I ordered the buffalo chicken, with banana peppers and jalapenos on top and it arrived tiny bit over an hour later. I thought it was good but it didn't come with the hot sauce or ranch drizzles which I was looking forward to! :( Also, the garlic sauce that came with tastes so bad (It tastes like the container it's in)
I'm operating with two handicaps when I review local pizzerias... 1. I'm Sicilian - I have family in a little olive and citrus grove close enough to Mount Aetna that the SOUND of the active volcano gets cursed with imprecations that I refuse to translate here, on a family site, for fear of a permanent, life long ban... Sicilians invented pizza... 2. I'm from Chicago, Illinois... Chicago pizza is uniquely world renowned for it's craft, art, and incomparable presence... As it is gently slid from the scorching oven paddle and quietly steams, mammoth taste awaiting to be conquered, but only with the love and pride it deserves... I, ummm, well, I take pizza pretty damn serious.... So.... My opinion, then, is that using Chicago pizza as The Bar to judge ANY other pizza is counterintuitive... To review non-Chicago local pies I act the part of someone who has NEVER had pizza and start fresh... This place..? They know how to craft a heck of a pie and hands down are in the top three of where to get one done right and hot and quick - TIP YOUR DELIVERY PEOPLE, people.... Unsung heroes who I hope never unionize, we'd all be chumped if that ever happens... And when I say top three, well, the other two are probably not who you may think - the first place I hit for a local pie 9 years ago was all "... In business forever, I'll meet ya' there... " I've microwaved better pizza in the camper and was disgusted - that's a story for another time... But really, what did it for me, here..? What iced the cake..? My younger sister (52, she's gonna kill me) can enjoy virtually any pie she puts her mind to - her food sensitivities are so acute that dining out can be made into a real medical issue for her if she doesn't watch EVERYTHING she consumed, and Mad Mushroom has menu choices for her that Chicago can't hold a candle to.... Mad Mushroom rocks - no restrictions on quality, appearance, taste and service for the dietetically challenged and when I had a slice of vegan, gluten- free, lactose free pie, I took a polite nibble, and tasted pizza not styrofoam ( again, separate story here but I was six when styrofoam cups hit the market, my cousins told me to taste it because if you chew and swallow they told me it was like cotton candy, so I know whereof I speak. OK..?) REWARD YOURSELF - This is fine food...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karie Gerdes
We stopped here with a group of boys after my son's bday party. Service was friendly and the food was made quick. Everyone said it was some of the best pizza we've had. The cheesticks were amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill DeWitt
Darn good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Kathleen McIlwain
I went there and got their cheesestixs on free cheesestix day. They were very nice and explained the rules to me. It was fast service as well. The cheesestixs were good. They even gave you a free dipping sauce to go with it. I been here before and got their pizza. Pizza has always been very good too. They have deals all the time. Just check online for them and sign up to get emails from them as well.
Parking: There isnt alot of parking spaces but most people get it to go so there seems to always be a spot open.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesestix
Erika Sussman
We were hungry on the road traveling back down to Indianapolis, and decided to try the Mad Mushroom! The guys working in the kitchen are super friendly and took our order quickly. We got a large half cheese/half mushroom pizza as well as an order of plain wings with ranch. The pizza was delicious! I loved the pizza sauce they use and the cheese was perfectly broiled. We thought the prices were very reasonable for a pizza restaurant. Although not the most welcoming building at first, we had a great experience and will definitely be back if we find ourselves in Lafayette again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza
Tim Brown
Tried the taco pizza. It was good but not really taco tasting.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mr. Gunter
I call and asked they have any specials. I get told no. I order. Once I walk in there is a TV with EIGHT DIFFERENT SPECIALS!!! Talk about garbage service. There is Two Mad Mushrooms. Don't not order from this one. They will lie to you.
