The Cheesecake Lady
305 W 42nd St, Indianapolis
(317) 608-7411
Customers' Favorites
Strawberry Crunch - Medium 12oz - No Baked Cheesecake Cup
Cookies N' Cream - Medium 12oz - No Baked Cheesecake Cup
Cookies N' Cream - Large 16oz - No Baked Cheesecake Cup
Banana Pudding - Large 16oz - No Baked Cheesecake Cup
Caramel Cake - Medium 12oz - No Baked Cheesecake Cup
Caramel Cake - Large 16oz - No Baked Cheesecake Cup
Strawberry Cheesecake and Oreo Cheesecake
Double Chocolate Brownie Cheesecake Cup
Classic Strawberry Cheesecake Cup 12oz
Classic Strawberry Cheesecake Cup 1lb
Breakfast Galore!
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Thick sliced bacon Egg and cheese on your choice of Bun.
Ham Egg and Cheese
Deli Sliced Ham Egg and Cheese on a Bun
Sausage Egg and Cheese
Sausage patty egg and cheese on a Bun.
Breakfast Beef Polish Sausage
Beef Polish Sausage Egg and Cheese on a Bun.
Breakfast Angus Glizzy
Angus Beef Dog Egg and Cheese on a Bun.
Lunch Frenzy!
Angus Glizzies (Beef Dogs)
Angus beef dogs on a Bun
Beef Polish Sausage
Beef Polish on a Bun
Walking Tacos
Doritos topped with chili and cheese
Frito Pie
Fritos topped with chili and cheese
Lady Sweetz Signature Cookies
Lady Sweetz Chocolate Chip
Enjoy our homemade lady sweetz chocolate chip cookies made from scratch. Secret recipe enjoy our homemade lady sweetz signature cookies made from scratch. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
M&Ms Cookie
Turtle Cookie
White Chocolate Chip Cookie
Lady Sweetz Oatmeal Chocolate Chip
Enjoy our homemade signature oatmeal cookie enjoy our homemade lady sweet signature cookies made from scratch. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Heath Cookie
Lady Sweetz Kitchen Sink
Signature cookies with everything but the kitchen sink enjoy our homemade lady sweet signature cookies made from scratch. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Lady Sweetz Signature Cookie
Enjoy our homemade lady sweet signature cookies made from scratch don't ask how I made them. It's a secret to enjoy our homemade lady-sweet signature cookies made from scratch. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Lady Sweetz Pistachio
Enjoy our homemade lady sweet signature pistachio cookie made from scratch enjoy our homemade lady sweet signature cookies made from scratch. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Lady Sweetz Snicker's Cookie
Lady sweet cookies with peanuts caramel and chocolate chips enjoy our homemade lady sweet signature cookies made from scratch. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Cereal Cookies
Reese's Cookie
Smore's Cookie
Lady Sweetz Oatmeal
Lady Sweetz ButterFinger
Vegan Desserts
Vegan Cookies
Enjoy our large vegan chocolate chip cookies made from scratch enjoy our large cookies made from scratch. Vegan options are available due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Vegan Yellow Cake
Vegan Chocolate Cake!
Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie Cheesecake
Vegan Cheesecake
Vegan Brownie Cheesecake
Vegan Brownie
Vegan Chocolate Cupcake
Venus Cheesecakes
Oreo Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade oreo cheesecake made from scratch and enjoy our various cheesecake desserts. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Strawberry Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade strawberry cheesecake made from scratch enjoy our various cheesecake desserts. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Brownie Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade brownie cheesecake made from scratch and enjoy our various cheesecake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Peach Cobbler Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade peach cobbler cheesecake and enjoy our various cheesecake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Original Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade cheesecake made from scratch and enjoy our various cheesecake desserts. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Cookie Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade cookie cheesecake made from scratch enjoy our various cheesecake desserts. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Chocolate Cheesecake
Cobblers
Cobbler
Enjoy our homemade cobbler and enjoy our various homemade cobbler desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Brownie Cobbler
Cookie Cobbler
Muffins/Vegan Muffins
Banana Bread Muffs
Homemade muffins enjoy our various homemade muffins.
Strawberry Cheesecake Muffs
Enjoy our homemade muffins enjoy our various homemade muffins.
Banana Nut Muffs
Enjoy our homemade banana nut muffins enjoy our various homemade muffins.
Vegan CornBread Muffs
Enjoy our homemade vegan cornbread muffins made from scratch enjoy our various homemade muffins.
Blueberry Cheesecake Muffs
Homemade muffins enjoy our various homemade muffins.
Bacon Cornbread Muffs
CornBread Muffs
Enjoy our homemade cornbread muffins made from scratch enjoy our various homemade muffins.
Pound Cake
Peach Cobbler Pound Cake
Homemade pound cake homemade pound cake.
Pound Cake
Homemade pound cake homemade pound cake.
Oreo Brownie Pound Cake
Homemade pound cake homemade pound cake.
Strawberry Topped Pound Cake
Homemade pound cake topped with strawberries homemade pound cake.
Lemon Pound Cake
Homemade pound cake homemade pound cake.
Peach Cobbler Lemon Pound Cake
Homemade pound cake homemade pound cake.
Strawberry Topped Lemon Cake
Homemade pound cake homemade pound cake.
Pudding
Banana Pudding Cupcake
Homemade vanilla cupcakes with banana pudding and nilla wafers enjoy our various pudding desserts.
Banana Pudding Cake
Homemade cake with banana pudding and nilla wafers enjoy our various pudding desserts.
Corn Pudding
Enjoy our homemade corn pudding made from the scratch old school. Enjoy our various pudding desserts.
