finalllllly got to try sam’s square pie for the first time and can’t wait to go back…truly some of the best pizza i’ve ever had. i had 2 pizzas in mind to order: the pepperoni and pepperoni sausage - but the pizza on special (with truffle mushrooms and potato) was calling my name so i left with the triple pepperoni and the special, both absolutely amazing in their own way. and the crust……..YUM. not to mention my friend ordered the granny tomato pie: so classic and so tasty.
we got stuck in the parking lot due to a flat tire and Sam took time out of his busy Saturday evening dinner rush to help us resolve the issue, if that isn’t customer service at its finest idk what is.
great spot all around and i encourage any lover of pizza to head to Sam’s ASAP, you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rachel Foreman
Very good, crunchy, saucy, cheesy goodness! Love the ricotta topped pepperoni pizza. Good local beers on tap as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jenna Hennis
Best pizza in Indy hands down! Delicious. Homemade. Prices are reasonable! I definitely recommend 👍👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
B dot
My wife and I came in on Valentines Day for dinner. Dining room was hoppin', plenty of carry out. We have had the pizza before, and loved it! I knew going in that I wanted to try the meatballs. They were served with a wonderful side of fresh mozzarella. Absolutely delicious! Our pizzas were amazing as always. Couldn't have asked for better way to spend the evening with my wife. Pizza, a great beer, good music, great service! Thank you to the whole staff at Sam's, you guys are awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loving Cup, Meatballs
Pedro Rodriguez
Great service and food was amazingly delicious 😋 👌 😍 Would definitely recommend 👌 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Haley Carver
Hands down the best pizza in Indianapolis. Probably the best in the state! The owner is also extremely kind and so attentive to customers. My only regret is not ordering a bigger pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Evan Julian
We have been a few times and always have a great time. The pizza is great, and has that good crispy cheese around the edge. The owner is always engaged with customers.
The only time I had a minor issue, he was quick to fix it and offered an extra drink if I wanted it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Moss
We found out about SSP scrolling through videos and drove 2 hours round-trip to check it out. We are still walking on clouds and we ate this pie last night. We ate 3 pieces and were stuffed with the finest pizza we've eaten. We cannot make this up, we are foodies and OMG! this pizza is FIRE!!! We got El Jefe...the whipped ricotta makes this pie unforgettable...exquisite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jayce
homey neighborhood pizza joint. i don’t like deep dish pizza typically but this place rocked my socks off. i can’t tell you what to get because it’s all good. service is friendly and familial. definitely will be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam Burdge
The family is the best, their food is delicious and their tiramisu is incredible….. please support this family owned local restaurant!
Absolutely delicious. Phenomenal. Friendly service, great pizza shop atmosphere. 10/10
Erick Lopez
I came because of the reviews. But the moment I walked in, I wasn’t too sure. I didn’t see any staff nor guests (only 1 couple) in the restaurant. But the moment Sam walked in, everything changed. Sam was incredibly welcoming, attentive, and knowledgeable. He walked us through what makes his pizza so great, including the quality that goes into preparing his dough. We ordered half of El Jefe and cheese pizza, and both of them were amazing. We decided to take an order to go (Irie) and him and his staff were knowledgeable enough to prepare it in such a way where we can freeze it and reheat it at home. By the end of the visit, his entire place was packed (on a random Thursday night), with both newcomers as well as old timers. He was incredibly attentive to both. Overall, I truly enjoyed coming to this place. The best part was seeing how enthusiastic Sam was at engaging with his customers and creating a welcoming space for them to enjoy his pizza. From a fellow pizza lover to you, this is really good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Mcfly
I've been on the search for my go to pizza place here in Indy and I have finally found it. Every single pizza I have had from here is absolute fire. The staff here are friendly and warm. If you have an opportunity order from here. It may be a little pricey but I guarantee you it's worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Privat
YES YES YES!!! Try this if you haven't. You won't regret it and will be beck the following day for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Turpen
Ist visit to Sam's Square Pie and it was excellent. We had the El Jefe and it was delicious.
