Pots & Pans Pie Co.
4915 N College Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 600-3475
Customers' Favorites
Shortbread Chocolate Chip Cookie
Thai Chicken Curry Pot Pie
Sugar Creme Brulee Pie
Honey Lemon Chess Pie
Beef and Mushroom Pie
Biscuits and Gravy
Oatmeal Crème Pie
Oatmeal Cream Pie
Apple Crumble Pie
Chicken Pot Pie
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Absolute BEST Apple pie I’ve ever eaten. So so good… thinly sliced apples, delicious flavor and perfect thickness of the top layer of crust. I drove over an hour round trip to pickup this pie. Zero regrets…100% recommend.
Wow. I stopped in today because I saw the crusts of pots & pans’ pies briefly on social media and it’s not every day you see a crust that has that volume and shine and looks that golden brown. I had to try. It has been a year since I had this epiphany and only stopped in today, 11/16/2025. I’m upset that I haven’t tried sooner.
First, I had the most easygoing welcoming experience. No pressure, just able to browse. There was someone stocking the pies and typically...
First, I had the most easygoing welcoming experience. No pressure, just able to browse. There was someone stocking the pies and typically...
Taking a bite of the pear frangipane as I write this, I think it's my new favorite of your frangipane pies (but I will gladly try the others, for science). Can't wait to cut into the pumpkin cream later tonight.
Also, I just wanted to mention how thorough the clerk was in explaining to the man before me, who I let cut me in line, that the reheating instructions on the box should be disregarded, as the pie is best served cold, or perhaps room temperature....
Also, I just wanted to mention how thorough the clerk was in explaining to the man before me, who I let cut me in line, that the reheating instructions on the box should be disregarded, as the pie is best served cold, or perhaps room temperature....
You May Also Like
Greek's Pizzeria - 4901 N College Ave
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian
Dunkin' - 4851 N College Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Upland College Ave Tasting Room - 4842 N College Ave
![]()
Brewery, Beer Bar, American, Pet Friendly, Vegan