Papa Johns Pizza

6311 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 251-7272

Recent Reviews

Elise

If you’re gonna charge for the sauce. Can you at least fill them up?

Josh Sterne

Managed a pizza place and when we door dashed orders we had to call the customer bc they didn’t choose that. Got door dashed my order months ago (put it in like one of their drivers is going to deliver) and they door dashed it again tonight. If u don’t have delivery drivers that’s fine just have a notification it’s going to be thru DoorDash. Why am I spending money on a tip just to have it redirected and not knowing how much money is going to the person who delivers? I didn’t have to order thru here tonight that’s fair, but you guys also don’t have to advertise delivery if you DONT HAVE DRIVERS!

Gabriel Carrasco

Good pizza and excellent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John T Rex

It's a Papa John's, they don't have

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Martinez

The worst experience I called today the day after Christmas to order a macaroni pizza as it was advertised online when I call the operator told me that that just stopped Christmas Day and I said well it’s still online so I should be able to still get it can I speak with your manager, and he greatly gave me the phone. at that point the manager got on the phone and angrily told me that if you want the pizza you’ll have to order it online you can’t pick it up and I was like why can’t you just accommodate me why do I have to go through all that? He said something smart to me and I told him how rude he was and he hung up on me and said we don’t need your “F$&Kin$ Business. I tried calling back several times, and no answer. I finally got an answer after my sixth attempts the manager answered the phone cuss at me again and hung up on me. I was in such disbelief I couldn’t believe it. so I hopped in the car and drove up there, I introduced myself and explained that I was the individual that he was cussing out on the phone. He started acting belligerent and cussing, and then I called 911 and he did the same. I was not too about let this slide by after all this I don’t care what business you’re in, Just be mindful to honor your customers. In no way, was I disrespectful or exhibited anger towards manager Simply wanted to file a complaint he wouldn’t give me anybody’s number the police gave me a police case number I to voice my concerns to somebody who will listen and not try to scoot me under the carpet. this manager needs to be retrained.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Kaylee G.

Your crew is awesome! So kind and always going above and beyond. Thanks for a delicious birthday pizza!

Olivia Zapp

This is probably one of the fastest, most professional pizza places in the area. The front staff are polite, courteous, and prompt. They don’t ignore you after you make eye contact and they typically have your order ready at the right time. The pizza is always on point but the service is what makes me recommend to others. Thank you for being kind!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lee S

75% chance you actually get your food. 50% chance it lives up to expectations. 0% chance they care either way. I've been burned by this place sooo many times over the years and they just don't care.

Corey Howe

I think this was a record breaker here folks. I’ve never seen it take an hour and a half for a pizza to be delivered a mile and a half on a Tuesday, but by god they pulled it off! It was like the reverse Jesse Owens of pizza delivery. Well done guys.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Caden // Near Light

Take my word. Don’t eat or order from here! I certainly won’t be anymore and due to how the manager named Zach decided to speak to me and also how he deliberately choose to handle resolving a mistake with my order. Not only had Zach NOT fixed the issue with my order but Zach also shared absolutely NO importance or concern towards the situation/mistake with my order.I come here ALL the time and never had any problems or issues that is until I spoke with the manager named Zach on duty and to address a mistake that was made with my order so we can get it fixed or resolved.Not going here anymore.100 % lack of care for customers.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Bob Saget

75% chance you actually get your food. 50% chance it lives up to expectations. 0% chance they care either way. I've been burned by this place sooo many times over the years and they just don't care.

M C.

I ordered a single top thin crust. Added extra pepperoni. Also requested "well done". Didn't get extra pepperoni, didn't get "well done". For $18. Pitiful!

Anna Berndt

Never ever got my pizza. I ordered a single pizza over an hour before closing time. They said it would arrive in 28 minutes. 5 minutes after closing time it’s marked as “delivered” and I can’t ever call them to ask where it is or get a refund

Elita Flowers

?Dirty location? Rude employees? Half baked pizzaBetter off trying to make a pizza at home ?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shane Hudnall

Food is just alright, pretty greasy leaking through the box, didnt get the extra sauces that i paid for, waited on hold for 15 minutes then hung up. Not too happy about it. Doordash guy couldnt so anything about it because they outsource all of their deliveries these days.

Load More