finalllllly got to try sam’s square pie for the first time and can’t wait to go back…truly some of the best pizza i’ve ever had. i had 2 pizzas in mind to order: the pepperoni and pepperoni sausage - but the pizza on special (with truffle mushrooms and potato) was calling my name so i left with the triple pepperoni and the special, both absolutely amazing in their own way. and the crust……..YUM. not to mention my friend ordered the granny tomato pie: so classic and so tasty.
we got stuck in the parking lot due to a flat tire and Sam took time out of his busy Saturday evening dinner rush to help us resolve the issue, if that isn’t customer service at its finest idk what is.
great spot all around and i encourage any lover of pizza to head to Sam’s ASAP, you will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good, crunchy, saucy, cheesy goodness!
Love the ricotta topped pepperoni pizza. Good local beers on tap as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Best pizza in Indy hands down! Delicious. Homemade. Prices are reasonable! I definitely recommend 👍👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I came in on Valentines Day for dinner. Dining room was hoppin', plenty of carry out. We have had the pizza before, and loved it! I knew going in that I wanted to try the meatballs. They were served with a wonderful side of fresh mozzarella. Absolutely delicious! Our pizzas were amazing as always. Couldn't have asked for better way to spend the evening with my wife. Pizza, a great beer, good music, great service! Thank you to the whole staff at Sam's, you guys are awesome!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loving Cup, Meatballs
Great service and food was amazingly delicious 😋 👌 😍
Would definitely recommend 👌 👍
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best pizza in Indianapolis. Probably the best in the state! The owner is also extremely kind and so attentive to customers. My only regret is not ordering a bigger pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been a few times and always have a great time. The pizza is great, and has that good crispy cheese around the edge. The owner is always engaged with customers.
The only time I had a minor issue, he was quick to fix it and offered an extra drink if I wanted it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We found out about SSP scrolling through videos and drove 2 hours round-trip to check it out. We are still walking on clouds and we ate this pie last night. We ate 3 pieces and were stuffed with the finest pizza we've eaten. We cannot make this up, we are foodies and OMG! this pizza is FIRE!!! We got El Jefe...the whipped ricotta makes this pie unforgettable...exquisite!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
homey neighborhood pizza joint. i don’t like deep dish pizza typically but this place rocked my socks off. i can’t tell you what to get because it’s all good. service is friendly and familial. definitely will be back!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The family is the best, their food is delicious and their tiramisu is incredible….. please support this family owned local restaurant!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely delicious. Phenomenal. Friendly service, great pizza shop atmosphere. 10/10
I came because of the reviews. But the moment I walked in, I wasn’t too sure. I didn’t see any staff nor guests (only 1 couple) in the restaurant. But the moment Sam walked in, everything changed. Sam was incredibly welcoming, attentive, and knowledgeable. He walked us through what makes his pizza so great, including the quality that goes into preparing his dough. We ordered half of El Jefe and cheese pizza, and both of them were amazing. We decided to take an order to go (Irie) and him and his staff were knowledgeable enough to prepare it in such a way where we can freeze it and reheat it at home. By the end of the visit, his entire place was packed (on a random Thursday night), with both newcomers as well as old timers. He was incredibly attentive to both. Overall, I truly enjoyed coming to this place. The best part was seeing how enthusiastic Sam was at engaging with his customers and creating a welcoming space for them to enjoy his pizza. From a fellow pizza lover to you, this is really good pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been on the search for my go to pizza place here in Indy and I have finally found it. Every single pizza I have had from here is absolute fire. The staff here are friendly and warm. If you have an opportunity order from here. It may be a little pricey but I guarantee you it's worth it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
YES YES YES!!! Try this if you haven't. You won't regret it and will be beck the following day for more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ist visit to Sam's Square Pie and it was excellent. We had the El Jefe and it was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...