Got Mad Mushroom Sunday, we ordered the “Mad Combo” which is a I think medium pizza and cheese sticks then we also ordered a large cheese sticks. Our total was $46 even. My son had friends over to work on his car so we had to feed several teenage boys. The lady that checked us out told me it was $46, I gave her a $50 bill and she gave me $4 back. I always get a receipt everywhere I go but for some reason she didn’t give me one or ask if I wanted my receipt and unfortunately I didn’t think about it. Got home opened the 3 boxes. The smaller cheese sticks looked like it had been cooked a little longer and when you picked the sticks up there was standing grease in the box under the entire cheese sticks. The pizza and large cheese sticks were perfect!! The next day “grandma” (the one that ordered and paid for the MM) realized she wasn’t charged correctly. They told her they could correct it and to bring the receipt in. Well unfortunately we weren’t given one and I forgot to ask for it. I’m pretty sure they have record in their computer of the order and the money that was paid and change given. It’s never cost us this much before. It should have been around $38 plus tax. Yeah we wouldn’t have gotten much money back but I just wish we were charged the correct amount in the beginning and the medium cheese sticks weren’t soooo greasy. We ended up not eating much of that one but it’s ok! But we will definitely GO BACK TO GET MORE when we are in the mood for Mad Mushroom. You can’t find cheese sticks as good as MM!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesestix
Indiana Spartan
Never doubt it will be amazing pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Buckels
Great pizza better than pizza hut
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizza
Brittany Butler
A group of us from work ordered lunch, they ordered pizza and I ordered a chicken club grinder NO cheese and light mayo. Order was delivered quickly. I grabbed my sandwich, the label on it was labeled correctly, I opened it and it was covered in cheese (top and bottom piece of bread) . I called and told them that my sandwich was not correct, the lady got the manager on the phone and he started off our conversation with “so you’re telling me your sandwich has cheese on it” yes I am telling you that. He proceeded to tell me that he knows the sandwich was made correctly because they just made it, and says “well I guess I’ll have to take your word “ and then says well make a new one. His attitude was horrible for a manager. New sandwich arrives and delivery person tells me he needs the wrong sandwich back because it’s going to come out of his paycheck. I tell him that I gave the sandwich to a coworker because places don’t take incorrect food back once it’s been delivered. He had a horrible attitude and started to raise his voice and said, well I’ll have to call my boss because I need to take it back. (I’ve had the wrong order delivered from a lot of places, and not a single one has needed to take it back. It’s not like you can give it to somebody else). He proceeds to tell me, just like his boss did, that he made the sandwich with no cheese. I again tell him that the one I got had cheese. He asked me if it had chicken on it and I said no because when I asked my coworker who ended up having the sandwich, she said it was definitely not a chicken club. Delivery guy says, well then they bagged it incorrectly. He then threw it on the front desk and as he was leaving said “I guess it will be coming out of my paycheck” all while still having a horrible attitude . On top of all of this, he did it while in the lobby of the doctors office I work at WHILE patients were in the waiting room. I have absolutely zero reason to lie about cheese being on a sandwich, so I don’t appreciate being called a liar by the manager and the delivery guy. HORRIBLE experience.
Amazing barbecue, chicken pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered the buffalo chicken, with banana peppers and jalapenos on top and it arrived tiny bit over an hour later. I thought it was good but it didn't come with the hot sauce or ranch drizzles which I was looking forward to! :( Also, the garlic sauce that came with tastes so bad (It tastes like the container it's in)
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
?Gluten Free crust option ?
Cheese Stix ?
Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mad Mushroom, Crustless Pizza, Cheesestix
I'm operating with two handicaps when I review local pizzerias...
1. I'm Sicilian - I have family in a little olive and citrus grove close enough to Mount Aetna that the SOUND of the active volcano gets cursed with imprecations that I refuse to translate here, on a family site, for fear of a permanent, life long ban...
Sicilians invented pizza...
2. I'm from Chicago, Illinois...
Chicago pizza is uniquely world renowned for it's craft, art, and incomparable presence...
As it is gently slid from the scorching oven paddle and quietly steams, mammoth taste awaiting to be conquered, but only with the love and pride it deserves...
I, ummm, well, I take pizza pretty damn serious....
So....
My opinion, then, is that using Chicago pizza as The Bar to judge ANY other pizza is counterintuitive...
To review non-Chicago local pies I act the part of someone who has NEVER had pizza and start fresh...
This place..?
They know how to craft a heck of a pie and hands down are in the top three of where to get one done right and hot and quick - TIP YOUR DELIVERY PEOPLE, people.... Unsung heroes who I hope never unionize, we'd all be chumped if that ever happens...
And when I say top three, well, the other two are probably not who you may think - the first place I hit for a local pie 9 years ago was all "... In business forever, I'll meet ya' there... "
I've microwaved better pizza in the camper and was disgusted - that's a story for another time...
But really, what did it for me, here..?
What iced the cake..?
My younger sister (52, she's gonna kill me) can enjoy virtually any pie she puts her mind to - her food sensitivities are so acute that dining out can be made into a real medical issue for her if she doesn't watch EVERYTHING she consumed, and Mad Mushroom has menu choices for her that Chicago can't hold a candle to....
Mad Mushroom rocks - no restrictions on quality, appearance, taste and service for the dietetically challenged and when I had a slice of vegan, gluten- free, lactose free pie, I took a polite nibble, and tasted pizza not styrofoam ( again, separate story here but I was six when styrofoam cups hit the market, my cousins told me to taste it because if you chew and swallow they told me it was like cotton candy, so I know whereof I speak. OK..?)
