Byrne's has the best customer service, hands down. There was a minor snafu with our food & they insisted on sending us home with a large pizza, on them. Great food, amazing staff.
Anne
Can't say enough good about this cool little place. Amazing food / drinks. Quality ingredients .. so tasty! Loved the cocktails and vino too! Great service .. hats off to them for their hard work.
Grace O
Cute little bar inside of a pizza place. Cozy and friendly atmosphere and responsive staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Elizabeth
Only 1 server on a busy Saturday afternoon and she killed it! Not sure how she managed all she did but did it with zero ‘tude. Pizza and salads were on point. We'll be back!
rbcm
We went here on New Years Eve at 6 pm. I was wanting pasta but after I ordered I was told they were out of pasta. My son changed his order to a meatball sub, but it wasn't very good. The cheeses wasn't melted and he said it didn't taste good. I ended up with a small pepperoni pizza which was actually really good. The bruschetta was good too. The salad was meh. There was one young lady serving everyone. She was quite efficient and very nice.
This is the 3rd time we have been there over the past year. Each time the service has been mediocre at best. Each time they have messed up our order. Once food came out we had to wait for them to come back by with plates, napkins and silverware. The pizza tasted fine but was undercooked at points. Overall not a great experience. Probably the time we will go there.
BethF
We had a wonderful time celebrating a college student graduation with a small group of 5. Having made a reservation, we were seated promptly. The service was very friendly, helpful and timely. LOVED our pizzas and pasta! There was plenty to go around and plenty for take home. Thank you Byrne's staff and chefs!!
JenniferM
We took our daughter and her room mate out to dinner during Butler University Family weekend. They had been here before and wanted to go again because they really liked the pizza. I made a reservation online, loved being able to do that! We were lead to a table outside, which I don't remember choosing. The service was slow but I don't know if there were only 2 people serving or not. My 12 year old son was with us and was getting hungry so we asked the server to bring out his order as soon as it was ready, even if it was ready before the pizza. We waited for a very long time for my son's order, which didn't come, because after my husband caught the attention of one of the server's they went to check on his order. The server came and told us that the restaurant had run out of red sauce for his pasta and wanted to know if he would be ok with pesto sauce or alfredo. We were very disappointed that the kitchen took a long time to tell us that they ran out of sauce. We did get a free meal because it took so long though. The pizza was great and we will go back again and I know my daughter will go back with her room mate again.
IndyAl
We had a great time celebrating a birthday with family. Byrnes was out of several items but the waitress was very sweet about it and the service was good. The pizzas were delicious!
TheCriticalDiner
We always enjoy dinner at Byrne's. Food is good, service is excellent, I was a bit disappointed that the tomato bruschetta and the veggie pizza seemed to have almost exactly the same pesto sauce and the pizza a bit overcooked. Would have been nice to have had two more different vegetarian options for their Devour menu.
We were there for a special lunch celebration. Requested server to turn the music down and I don't think they bothered to change the settings. The service was average- our server didn't really care to be pleasant. Pizzas were great.
Wright
This is our favorite pizza place!! My friend brought me here and I brought my husband. We have been bringing all our friends too. My husband picked this place for his birthday dinner. Love trying the different pizzas. Just saw a guy having the steak sandwich. Looked amazing. We are gonna have that next time. Cocktails are great too!!! Can't wait to come back.
DiningJen
Always delicious pizza and excellent service! And this time we had the Caprese Salad and it was one of the best we've ever had - with Indiana beefsteak tomatoes. Thanks and we'll be back!
Shar
Sooo good, no great! Sat outside and shared 3 different pizza's with girlfriends enjoyed with 2 bottles of wine ( 1/2 price bottle night—nice!) leisurely 3 hour dinner that we were never rushed to give up the outdoor table on a beautiful summer eve. Favorite new meeting place!
RayL
Joined our daughter and Grandaughter before a play at Clowes Hall. We had reservations but it was nice out and we chose to dine outside. It was lovely. The service was good and the pizza was delicious. We chose this place because of its proximity to Clowes Hall. This is the second time we have been there and we will be sure to return. .
