Sam's Gyros

5404 N College Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 251-8503

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Shawarma Plate
Spicy Gyro Sandwich
Falafel Sandwich
Hummus with Lamb
Cucumber Sauce
Grilled Chicken
Beef Shawarma
French Fries
Pound Gyros
Greek Salad

Menu

Picked for you
Gyros Sandwich
Lamb and beef broiled on a rotisserie. Served in pita bread with your choice of our famous cucumber sauce, tahini sauce, or sour cream.
Gyros Spicy Sandwich
Gyros slow cooked in onions, tomatoes, and red cayenne pepper with your choice of sauce.
Gyros Plate
Gyros stripes topped with onions, tomatoes, and cucumber sauce. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Chicken Shawarma Sandwich
Marinated chicken grilled with our own blend of spices. Served in pita bread with your choice of sauce.
Falafel Sandwich
Ground chickpeas, onions, and spices deep-fried. Served in pita bread with your choice of hummus-cucumber sauce, tahini sauce, or sour cream.

Appetizers
Hummus
A blend of chickpeas, tahini sauce, garlic, and lemon juice. Served with pita bread.
Sam's Plate
A sampler of hummus, tabouli, baba ghanoush, and falafel. Served with pita bread.
Spanakopita
Feta and cottage cheese with spinach wrapped in filo dough pie.
Saganaki
Kassari cheese dipped in our famous batter, fried, and flamed in the back. Served with pita bread.
Tyropita
Feta and cottage cheese wrapped in filo dough pie.
Hummus with Chicken
Hummus topped with meat. Served with pita bread.
Hummus with Gyros
Hummus topped with meat. Served with pita bread.
Foul
Fava beans mixed with garlic and lemon juice. Served with pita bread.
Baba Ghanouj
Baked eggplant mixed with tahini, lemon juice, and garlic. Served with pita bread.
Hummus with Lamb
Hummus topped with meat. Served with pita bread.

Soups and Salads
Greek Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, feta cheese, and our own dressing.
Lentil Soup
Sam's famous recipe.
Gyro Salad
Greek salad topped with gyros meat.
Small Arabian Salad
Small. Diced tomatoes, cucumbers, parsley, tahini, and lemon juice.
Chicken Salad
Greek salad topped with grilled chicken.
Small Tabouli Salad
Parsley, tomatoes, cracked wheat, and fresh mint tossed with olive oil and lemon juice.

Sandwiches
Gyros Sandwich
Lamb and beef broiled on a rotisserie. Served in pita bread with your choice of our famous cucumber sauce, tahini sauce, or sour cream.
Gyros Spicy Sandwich
Gyros slow cooked in onions, tomatoes, and red cayenne pepper with your choice of sauce.
Falafel Sandwich
Ground chickpeas, onions, and spices deep-fried. Served in pita bread with your choice of hummus-cucumber sauce, tahini sauce, or sour cream.
Chicken Shawarma Sandwich
Marinated chicken grilled with our own blend of spices. Served in pita bread with your choice of sauce.
Philly Steak Sandwich (1/2)
Beef strips with Swiss cheese, onion, tomatoes, and green peppers.
Beef Shawarma Sandwich
Marinated beef grilled with our own blend of spices. Served in pita bread with your choice of sauce.
Chicken Philly Steak Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Hamburger (1/2 lb)
Burger, grilled and served on a bun with lettuce, tomatoes, and onion.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast. Served on a bun with lettuce, tomatoes, and onion.
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
BBQ Chicken Sandwich with Fries and Drink
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with Fries and Drink
Chicken Philly Steak Sandwich with Fries and Drink

Special Combinations
1/2 Gyros with French Fries and Drink
1/2 Gyros with Small Hummus Combination
1/2 Gyros with Salad Combination
1/2 Falafel, French Fries, and Drink Combination
1/2 Gyros with Lentil Soup Combination

Entrees
Gyros Plate
Gyros stripes topped with onions, tomatoes, and cucumber sauce. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Chicken Shawarma Plate
Chicken shawarma over a bed of rice. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Lamb Kabob
Marinated lamb grilled with tomatoes, green pepper, and mushroom. Served on a bed of rice. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Chicken Kabob
Marinated chicken grilled with tomatoes, green pepper, and mushroom. Served on a bed of rice. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Beef Dolmathes
Grape leaves, stuffed with rice, beef, and spices. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Beef Kabob
Marinated beef grilled with tomatoes, green pepper, and mushroom. Served on a bed of rice. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Beef Shawarma Plate
Beef shawarma over a bed of rice. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Tyropita (3 pcs)
Served with a side of rice and green beans. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Spanakopita (3 pcs)
Served with a side of rice and green beans. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Veggie Dolmathes
Grape leaves stuffed with rice pine nuts. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.
Kibby
Ground beef and cracked wheat stuffed with beef, pine nuts, and onions. Served with a side of rice and green beans. Served with small Greek salad and pita bread.

Kids Menu
Kids Chicken Strips
Kids Gyros
Kids Hamburger
Kids Hot Dog

Side Orders
French Fries
Greek Fries
Rice
Rice and Gree

Dessert
Baklava
Layers of pastry with walnuts and cinnamon topped with a sugary glaze.

Beverages
Dr. Pepper
Coke
Orange Fanta
Lemonade
Diet Coke
Bottle Water
Sprite
Hot Tea
Coffee
Turkish Coffee

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+31 photos
Photo credit: google
+30 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Amazing food and excellent customer service. The portions are generous, everything tastes fresh, and the flavors are on point. The staff is very friendly and welcoming, and the prices are fair for the quality. One of the best Mediterranean spots in Fishers
February 2026
The service and food is amazing. The shawerma is the best in town and so is the falafel! It’s packed with flavor and a taste of back home in the middle east. It’s always my go to spot and will never get bored of it!
November 2025
when i moved into the neighborhood the thing i was most excited about was walking to get falafel, and that’s what i do and sam’s is the spot.
nothing too fancy, just traditional falafel, delicious and filling.
perfectly seasoned and herbed, yogurt and veggies, tahini + hummus. friendly pricing.
now i have to go try the coffee…
November 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Twenty Tap - 5406-08 N College Ave
Gastropubs, Bar, American, New American, Vegan
Fat Dan's Deli - 5410 N College Ave
Deli, Barbeque, Chicken Wings, Pet Friendly
The Bulldog Bar and Lounge - 5380 N College Ave
Bar, American, Venues & Event Spaces, Sports Bar, Pet Friendly

Sam's Gyros

5404 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
(317) 251-8503