The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers

6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis
(317) 257-2253

Recent Reviews

Sort by
diane

It is the world's biggest treat for all of us!!! The service was fantastic . Jeremy was do sweet to my 2 year old grandson.

Lisa

Our host didn't offer a drink refill once on tea or lemonade. So ate most dinner with little water.

Julie

This was a celebration luncheon 4 adult sisters gifted our 80-year-old mother this experience and it did not disappoint. Beautiful rooms, wait staff was literally perfect, food delicious and we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. I knew what to expect, but there was some "sticker shock" especially the cake by the slice prices, for some of the family. So delicious though...definitely worth it for a special occasion.

Allison

What a wonderful atmosphere! We had such a wonderful time celebrating a family birthday! We will definitely be back!

David

First time to the Cake Bake Shop, and it was wonderful. Well-managed, great staff, beautiful space, and delicious food. I will definitely go back!

Ann

It was my birthday and I was being treated to lunch. I ordered the Pick Two - Brie Ham sandwich and the no up charge salad. My friend reviewing the bill asked our server about the $3 upcharge on my salad. I had asked about the one with the Brie but did not get that one honestly to not add an upcharge. The waitress returned to our table and said the manager said the upcharge was correct. It was just an odd ending to a special lunch.

Abigail

Was not impressed with service or the cake. Would not recommend the broad ripple location if celebrating something important

Rebecca Bidlen

Used to be the best cake I’ve ever had in my life. Today I was disappointed. We ordered the Earl’s Court & Cookie Dough. The cake was pretty dry. Used to be a cake I dreamed about so I’m really sad to see something has changed ☹️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Lizzy Roth

I had an amazing experience at Cake Bake. My server Stella was very helpful and my friends and I loved chatting with her!! Highly recommended!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren Holcroft

I had the best experience with my friends on an early Saturday evening. Stella was AMAZING! She kept us entertained and smiling the whole time. I highly recommend her.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brianna Tappendorf

The food and service was amazing. Stella was our server and she was literally the best she was so funny and attentive!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jennifer Priser

Picked up slices of pixie fetti birthday, mint chip and Earls Court cake for a special occasion. I brought them home and we ate them after dinner. Unfortunately no one was wowed by my special surprise and I was really disappointed. Everyone wanted the cake to taste great-and expected it to-but all three slices were dry. Super bummed that I paid $60 for three (big! I’ll give you that) slices of cake and no one was happy.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Mason Barnett

Neka was great!!! Absolutely amazing customer service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kenneth Sposito

Absolutely not worth the cost to eat. Wife and I made a special trip down for a belated kids free Valentines date. This place was raved about, both the food and the cakes. I ordered a $51 steak and frites. The steak was undercooked, tough as rocks, with no flavor but the butter that it was drenched in. The wifes' quiche had no flavor which the server didn't notice was an issue that she took one bite of it and hesitated when she was asked if she wanted it boxed up. We stated our issues to the manager and they did comp a portion of the meal which was appreciated. We ordered some dessert to go in an attempt to save the experience. The chocolate cake I got felt dry and the ganache was oily. The icing on my wife's cakes tasted and felt like crisco with a bit of sugar melting in your mouth. We tried the key lime pie we got for her mother and that also tasted like crisco. We won't even give that to her it was so bad. Ive gotten better steaks at Applebee's for a quarter of the price and I've made key lime pie from scratch that could blow what these PROFESSIONALS made out of the water, and I'm lucky if i don't ruin Ramen noodles. Suffice it to say we will not be going back there ever again. There is nothing there that would make us want to give them another chance. This place is all outside appearances with no substance.

Elise Davis

NEKA IS AMAZING!!! she is so sweet and hilarious, really makes the spirit in the establishment shine. Our experience was amazing with her!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers

6515 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
(317) 257-2253