfect. I wish I could remember exactly what we got to eat - the menu has changed since we went and it's no longer on there, but it was so delicious. My husband had some kind of smashburger and it was so savory while I had the red highlighted breakfast special for the week and it was SOO good. Even our drinks were delicious - my husband got some kind of iced mint coffee (he is NOT a coffee fan) and he loved it, while I got the toasted caramel latte iced and boy was it sooo delicious. Our server Jess W did such a great job, especially on a chaotic Saturday morning, while being so busy she was very attentive and thorough with a smile on her face. We already cannot wait to come back again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I got in early one Sunday morning and gave Milktooth a try. It’s a very popular place, and finding parking can be hard. The staff was professional, and I was able to sit down at the bar right away. The menu changes quite often, so I’m not 100% what I got anymore. The latte was good, but the Indian-inspired biscuits and gravy was delicious. I think it was something like a saag paneer style gravy over the biscuits with an egg on top. The flavor was great, and it was just filling enough. The place has a bright, kind of retro atmosphere, and they pack a decent number of tables into the place. It still fills up fast though, so be prepared. It’s worth a wait if you’re a fan of nice breakfasts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic place to eat. There is never a single bad item on the menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Quality has gone down…
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 2
Favorite brunch in Indy. Best vibes, people and food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love Milktooth. The food is amazing and I'm going to miss the breakfast options. The saag paneer biscuits and gravy? Oh my GOSH. You'll definitely have a wait if you don't show up a little before they open but they are so quick to get your food out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
UNIQUE and tasty you’ve got to stop by
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered the chilaquiles and thought the food was just okay. The portion size seemed a little small, and I wish there were more side options or options for the meal to come with a side. I thought the food was slightly overpriced. The service was great and the atmosphere is fun and inviting. I am interested to see what this place is like after the new rebrand. I would try again, but would probably wait for a menu that appeals more to my taste buds.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
This place is everything the world says it is. I rolled in just before 3pm on a Monday and they accommodated me. Got some oysters, a spiced chai waffle and a few drinks. I had a Turbo something IPA which was alright and an Indianapolis Brewing Company lager, another alright beer. The spiced chai is everything it said it was. Oysters were fresh and didn't cause any health issues. I appreciated my time and the Hoosier hospitality I received.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Took forever to be seated. Place is WAY too loud, like a night club in Vegas. Service was poor, slow and just not friendly. The bathrooms stunk and both toilet lids were left up- I am a woman I don’t think I should have to have to deal with that- I’m assuming they’re gender neutral bathrooms, so it makes sense with their atmosphere and semi trashy/gross atmosphere. Latte was disgusting. Zero flavor. Food 2/10. Was so excited to finally try this place and I was extremely disappointed. I had to shout at the person next to me just to talk/ hear them.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Was extremely disappointed. Everyone in Indy hypes this place up and was so excited being a foodie myself. I was so under impressed and it started from the start when just sitting down. We waited about 30 minutes on a Sunday, which is expected for late morning brunch. What I was so upset about was that we were directly sat with other people. No warning or asking us, “hey is it ok if we seat you with others?” NOTHING! That really not only made us feel weird and the couple we were sitting with also, who were unaware. Wasn’t even like a partition or anything, directly sitting at the same table with not much room, elbow to elbow. What upset both our group and the other couple was there was tables opening. I feel like for the cost we paid, could have said “hey would you like to move or anything like that… nothing.”
Next, the coffee was unexciting and had a weird orange taste for a caramel coffee latte. When brought up to our waitress, it seemed like I was being a burden asking if there was orange in the coffee and had to look back at the menu to make sure I didn’t miss it.
Now the food was ok. Portions are small and not worth the price in my opinion. For two people with one food item each and a coffee plus tip built in, be ready to spend about $60-70 total. In my opinion, not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Everything was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food and service. Really one of the best restaurants!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good as usual as well as the service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came here because a travel YouTuber raved about this place. Let's start with the good... The presentation and unique menu items are definitely a plus. It was a beautiful day so we decided to sit outside.
My wife had the smash burger and iced matcha magic with lavender. I had the pastrami hash with an iced honey buzz latte.
The food was okay. The smash burger had an odd combination of flavors and did not impress. It came with a pretty tasty side of fries.
The pastrami hash included an egg, potatoes, carrots, onions, and mustard. It was nice but not something I would write home about.
Overall, the portion sizes for the drinks and food were mediocre for the price. The food quality was very high however there is an included 20% gratuity which I am very much against. Maybe I'm missing something but I don't get why this place is so expensive.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Loading...