Papa Johns Pizza

11671 Fox Rd, Indianapolis
(317) 826-9595

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David Moscrip

Very quickly made, friendly staff

Rodney Joseph

Very bad I don't recommend to anyone

Tina Barnheart

We enjoy Papa Johns Pizza! Especially when we invite our neighbors over. Their website is easy to order from. Our pizzas and breadsticks are perfect! Fresh and hot.

Takita Lockridge

Papa John's never disappoints, and today’s experience was top-notch, thanks to Mike! The pizza was fresh, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor, as always. Mike went above and beyond with his excellent customer service — he was friendly, helpful, and made sure my order was exactly what I wanted. It's people like Mike that make this location stand out. Highly recommend Papa John's, especially with Mike leading the way!

Howard Moulton

Jordan is a 5 🌟 employee!! Hands down saved our night and this guy deserves a raise. Flawless customer service.

Monotone Matt

The lady working the counter late last night was not friendly or courteous or anything. As I left, I said thank you have a nice night and she had an upset look on her face and just stormed away from me and said nothing! Needless to say, I won’t be spending any more money here!

John Marcum

Absolutely horrible pizza. This is the second bad experience it just as many years. We decided to give this place another try and ordered a XL meat pizza and order of cheese stix. The website keep showing our pizza was in oven for the whole hour we waited. So they need to update status while using the app. When the door dash driver showed up our food was luke warm at best, after waiting a hour. Our pizza and cheese Stix had bare minimum cheese on it. Some of the slices had bare spots with only pizza sauce(picture included). Needless to say, we will not order another pizza from this Papa Johns establishment.

Matt Fielder

Tell your employees to stay off the phone and actually get order right.

lorena lingow

Favorite papa johns

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stephen Casey

Was at the Papa John’s on Fox Rd and it was a clown show. 2 young girls with headsets on literally sitting on the counter making out! Screwing around in their phones and with each other while I stood there waiting. Minimal customer interaction. Sickening and as unprofessional as I’ve ever seen. They need to be fired. NEVER going back

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Brea D

The employees are great! The atmosphere and food has changed for the worse. There is a peculiar smell when you enter the store, it does not smell like pizza is being cooked. The pizza is tasteless. I think the cheese has changed to probably a blend of cheese instead of 100% mozzarella. Also I think they may have a plumbing problem at this location. I will no longer order food from this location.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Michelle C

So, I placed my order online and picked it up on time, I asked for a square cut. I've learned to look at my order before I leave the store. I realized that they tried to correct their mistake by cutting over the triangles into squares. I asked for a new pizza to be made and that I would be back to pick it up. This time I realized the crust was not garlic parmesan, so once again, they remade the pizza. I'm certain they are not paying attention to instructions. However, within 10 to 12 minutes, they had a fresh pizza, and they gave me the other pizza as well. I appreciate their efforts to make a wrong right!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Matthew Kidd

Overall, the flavor is good, and we really enjoy the epic stuffed crust. That stated, the last two times we have requested light sauce as we always do. Each time the sauce has been heavy. I am not certain they are paying attention to the order.

Food: 2

Service: 5

Hardeep Singh

The food always comes out lacking ingredients and never the way papa John’s should be. The cheese sticks are pretty much just bread with a little bit of cheese on top and always dry/crisp.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Tony Montana

Well we ordered pizza at 7:52 last night Nov 22nd, we woke up this morning to it on our porch. A quick look at the ring camera this morning shows him here around 8;23 standing at our door for about 60 seconds, not ringing the doorbell. Then just sitting it down and running off... we have a rind doorbell for a reason, why not ring it? Needless to say we fell asleep and never got our pizza I will be calling tomorrow and would really like to have it replaced or refunded. If taken care of I will change my review.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...