Papa Johns Pizza

5035 W 71st St, Indianapolis
(317) 297-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wayne McCoy

Placed order on line with pickup. Upon arriving order was ready, on time, however it was incorrect. Both employees were apologetic and said they will make a new one that would be correct. It seems less than 10.min and had hot fresh correct order. Thanks guys

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ricardo Gonzalez

Truck driver from here. Showed up they were swamped but the night crew Amber /lelahon were super friendly (DESPITE BEING SWAMPED). They were fast and courteous. I have eaten out pretty much everywhere in the US, and I've had a handful of pleasant.THIS IS WAS ONE OF THEM

Quin Perry

Pizza was good staff was funny

Robert Edwards

Excellent

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

G. McGuire

Omg No one has on gloves or hair nets - The floor was Clean but the Pizza shows the reflection of the employees attitude toward making the Pizza - it was sloppy & undercooked

Meikos Nelson

Ordered a pickup online, didn't tip, so I ended up trying to place my toppings evenly among the other 6 slices. Looked like they just scooped the toppings up and dumped them in one place... So, if you want all your slices to have your toppings on them, MAKE SURE YOU PAY THAT EXTRA MONEY AND TIP THEM FOR DOING THEIR JOB THEY'RE GETTING PAID TO DO...

Kory Johnston

So i tried ordering the pizza online and was unable to order it the way I wanted but when I got in I spoke with the lady that worked there (AMBER) and she helped me out not only in making it so the pizza could be the way I wanted it this time but also explained to me how I could have it done easier even though online wont let you. It was nice to have that kind of customer service again as I find some of the papajohns around this area really lack that. She personally made it a good experience that I would be willing to go there again even though it's not the closest to my house

Michelle Hunt

The appeared very understaffed. The app said a 20 mins pickup window. When I arrived after 25 mins the worker told me my order had not been started and I would need to wait another 20 mins until it would be ready and if I still wanted it. A little frustrating but the pizza was good when we got it.

dallas lawson

Cancel my order after the order said it was ready not coming back again

Danielle Lewis

I had an issue with my pizza last night and was told I could return it today. When I arrived I was greeted by Nicki and Robert who quickly resolved it with so much kindness. I’m also very appreciative of the manager from last night calling and apologizing as well. I’ll go back from their customer service alone. It was greatly appreciated ❤️

Jason Schmidt

Guaranteed to make your order incorrect

Kirubel Yemaneab

Nice places

Aaron Strand

I thought the carry-out pizza was fine. You get what you pay for at a Papa John’s. It was ready when I arrived which is good for carry-out pizza

Brent Cox

Ordered at 4:10pm went in to carry out at 5:00pm long line waiting to pick up. Gave name said backed up. 30 min later they looked on computer said order was canceled. Worst customer service. With staff standing around

dnnor

The pizza is consistent, but the service is not....but maybe in today's food service, that's asking a bit too much

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 3

Loading...