Byrne's has the best customer service, hands down. There was a minor snafu with our food & they insisted on sending us home with a large pizza, on them. Great food, amazing staff.
Can't say enough good about this cool little place. Amazing food / drinks. Quality ingredients .. so tasty! Loved the cocktails and vino too! Great service .. hats off to them for their hard work.
Cute little bar inside of a pizza place. Cozy and friendly atmosphere and responsive staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Only 1 server on a busy Saturday afternoon and she killed it! Not sure how she managed all she did but did it with zero ‘tude. Pizza and salads were on point. We'll be back!
We went here on New Years Eve at 6 pm. I was wanting pasta but after I ordered I was told they were out of pasta. My son changed his order to a meatball sub, but it wasn't very good. The cheeses wasn't melted and he said it didn't taste good. I ended up with a small pepperoni pizza which was actually really good. The bruschetta was good too. The salad was meh. There was one young lady serving everyone. She was quite efficient and very nice.
This is the 3rd time we have been there over the past year. Each time the service has been mediocre at best. Each time they have messed up our order. Once food came out we had to wait for them to come back by with plates, napkins and silverware. The pizza tasted fine but was undercooked at points. Overall not a great experience. Probably the time we will go there.
We had a wonderful time celebrating a college student graduation with a small group of 5. Having made a reservation, we were seated promptly. The service was very friendly, helpful and timely. LOVED our pizzas and pasta! There was plenty to go around and plenty for take home. Thank you Byrne's staff and chefs!!
We took our daughter and her room mate out to dinner during Butler University Family weekend. They had been here before and wanted to go again because they really liked the pizza. I made a reservation online, loved being able to do that! We were lead to a table outside, which I don't remember choosing. The service was slow but I don't know if there were only 2 people serving or not. My 12 year old son was with us and was getting hungry so we asked the server to bring out his order as soon as it was ready, even if it was ready before the pizza. We waited for a very long time for my son's order, which didn't come, because after my husband caught the attention of one of the server's they went to check on his order. The server came and told us that the restaurant had run out of red sauce for his pasta and wanted to know if he would be ok with pesto sauce or alfredo. We were very disappointed that the kitchen took a long time to tell us that they ran out of sauce. We did get a free meal because it took so long though. The pizza was great and we will go back again and I know my daughter will go back with her room mate again.
We had a great time celebrating a birthday with family. Byrnes was out of several items but the waitress was very sweet about it and the service was good. The pizzas were delicious!
We always enjoy dinner at Byrne's. Food is good, service is excellent, I was a bit disappointed that the tomato bruschetta and the veggie pizza seemed to have almost exactly the same pesto sauce and the pizza a bit overcooked. Would have been nice to have had two more different vegetarian options for their Devour menu.
Restaurantji Recommends
We were there for a special lunch celebration. Requested server to turn the music down and I don't think they bothered to change the settings. The service was average- our server didn't really care to be pleasant. Pizzas were great.
This is our favorite pizza place!! My friend brought me here and I brought my husband. We have been bringing all our friends too. My husband picked this place for his birthday dinner. Love trying the different pizzas. Just saw a guy having the steak sandwich. Looked amazing. We are gonna have that next time. Cocktails are great too!!! Can't wait to come back.
Always delicious pizza and excellent service! And this time we had the Caprese Salad and it was one of the best we've ever had - with Indiana beefsteak tomatoes. Thanks and we'll be back!
Sooo good, no great! Sat outside and shared 3 different pizza's with girlfriends enjoyed with 2 bottles of wine ( 1/2 price bottle night—nice!) leisurely 3 hour dinner that we were never rushed to give up the outdoor table on a beautiful summer eve. Favorite new meeting place!
Joined our daughter and Grandaughter before a play at Clowes Hall. We had reservations but it was nice out and we chose to dine outside. It was lovely. The service was good and the pizza was delicious. We chose this place because of its proximity to Clowes Hall. This is the second time we have been there and we will be sure to return. .