REWARD YOURSELF - This is fine food...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped here with a group of boys after my son's bday party. Service was friendly and the food was made quick. Everyone said it was some of the best pizza we've had. The cheesticks were amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Darn good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I went there and got their cheesestixs on free cheesestix day. They were very nice and explained the rules to me. It was fast service as well. The cheesestixs were good. They even gave you a free dipping sauce to go with it. I been here before and got their pizza. Pizza has always been very good too. They have deals all the time. Just check online for them and sign up to get emails from them as well.
Parking: There isnt alot of parking spaces but most people get it to go so there seems to always be a spot open.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesestix
We were hungry on the road traveling back down to Indianapolis, and decided to try the Mad Mushroom! The guys working in the kitchen are super friendly and took our order quickly. We got a large half cheese/half mushroom pizza as well as an order of plain wings with ranch. The pizza was delicious! I loved the pizza sauce they use and the cheese was perfectly broiled. We thought the prices were very reasonable for a pizza restaurant. Although not the most welcoming building at first, we had a great experience and will definitely be back if we find ourselves in Lafayette again.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Pizza
Tried the taco pizza. It was good but not really taco tasting.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
I call and asked they have any specials. I get told no. I order. Once I walk in there is a TV with EIGHT DIFFERENT SPECIALS!!! Talk about garbage service. There is Two Mad Mushrooms. Don't not order from this one. They will lie to you.
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Got Mad Mushroom Sunday, we ordered the “Mad Combo” which is a I think medium pizza and cheese sticks then we also ordered a large cheese sticks. Our total was $46 even. My son had friends over to work on his car so we had to feed several teenage boys. The lady that checked us out told me it was $46, I gave her a $50 bill and she gave me $4 back. I always get a receipt everywhere I go but for some reason she didn’t give me one or ask if I wanted my receipt and unfortunately I didn’t think about it. Got home opened the 3 boxes. The smaller cheese sticks looked like it had been cooked a little longer and when you picked the sticks up there was standing grease in the box under the entire cheese sticks. The pizza and large cheese sticks were perfect!!
The next day “grandma” (the one that ordered and paid for the MM) realized she wasn’t charged correctly. They told her they could correct it and to bring the receipt in. Well unfortunately we weren’t given one and I forgot to ask for it.
I’m pretty sure they have record in their computer of the order and the money that was paid and change given. It’s never cost us this much before. It should have been around $38 plus tax.
Yeah we wouldn’t have gotten much money back but I just wish we were charged the correct amount in the beginning and the medium cheese sticks weren’t soooo greasy. We ended up not eating much of that one but it’s ok!
But we will definitely GO BACK TO GET MORE when we are in the mood for Mad Mushroom. You can’t find cheese sticks as good as MM!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheesestix
Never doubt it will be amazing pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza better than pizza hut
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Pizza
A group of us from work ordered lunch, they ordered pizza and I ordered a chicken club grinder NO cheese and light mayo. Order was delivered quickly. I grabbed my sandwich, the label on it was labeled correctly, I opened it and it was covered in cheese (top and bottom piece of bread) . I called and told them that my sandwich was not correct, the lady got the manager on the phone and he started off our conversation with “so you’re telling me your sandwich has cheese on it” yes I am telling you that. He proceeded to tell me that he knows the sandwich was made correctly because they just made it, and says “well I guess I’ll have to take your word “ and then says well make a new one. His attitude was horrible for a manager. New sandwich arrives and delivery person tells me he needs the wrong sandwich back because it’s going to come out of his paycheck. I tell him that I gave the sandwich to a coworker because places don’t take incorrect food back once it’s been delivered. He had a horrible attitude and started to raise his voice and said, well I’ll have to call my boss because I need to take it back. (I’ve had the wrong order delivered from a lot of places, and not a single one has needed to take it back. It’s not like you can give it to somebody else). He proceeds to tell me, just like his boss did, that he made the sandwich with no cheese. I again tell him that the one I got had cheese. He asked me if it had chicken on it and I said no because when I asked my coworker who ended up having the sandwich, she said it was definitely not a chicken club. Delivery guy says, well then they bagged it incorrectly. He then threw it on the front desk and as he was leaving said “I guess it will be coming out of my paycheck” all while still having a horrible attitude . On top of all of this, he did it while in the lobby of the doctors office I work at WHILE patients were in the waiting room. I have absolutely zero reason to lie about cheese being on a sandwich, so I don’t appreciate being called a liar by the manager and the delivery guy. HORRIBLE experience.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Clean place and the pizza taste very good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Loading...