St. Elmo Steak House

The menu here was very delicious. And also the staff here was very friendly and polite and also the owner was kind. I love how they accommodate their customer. the atmosphere was relaxing. Everything here was amazing!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had such a great experience here! The atmosphere is amazing—you can really feel the history since this place has been around It’s got that classic, timeless vibe that makes dining feel special. The food and service were both excellent; everything came out perfectly, and you could tell they really take pride in what they do. Our waiter, , was fantastic—friendly, attentive, and made the meal even better with his recommendations and great service. One thing I’ll definitely say: don’t skip the shrimp cocktail to start—it’s a total must! Between the historic atmosphere, top-notch food, and stellar service, this spot really delivers on all fronts. I’ll absolutely be coming back next time I’m in the area. Definitely a place I’d recommend for a special night out or just a classic, satisfying meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is my favorite restaurant in the country. I always love getting the shrimp cocktail, cream spinach, mushrooms, red potato mash and w nice ribeye. The food, ambiance, everything is marvelous. I don't go to Indianapolis without stopping by St. Elmos!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

St. Elmo Steak House is an absolute classic. The food is outstanding, the atmosphere is timeless, and the service lives up to the reputation. The shrimp cocktail is a must easily one of the best you’ll ever have. Highly recommend when you’re in Indianapolis.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was absolutely amazing and the service was even better!! Had a reservation on a Saturday night and was immediately seated upon arrival. That shrimp cocktail is delicious but it will clear out the nostrils & make you hear all the colors of the rainbow. Overall the best dining experience!

Our first time at St Elmo did not disappoint. The service and hostess were very friendly and the food was amazing!! The Filet and Prime Ribeye Oscar Style were delicious and more than enough! And the cheesecake!!! It was a religious experience. We will definitely be back to try something new.

Amazing dinner. We celebrated my daughter's birthday and had a fabulous time. Food was excellent and the service was outstanding. Thank you St. Elmo's.

This was our first time to St. Elmos. Overall it was a good experience. Service was great, food was very good. The inclusion of a baked potato and the white bean soup was a great addition. Three of us had the small filet which was very tasty. A little under cooked but yummy. Definitely ask for medium if you want a small bit of warm red in the center. The 4th meal was a rib eye which was a bit thin and no where near as tender as the filet. Wine selection is extensive and priced all over the board. The ‘famous’ shrimp cocktail was good but not close to the hype, but ya gotta try in anyway. All in all a place I would definitely return to.

Our 1st time in Indianapolis and at St Elmo's.. we were met by very polite hostesses and servers. The food and wine was excellent. We thoroughly enjoyed our meal.

The Filet was excellent. We tried the Bean soup, that was very good. The baked potato was perfect. The bread basket was not the usual bread basket, but was very good.

Quick business dinner, we opted for the basement seating. Great choice, a little quieter, and tad bit more space. St Elmo's never disappoints

We love coming to St. Elmo's for our special occasions. We know the food, service and environment will all be excellent every time!

One of the best steaks I have ever eaten. The shrimp cocktail was all that and a bag of chips.

Always love going to Saint Elmo’s steakhouse. Best steaks around!

Atmosphere was very nice and service was great. Filets and desserts were excellent but bone in ribeye was very fatty. Side dishes were average. Crab mac and cheese was very fishy.