Best pasta restaurant I've ever been to. Unbelievable. Incredible cost performance!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oliver H.
Had lunch here for the first time today. Mind was blown by the quality of the pasta. Amazing Paccheri noodles. Will definitely say the best pasta I've had in Indy, but just my opinion!
Brett Rathmell
...Great place for a meal , lunch or to take away , lots of tasty pasta & non pasta choices YUM !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Steph Mayes
Looking for Italian lunch this past Saturday. Had never heard of this place & decided to try. It is a delightful place & food was absolutely delish!! Nothing fancy, very simple, & staff is wonderful. I'm on a mission now to tell folks about this charmer & I definitely will be back. The tiramasu is some of the best I've ever had!! Thank you for a lovely experience!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Symone Cole
Came in for pasta today .. was never greeted .. was in the store about 7 mins .. no one ever said HELLO.. I left .. maybe I try again .. maybe not
Angie King
I picked some pasta up for the first time last week! I made it tonight and it was AMAZING!!! I’ll never go back to that dusty crusty boxed pasta
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ashli A.
So happy this place is here. Can't beat it! Fresh ingredients and always a treat!I got the Pear, Prosciutto, Brie Sandwich with basil pestoIt was so good truly words can't do it justice so just come in and try this place out!
Kyle S.
I've been here countless times to get fresh pasta and dessert. Everything they make in house is phenomenal. Grab some of their pasta and sauce then tiramisu for dessert.First time coming here to eat. They have several pasta dishes then a few non pasta dishes. I wish they had a few more sandwiches because I don't typically associate pasta with lunch but what do I know.I got the pear, prosciutto and Brie sandwich and it was incredible. THE BREAD. The bread was the star and all the flavors commingled together perfectly. Highly recommend. They rotate their menu a few times a year so there's always something new!
skeen MacKie
Under new management.The food is very average now and has lost its charm and soul. I hold out hope that they may reverse some of their most regressive alterations to the spirit of the food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Silene Oviedo
Is amazing, the taste, the place the people, everything. This is a place you really have to visit. Even the restroom is good. You should try the tiramisu.
There's nothing like homemade pasta & Nicole-Taylor's. I've only had the pasta at Italian restaurants but it's always obvious it's gourmet & special!
Sue C.
Hands down one of the best chef's table experiences ever!! My sister & dear friend had this reservation for 6-8 months for my 59th birthday(Oct will be my 60th) and we had 8 for the evening at 7pm on Aug 19, 2023. The new Owner/Chef, Erin was beyond amazing to say the least (culinary veteran through and through)! Chef's email to my sister and dear friend Tonya stated "going a little east of Italy, but I think you'll dig it"!! Oh and did we dig it!!! We had a 4 hr dining experience along with a lot of amazing vino!It's definitely worth a reservation and the anticipated wait, trust me!!Chef's kiss goes out to Erin! Grazie Grazie for a wonderful evening!Sue CarneyTerre Haute, IN
Karmen J.
I see what all the hype is about here at Nicole-Taylor's! Cute spot, very nice staff, awesome food, and carry out meals. Great spot for lunch or dinner. Go check it out!!
LG
The best! If you haven't tried the backroom eatery you must. Food is always excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drew “The Legend” Davis
Best pasta I've ever had. Rotating menu. Everything they prepare is amazing.Parking: There is parking along the strip mall, but can be limited at times. There is one handicap parking spot in front of Nicole Taylor's.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a wheelchair accessible ramp to get into the establishment.
Best pasta restaurant I've ever been to. Unbelievable. Incredible cost performance!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had lunch here for the first time today. Mind was blown by the quality of the pasta. Amazing Paccheri noodles. Will definitely say the best pasta I've had in Indy, but just my opinion!
...Great place for a meal , lunch or to take away , lots of tasty pasta & non pasta choices YUM !
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Looking for Italian lunch this past Saturday. Had never heard of this place & decided to try. It is a delightful place & food was absolutely delish!! Nothing fancy, very simple, & staff is wonderful. I'm on a mission now to tell folks about this charmer & I definitely will be back. The tiramasu is some of the best I've ever had!! Thank you for a lovely experience!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came in for pasta today .. was never greeted .. was in the store about 7 mins .. no one ever said HELLO.. I left .. maybe I try again .. maybe not
I picked some pasta up for the first time last week! I made it tonight and it was AMAZING!!! I’ll never go back to that dusty crusty boxed pasta
Food: 5
Service: 5
So happy this place is here. Can't beat it! Fresh ingredients and always a treat!I got the Pear, Prosciutto, Brie Sandwich with basil pestoIt was so good truly words can't do it justice so just come in and try this place out!
I've been here countless times to get fresh pasta and dessert. Everything they make in house is phenomenal. Grab some of their pasta and sauce then tiramisu for dessert.First time coming here to eat. They have several pasta dishes then a few non pasta dishes. I wish they had a few more sandwiches because I don't typically associate pasta with lunch but what do I know.I got the pear, prosciutto and Brie sandwich and it was incredible. THE BREAD. The bread was the star and all the flavors commingled together perfectly. Highly recommend. They rotate their menu a few times a year so there's always something new!
Under new management.The food is very average now and has lost its charm and soul. I hold out hope that they may reverse some of their most regressive alterations to the spirit of the food.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Is amazing, the taste, the place the people, everything. This is a place you really have to visit. Even the restroom is good. You should try the tiramisu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
There's nothing like homemade pasta & Nicole-Taylor's. I've only had the pasta at Italian restaurants but it's always obvious it's gourmet & special!
Hands down one of the best chef's table experiences ever!! My sister & dear friend had this reservation for 6-8 months for my 59th birthday(Oct will be my 60th) and we had 8 for the evening at 7pm on Aug 19, 2023. The new Owner/Chef, Erin was beyond amazing to say the least (culinary veteran through and through)! Chef's email to my sister and dear friend Tonya stated "going a little east of Italy, but I think you'll dig it"!! Oh and did we dig it!!! We had a 4 hr dining experience along with a lot of amazing vino!It's definitely worth a reservation and the anticipated wait, trust me!!Chef's kiss goes out to Erin! Grazie Grazie for a wonderful evening!Sue CarneyTerre Haute, IN
I see what all the hype is about here at Nicole-Taylor's! Cute spot, very nice staff, awesome food, and carry out meals. Great spot for lunch or dinner. Go check it out!!
The best! If you haven't tried the backroom eatery you must. Food is always excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pasta I've ever had. Rotating menu. Everything they prepare is amazing.Parking: There is parking along the strip mall, but can be limited at times. There is one handicap parking spot in front of Nicole Taylor's.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a wheelchair accessible ramp to get into the establishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5