Papa Johns Pizza

10598 N College Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 846-7272

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Andrew Calloway

Went in to the store today, no menus anywhere displaying available food or prices. Stood there for about 30 seconds, no employees. Did this place close down and someone just forgot to lock up?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Dan Grossmann

Whenever I've ordered a carryout order from this location (106th/College), they always have it ready on time or early, which is a huge plus for me! It's always the perfect temperature and I've never had an order made incorrectly here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mohsen Dawood

My pizza was 2.5 hours late and cold
Dropped it in front of my hotel room door and didn't even bother to knock

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Growth Foundry

The service here is great. Everyone always treats me well.

Service: 5

LB

This place has gone way downhill. Used to be my “go-to” pizza place but as of late, food quality is atrocious! Delivery service is ridiculous!! Stop using third party deliveries!! If door dash throws my pizza on my front stoop one more time when it’s below freezing outside. Oh and management finds nothing wrong with it to boot. “It was only outside for five minutes” WHAT? You don’t put hot food on the freezing ground. Thats enough stupid for today….

michael whelan

Staff is friendly, and pick-up orders are quick and easy.

Julian Crowell

Ordered a pizza for the fam for dinner! 1.5 hours later I get an email from papa John’s saying “sorry about your order inconvenience HEEEEEERES $50% off if you order today!”

so then I call the store. 7 times. No answer. So then I check the “papa tracker” and it says door dash was doing the delivery… it shows the car roaming around my neighborhood for about 7 minutes, while I’m calling the driver as well and no answer. So I got my money robbed by papa, and my pizzas and breadsticks and dr p are lost in the ether. Godspeed bread and cheese. I’m moving out of the city.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Sara Couch

Not sure what’s going on with this location, but I told myself if I ordered and had yet another poor experience that it would be the last order. This will indeed be the LAST. Ordered a large pepperoni and sausage pizza well-done. It was not well-done and was delivered via DoorDash in an unsealed box. Missing the extra dipping sauce I ordered. The pep and sausage was so scarce that it was basically a cheese pizza (seemed strange that there was exactly one pepperoni per slice-what’s up with that?). Family was unhappy. I’ll go with Mellow Mushroom next time. My penultimate pizza order was a doughey, gooey mess despite also being ordered well-done. Get it together!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Amanda Montgomery

Pizza was great. Did pay at delivery. It was done by door dash. Dasher did not have change I only had $40 pizza was $23 Dasher got a $17 tip because they did not have change I usually tip $9 for delivery

Food: 5

Service: 4

Steve Hoppe

I ordered at around 10. It was after 1130 before it got here. I'm less than a mile away.
And it wasn't good. The only reason I order from here is because it is late and nothing is open. Papa John's, do the world a favor and go bankrupt. A better pizza place could use the space. You have and always will suck.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Wesley McCoy

This is my go-to place to get pizza. Orders are done quickly and accurately. The staff are friendly. Every experience has been great! Keep it up!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bob Fox

Nightmare store. Never even got food and when I called, I get a 1800 number. I finally had to dispute it with Amex.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Mahmoud Abdel-Rahman

Great and quick service ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Randy Williamson

Pizza is always delivered sooner than the estimated time. It is always hot and fresh out of the oven.

Food: 5

Service: 5

William DePuye

Ordered a pizza and waited for it
They made it perfectly and brought it out to my car while we were waiting….. super nice people

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...