Hinkle's Sandwich Shop

Name: Hinkle's Sandwich Shop
Address: 204 W Main St, Madison, Indiana, 47250, US
Telephone: (812) 265-3919
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

$ • Sandwich Shops, Burgers

Hours:
204 W Main St, Madison
(812) 265-3919

About Hinkle's Sandwich Shop

Hinkle's Sandwich Shop in Madison continues to offer great food and service in a small, unassuming setting. Their impressive selection of milkshakes, particularly the standout banana split flavor, remains a unique attraction. The flavorful burgers, especially the cheeseburger described as absolutely primo, and the hidden gem chili & cornbread are worth trying, along with the hashbrowns with cheese and gravy.

This long-standing establishment, in business since 1933, provides a small-town, down-home atmosphere. Customers can sit at the bar and watch the cooks prepare the food in the old-fashioned way or dine in the cozy dining area. The friendly staff and made-to-order meals create an enjoyable dining experience, although some customers have noted occasional service issues.

Located in the downtown area, Hinkle's is a popular destination for both locals and visitors, who often plan their trips around a visit to the restaurant for a great, affordable meal. Customers have remarked on the generous portions and nostalgic feel of the place, with sandwiches that remind some of the flavors of White Castle, but much better.