Pots & Pans Pie Co.

4915 N College Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 600-3475

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Shortbread Chocolate Chip Cookie

Thai Chicken Curry Pot Pie

Sugar Creme Brulee Pie

Honey Lemon Chess Pie

Beef and Mushroom Pie

Biscuits and Gravy

Oatmeal Crème Pie

Apple Crumble Pie

Oatmeal Cream Pie

S’Mores Pie

Photos

+34 photos

+33 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Potsandpansindy

Doordash

Postmates

Indypies

Recent Reviews

This was one of several places I stopped at in my quest to try as many different sugar cream pies as possible, and while their pie offerings are certainly tasty, I have to say that in terms of bang for buck, I felt I got a lot more at a number of other places. I do love that they offer some unique pie flavors that you don't see anywhere else, but for me to fully justify the price they charge per slice, I'd have to be pretty blown away, and I just wasn't. I had a...

April 2025

Fast service! And yummy food! My first time coming here! Glad i did the food was really good and fresh tasting! We got the most popular, the classic chicken! 10/10! The cost is kinda higher for 6” -$13. But its homemade so its worth it. The store is super small so not any seats! The parking is small. But definitely recommend

April 2025

Perfect pies ✔️ from a cute little shop with friendly people. Seriously, y'all were so patient as I indecisively mulled over which of the many delicious pie options.

We ended up getting a supreme pizza hand pie, and individual slices of the sugar creme brulee and the blackbottom frangipane. My favorite was the creme brulee since I have a sweeter palette but my significant other really liked the frangipane as it was less sweet and had a bit of a kick...

March 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Indianapolis, IN

Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Pots & Pans Pie Co.