Sauce on the Side

130 S Pennsylvania St Suite 2, Indianapolis
(317) 757-2859

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Meet Me in St Louie Calzones
Caramel Apple Pie
Magic Carpet Ride
Costanza Calzone
Strawberry Fields
Choice of Sauce
Roasty Toasty
Caesar Salad
Pancho Villa
Figgy Piggy

Menu

Calzones
Feliz Navidad
*DECEMBER SPECIAL* Beef Birria / Quesadilla Cheese / Cilantro Lime Marinated Jalapenos & Onions / Queso Fresco / Served with Cilantro Lime Crèma
Skinny V
Our Vegan Calzone. HAPPY LITTLE PLANTS® Pepperoni / Vegan Mozzarella / White Onion / Green Peppers / Roasted Garlic / Served with Spicy Red Sauce.
Bull's Eye
The Fold
Build Your Own. Start with Mozzarella and Ricotta. Add any fillers and your choice of sauce. Finished with Garlic Oil.
Carmen
Prosciutto / Capicola / Spinach / Parmesan / Fontina / Ricotta / Garlic Oil / Garlic Butter
Cock-A-Doodle Noodle
★As seen on the Travel Channel's Food Paradise!★ Mac ‘n Cheese / Roasted Chicken / Applewood Bacon / PROVEL® Cheese / Mozzarella / Green Onion / Garlic Oil / Buffalo Butter
Costanza
Pepperoni / Eggplant / Roasted Garlic / Basil / Mozzarella / Ricotta / Garlic Honey Oil / House Red Sauce
Duke
BBQ Chicken / Applewood Bacon / Corn Salsa / Smoked Cheddar / Mozzarella / Smoked Chili Oil / BBQ Ranch
Fatty B
Pepperoni / Meatballs / White Onion / Provolone / Roasted Garlic / Mozzarella / Ricotta / Garlic Oil / Spicy Red Sauce
Figgy Piggy
Applewood Bacon / Figs / Balsamic Onions / Garlic Herb Cheese / Mozzarella / Ricotta / Garlic Honey Oil / House Red Sauce
Five-O
Prosciutto / Pineapple / Red Peppers / Smoked Cheddar / Mozzarella / Mascarpone-Ricotta Blend / Smoked Chili Oil / BBQ Sauce
Gonzo
Salami / Dates / Spinach / Garlic Herb Cheese / Mozzarella / Mascarpone-Ricotta Blend / Garlic Oil / Garlic Butter
Hot Mother Clucker
Buffalo Chicken / Fontina / Mozzarella / Applewood Bacon / Red Onions / Bleu Cheese Crumbles / Served with Chipotle Garlic Ranch
Magic Carpet Ride
Button Mushrooms / Crimini, Portabella and Shiitake Mushroom Mix / Minced Garlic / Parmesan / Mozzarella / Ricotta / Garlic Honey Oil / Garlic Butter
Meat Me in St. Louie
Pepperoni / Italian Sausage / PROVEL® Cheese / Mascarpone-Ricotta Blend / Garlic Oil / Meat Sauce
Pancho Villa
Chorizo / Fresh Jalapeños / Red Peppers / Smoked Cheddar / Mozzarella / Smoked Chili Oil / Queso
Roasty Toasty
Pesto Chicken** / Arugula / Red Onion / Toasted Pine Nuts / Mozzarella / Ricotta / Garlic Oil / Roasty Toasty Pesto **Pesto contains nuts & dairy
Which Came First...?
Roasted Chicken / Applewood Bacon / Fresh Jalapeños / Egg Yolk / White Onion / Mozzarella / Smoked Chili Oil / Salsa Verde

