Punkin's Pies

1220 Waterway Blvd, Indianapolis

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jenni Schwartz (HarleysGonePostal)

Omfg this place is to die for. Absolutely delicious

Papi Schwa

OMG, I can't say enough about how awesome this place is. I would definitely put it as a MUST TRY.

Shell Winkler

Delicious like always! We love to stop in as often as possible for a sweet treat! Their always so friendly!

Phil Strack

Recently I worked with Joanna of Punkin’s Pies. What a treat it was, she helped our Family make an anniversary celebration truly amazing. From delivery, set up; to clean up she and her husband Mark did this all with huge smiles on their faces.
Strawberries and Oreos almost looked too nice to eat. Everyone loved them and talked about how beautiful they appeared. Punkin’s Pies made my parents’ 50th-anniversary party a little sweeter. Making a life memory and celebration a little sweeter as well.
Thank you, Joanna and Mark, you guys are the sweetest people!

Tony Donohue

Oreo cheesecake bar was incredible! Took me 2 sittings to eat! Tried it last night at the PRI event in speedway !! Delicious

Megan Mitchell

Sawyer y'all on Tiktok and had to stop by! The Oreo truffles are so rich and yummy. The bling berry is so cool, and the cheesecake stuffed strawberries are to die for!!

Neyci Miguel

Visiting from out of state. My sister's and I were craving something sweet. Those strawberries definitely did the job! Not only were the strawberries great and Sweet but so was the customer service. Definitely coming back before we leave!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jaime Jones

Very good customer service! Sweet treats taste freshly made and a beautiful shop! Definitely come by and support this black owned business!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pecan Turtles, Cake Pops, Strawberry

Rebecca Wilson

DELICIOUS ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rosa Ojeda

Had some bling strawberries and they were Amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michele Reffett

Stopped by Punkin’s Pies in Amp. Turtles are my favorite, so I chose a white chocolate and milk chocolate because making a choice was too difficult! And….OH My Goodness! First of all, they’re HUGE. Everything, even the pecans, melt in your mouth. Turtle Perfection. Seriously. I will definitely be a customer for life now! On a side note— the gentleman was making cheesecake fruit bowls, and if they weren’t spoken for, I’m pretty sure one of those would have a went home with me, too! They were beautiful!

Marlexis Wilson

I come here all the time and I love the strawberry crunch truffles!!!! I’ve never had a problem with these, they’re the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pecan Turtles, Plain Chocolate, Cake Pops

Zara Hess

I ordered the Apple Crumble pie and the Sweet Potato pie for our Thanksgiving this year and they did not disappoint! the Sweet Potato pie was a huge hit and the Apple crumble is the best I've ever purchased. Definitely will be back again soon!

Zara Boyer

I ordered the Apple Crumble pie and the Sweet Potato pie for our Thanksgiving this year and they did not disappoint! the Sweet Potato pie was a huge hit and the Apple crumble is the best I've ever purchased. Definitely will be back again soon!

Itz6.2 Kell

I love the strawberry cheesecake ??Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...