Brownies/Vegan Brownies
S'mores Brownie
Enjoy our homemade s'mores brownies made from scratch enjoy our large homemade brownies. Vegan options are available. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Chocolate Brownie
Enjoy our large homemade brownies. Enjoy our large homemade brownies. Vegan options are available. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Turtle Brownie
Enjoy our homemade turtle brownies made from scratch enjoy our large homemade brownies. Vegan options are available. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Strawberry Brownies
HomeMade
Oreo Brownie
Enjoy our homemade oreo brownies enjoy our large homemade brownies. Vegan options are available. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Brownie with Walnuts
Cakes/Vegan Cakes
Pineapple Up and Stuck Cake
Homemade pineapple cake enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Banana Pudding Cake
Homemade cake with banana pudding and nilla wafers enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Yellow
Carrot
Enjoy our homemade carrot cake and enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Chocolate Cake
Cake Cheesecake
Enjoy our homemade cake cheesecake and enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Lemon Cake
Enjoy our homemade lemon cake and enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Red Velvet
Strawberry Cake
Enjoy our homemade strawberry vanilla cake made from scratch and enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations, some items are subject to price changes.
Cherry Delight Cake
Vanilla cake with cherry icing enjoy our various cake desserts. Due to inflations some items are subject to price changes.
Parfaits
Brownie Cheesecake Parfait!
Brownie Banana Pudding Parfait!
HomeMade parfait!
Cake Banana Pudding Parfait!
HomeMade parfait!
Cake Cheesecake Parfait
HomeMade parfait!
Cupcakes/Vegan Cupcakes
Vanilla Cupcake
Chocolate Cupcake
Enjoy our homemade chocolate cupcake try our homemade cupcakes. Vegan options are available made from scratch.
Red Velvet Cupcake
Homemade chocolate cupcakes with caramel icing topped with pecans or walnuts try our homemade cupcakes. Vegan options are available made from scratch.
Strawberry Cupcake
Enjoy our homemade strawberry cupcakes try our homemade cupcakes. Vegan options are available made from scratch.
Lemon Cupcake
Enjoy our homemade lemon cupcakes try our homemade cupcakes. Vegan options are available made from scratch.
Carrot Cake Cupcake
Homemade vanilla cupcakes with cookie dough icing try our homemade cupcakes. Vegan options are available made from scratch.
Cherry Delight Cupcake
Vanilla cupcakes with cherry icing try our homemade cupcakes. Vegan options are available made from scratch.
For Yo Petz
Peanut Butter Apple Doggy Cakes
Homemade dog cake made with peanut butter and applesauce. Contains pure pumpkin more options visit yo petz bakery. Homemade cupcakes and doggy cakes made with flour, baking soda, eggs with no shell, pure pumpkin, all-natural peanut butter, unsweetened applesauce, carrots, and honey.
Peanut Butter Pumpkin Pupcakes
Homemade cupcakes made with all-natural peanut butter. Contains applesauce more options visit yo petz bakery. Homemade cupcakes and doggy cakes made with flour, baking soda, eggs with no shell, pure pumpkin, all-natural peanut butter, unsweetened applesauce, carrots, and honey.
Peanut Butter Pumpkin Doggy Cakes
Homemade dog cake made with pure pumpkin and applesauce. Contains peanut butter. For more options visit yo petz bakery. Homemade cupcakes and doggy cakes made with flour, baking soda, eggs with no shell, pure pumpkin, all-natural peanut butter, unsweetened applesauce, carrots, and honey.
Honey Carrot Pupcakes
Homemade cupcakes made with carrots and all-natural peanut butter. Contains honey more options visit yo petz bakery. Homemade cupcakes and doggy cakes made with flour, baking soda, eggs with no shell, pure pumpkin, all-natural peanut butter, unsweetened applesauce, carrots, and honey.
Apple Carrot Doggy Cakes
Homemade dog cake made with applesauce and carrots. Contains peanut butter. For more options visit yo petz bakery. Homemade cupcakes and doggy cakes made with flour, baking soda, eggs with no shell, pure pumpkin, all-natural peanut butter, unsweetened applesauce, carrots, and honey.
Gluten-Free/Sugar-Free
Gluten-Free Brownie
Gluten-Free Yellow Cake
Sugar-Free Yellow Cake!
topped w/ sugar-free chocolate icing
Gluten-Free Chocolate Cake
Gluten-Free Cornbread
Sugar-Free Brownie
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Seen her on TikTok and just had to go try her cheesecakes. We tried the brownie cheesecake the strawberry crumble cheesecake, the brownie cheesecake and the blueberry cheesecake and of course the cinnamon roll. All was really good everything less then $55 not bad at all. Go check her cheesecakes out you will not be disappointed. You can get your cheesecake and gas all in the same parking lot can’t be this service.
January 2026
My kids and I had tried her sampler...and it was the BEST!! I had bought my celebratory cake for finishing school. I cant wait to try it!!! She is flexible and her price is reasonable. If you like cheesecake, I highly recommend. And her caramel cake is super moist!!! Super tasty
December 2025
You May Also Like
Twisted Wings - 4148 Boulevard Pl
![]()
Chicken Wings, Pet Friendly
Chilly Water Tap Room - 4155 Boulevard Pl
![]()
Brewpubs, Pubs
Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington - 4155 Boulevard Pl
![]()
Cheesesteaks, Vegan
It’s such a cute little place, served by a sweet employee (I’m sure they’re all sweet!), and I love the samples. I didn’t grab a sample, however, I appreciate the generous amount you get.
I hope to see you expand in a bigger building that would allow more customers to sit down at once and socialize.
Can’t wait...