Salads
Large Beets Me! Salad
Arugula / Spring Mix / Toasted Walnuts / Mandarin Oranges / Golden Beets / Red Onions / Parmesan Cheese / Citrus Vinaigrette
Small Beets Me! Salad
Arugula / Spring Mix / Toasted Walnuts / Mandarin Oranges / Golden Beets / Red Onions / Parmesan Cheese / Citrus Vinaigrette
Large Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce / Parmesan Cheese / Pesto Croutons** / Red Onions / Caesar Dressing **Pesto contains nuts & dairy.
Small Caesar Salad
Romaine Lettuce / Parmesan Cheese / Pesto Croutons** / Red Onions / Caesar Dressing **Pesto contains nuts & dairy.
Large Italian Salad
Romaine Lettuce / Salami / Artichoke Hearts / Mozzarella / Green Olives / Roasted Red Peppers / Basil / Pear Tomatoes / Rosemary Vinaigrette
Small Italian Salad
Romaine Lettuce / Salami / Artichoke Hearts / Mozzarella / Green Olives / Roasted Red Peppers / Basil / Pear Tomatoes / Rosemary Vinaigrette
Large Smokehouse Salad
Butter Lettuce / Corn Salsa / Applewood Bacon / Smoked Cheddar / Pear Tomatoes / Basil / BBQ Ranch Dressing
Small Smokehouse Salad
Butter Lettuce / Corn Salsa / Applewood Bacon / Smoked Cheddar / Pear Tomatoes / Basil / BBQ Ranch Dressing
Large Strawberry Fields
Spring Mix / Strawberries / Feta / Red Onion / Sage / Mint / Candied Walnuts / White Balsamic Vinaigrette
Small Strawberry Fields
Spring Mix / Strawberries / Feta / Red Onion / Sage / Mint / Candied Walnuts / White Balsamic Vinaigrette

Desserts
Caramel Apple Pie
Hot Cinnamon Apples / Crunchy Graham Crackers / Crumbly Cinnamon Crust / Finished with Caramel Sauce
Nutella(R) Banana
Whipped Nutella® and Mascarpone Cheese / Fresh Sliced Bananas / Finished with Powdered Sugar *Mascarpone Cheese is a sweet Italian cream cheese
S'mores
Chocolate / Marshmallow / Crunchy Graham Crackers / Finished with Chocolate Syrup Drizzle, Mini Marshmallows and Chocolate Chips

Bite Sides
Buffalo Chicken Bites
Served with Chipotle Garlic Ranch.
Jalapeño Cheddar Bites
Served with Strawberry Chipotle Jam
Pepperoni Basil Bites
Served with House Red Sauce.
Spinach Artichoke Bites
Served with Queso Pesto Sauce.

Beverages
Icelandic Water
Coke Can
Sprite Can
Diet Coke Can

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+35 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+34 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I ordered the “Meat me in St. Louis” calzone. The sausage on the particular calzone tasted like it was jimmy deans sausage that I would buy at the store so I can’t give this sandwich the best rating.
The pepperoni was delicious as was the cheese. I am not sure I will try this one again but I I will be back for something without sausage and plenty of pepperoni.
December 2025
This is my new favorite spot in Indy! The service was excellent and I’ve never tasted a calzone like the one I got there and I can’t even tell you how wonderful the smores calzone was it was like nothing I’ve ever ate before! Awesome
December 2025
The food was absolutely excellent. Exactly what you need on a cold wet rainy day for that comfort food vibe. The staff was very nice and brought our food out. Piping hot with a smile. The sodas were unique, especially the ski and Cherry cola option and I am not a soda drinker but I had two glasses with our meal. The sauce pairs excellently with the calzones and the food was super affordable for the massive portion to get. Definitely some place to try and return to again.
December 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Pivot Bar and Balcony - 130 S Pennsylvania St
Cocktail Bar, American, Sports Bar, New American, Vegan
SOS Pub Indianapolis - 30 E Georgia St
Pubs
HotBox Pizza - 30 E Georgia St
Pizza

Sauce on the Side

130 S Pennsylvania St Suite 2, Indianapolis, IN 46204
(317) 757-2859