Tilly's Tea Room
8701 Keystone Crossing, Indianapolis
(317) 816-0171
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Celebrates my mom's birthday at Tilly's. It was a great experience. She loved everything. It was her first time experiencing an afternoon tea! I'm appreciative I could spend this experience with her!
Oh my goodness, this place is beautiful and the 2 staff ladies were just lovely! We all really enjoyed our food and tea. My friend enjoyed her Diet Coke:) We ordered the traditional tea for $45 and a couple of other items: Chicken Velvet Soup and a Chicken Salad Croissant. Everything was very yummy-the egg salad, the cucumber sandwiches, and the soup. The tiny desserts were yummy too. A fun place for everyone, but it is a very quiet and beautiful place, so maybe not for a time when the kids need to run around and be energetic. Please go. You don't have to have tea. It's just a sweet, lovely experience for a luncheon or an afternoon break.
Definitely a cute place for girls to hang out. Service was good. One waitress seemed she needed more training though. She talked too quietly I couldn't barely hear her even though the place was quiet. First she bright out soup without a spoon so we had to wait for it. She served us a tea spoon, not a soup spoon. Food came out but she forgot to give us a plates. We had to waive at other waitress for the plates. Food was just ok but teas were excellent.
My sister in law and I went in for afternoon tea. We were immediately sat and greeted by our wonderful server. She was amazing and gave great suggestions on teas and finger sandwiches to try. We split the afternoon tea and were stuffed when we left. Great experience! We both want to come back again.
A really nice place to go for tea or lunch. Our server was so nice . The atmosphere is calming because it isn't noisy. The tea food was really delicious. So glad Tilley's is back. It was worth the wait.❤️
I love this place. I have been there multiple times. The last time I went was their last day before they closed at Sak’s. They accommodated allergies. We had a group of 8 for the traditional tea. It was a lovely time. The owner is a gracious and sweet woman. I definitely will go to their new location when it opens and can’t wait to try Max and Tilly’s, their new fish and chips location!
Dietary restrictions: Corn and sulfite free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Afternoon Tea
Super annoyed! I booked my reservation over a month ago for a bachelorette party. Two days ago I received an email (after they had already closed for the day) saying my reservation was cancelled! I go to their website to contact them to see why it was cancelled since the email provided NO context and I see that they’re closing. The least they could’ve done was provide an email saying why they were cancelling.
Went to their Facebook page to see when they announced they were closing since I booked OVER A MONTH AGO, to see that their latest post says they’re continuing booking events at partnered locations? Okay, so why was my reservation cancelled with no notice or reason instead of contacting me to see if we would be able to go to another location?
This would’ve been our first time visiting and the whole party was super excited since we’ve heard great things but this was a completely unprofessional way of handling customers. So disappointed.
was just straight up a terrible time. we arrived was welcomed with menus and for whatever reason we weren’t able to order our own selection of food. what we received was basically their sample plate which was $35 PER person. with this being said the food was just absolutely mid. nothing special about anything on the plates. best thing they had was the water. then they just decided to add 20% gratuity without permission. i had initially planned on tipping more but with being said my experience is not what i had hoped for the money. i paid for 12 puny items that had little to no flavor. thanks for wasting my time and money.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I took my two daughters,sister and niece to tea at Tillys. It took an hour to receive water for the table and a little over an hour for our tea service. The waitress was a little detached. The sandwiches had great flavor except the bread was hard, you could tell they were made in advance. The assortment of teas were good. The tea came out tepid at best. The princess tea was cute but not enough food for a 7 year old. We did enjoy the experience and our time together. Be prepared to spend a little over 2 hours there. And we stopped for pizza on our way home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Scone
I cannot say enough good about this place. I wanted to do something special for my Mom's 70th birthday. Some things caused us to be late for our reservation, but Debbie was absolutely incredible making sure we still had the opportunity to enjoy the experience to its fullest. She was so accommodating and made sure that we didn't feel rushed. Everything was just so perfect from the service and presentation to the atmosphere and taste of every single item. We loved our afternoon tea. We did afternoon tea and share with a friend and the amounts were perfect for the two of us. The display of the teas and all the treats were perfectly charming. We loved each of the finger sandwiches and the scones and desserts were amazing. I can't wait to come again whenever we have a celebration that we want to add a special touch to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Afternoon Tea, Scone
Restaurantji Recommends
Love it here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Very difficult to find due to being in Saks on the 3rd level but there is no signage. Had reservations, but our table was given to a walk in. And then when we got a table we waited for over an hour and never got our food. We got our tea but it was about 30 minutes into the wait. We had to drink it as it got cold waiting for the food. We ended up just leaving some money for the tea and leaving because we had other plans we did not want to be late for.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Waitress did not acknowledge us for an hour! Yes an hour! Took another hour for our food. Never checked on us or refilled drinks. Horrible service and food. Was forced to tip 30% for a long wait and the food was not good. Left today and will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Debbie provides the best service l! So personable& friendly. You don’t even have to ask for a refill, etc. She’s on it!
Service: 5
I just wanted to take a moment to give our server Debbie and shoutout. She was very attentive and so sweet :) if Debbie is your server, you will be in wonderful hands!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scone
Loading...