The Eatery

1125 S Seventeenth St, Kokomo
(765) 457-4595

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joseph

Beautiful friendly family owned Italian restaurant. The best Chicken parm I have ever eaten and I have traveled the world!

Suanne

Awesome place to eat and enjoy friends and family. Great atmosphere and not noisy! Love the food and my favorite is the Pollo Piccata! Delicious!

Frank

Crowded game day dinner. Service was very good food was good-a couple dishes not as hot as we'd prefer however: lasagne). Will go back overall very good

Alex

This was an amazing venue! Great atmosphere, food and drinks! Will be back for the 3rd time here soon.

Mary

Always a wonderful experience from delicious entrees to desserts! Especially the wedding cake slices!! A very warm and welcoming atmosphere. Audriana is the best!! Thank you for a delicious meal each and every time.

Don

The food was very good with Italian zesty flavor. Angela was a very attentive server getting everything on time!

Jan

We enjoyed a wonderful experience in one of the corner tables where we enjoyed our party experience of 6 family members. The food was delicious and our server was great!

Albert

Everything was perfect- service, attention and food. This is a great family friendly restaurant where the staff really cares about your experience.

Monique

Great place to have a nice dinner. The new tables, and table lights really have improved the atmosphere. The service is fantastic and they take great care of of you. Thank you for a lovely meal!

Jeff & Sheryl

I can't wait to go back! The food was phenomenal and the tarimasu was the best I have ever had!

Mark

Highly recommend you trying Carmela's at Macri's, they won't disappoint. Food is fantastic!

Rick

Great time at former Macri's as usual! Mozzarella fritta still the best around. Great service!

Dalton

Carmela's has an amazingly quaint atmosphere. The service is outstanding and the food is even better.

Sharon

On a good note, we had excellent service! Our server was very friendly, knowledgeable and attentive! She was kind enough to ask the bartender if they could make me a peach Bellini, which they did and it was awesome! Unfortunately, the food was only so-so at best. Our adult grandson was highly disappointed in the carbonara, which contained huge hunks of uncooked bacon. It was as if they chopped it in a stack and failed to separate it while cooking! He ate maybe a quarter of his entree. My husband had the chicken parmigiana and I had the eggplant parmigiana. Ours were decent, but nothing special. We felt the entire meal was overpriced for what we received.

Kurt

I had the shrimp scampi and it was good, not great. For dessert I had the chocolate bomba and it was fantastic. I've had many meals here and it's always good to great. Good selection of beer and wine, they have hard liquor too. I highly recommend Carmela's.

Loading...