This place is great! A huge variety of pizzas with uncommon pizza toppings. I really enjoy visiting this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lee Adrianson
Was in town for a quick mini vacation and stopped in here for a bite. We chose the chicken bacon ranch pizza and breadsticks. Food was delicious. Definitely homemade not boxed. People were friendly and prices decent. If I were feeling more adventurous,I would have tried one of the uncommon and unique offerings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elissa McKee
The family played some of the pizza themed games and all had a great time while we waited for our ? . We got the fire sticks & pepperoni sticks. The dough was ?. We got the lemon chicken and pesto Gorgonzola pizzas (I don’t remember the names) on gluten free and I couldn’t stop eating. So good. I’d love to come back and try the vegan options.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free & Dairy Free options. Taste good!Kid-friendliness: Games and pizza - kids happy!Wheelchair accessibility: Father is in a motorized chair, got in and seated with no issues.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything, Pepperoni Sticks
Crystal Moore
Dietary restrictions: Large vegan menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hannah
I placed a very large order for a work lunch, and Pizza Uncommon did an AMAZING job at tackling it and getting it to us in a good amount of time. The pizzas are amazing, the wings are delicious, the breadsticks are killer, the desserts are almost sinfully good, and on top of the amazing service, you cannot go wrong with Uncommon! Thank you all so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Flyinghigh 21
Got the Taco Pizza with Doritos. It was very special and filling. Young man at the register did a great job and the rest of the staff was very friendly. Would highly recommend if you want to try something different besides the same old stuff.Kid-friendliness: Have puzzles and board games for the kiddos.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Elizabeth Mckittrick
Gave me food poisoning
Chris Rumfelt
This pizza is absolutely amazing and fresh!! The crust is delicious light and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
S L
I like their pizzas, but I don't think they know what they're doing there. They've messed up my take out order the last three times I've been there. I don't think I'm going to order from them again.
I'd heard quite a buzz about this little pizza place in Madison from other friends in IN (as their first location is in the college town of West Lafayette). So a vegan friend from Cincinnati and I decided to meet up in this picturesque river town for a day of shopping. We started off with lunch at Pizza Uncommon.Pizza Uncommon is located on the corner of Main St. Street parking is widely available and we found spots right away on a Sat at lunchtime. The dining room is fairly spacious but can be a bit tricky to maneuver when they're busy - since you order at the counter rather than have table service.They have an extensive vegan menu that includes a variety of bread sticks, pizzas, and desserts. The vegan "meats and cheese" are made by Be-Hive in Nashville (delicious!).We decided on the vegan pepperoni bread sticks with garlic sauce and a medium garden pizza. The sticks were amazing but the pizza was a bit soggy - could've been from all the veggies. We ate our fill and had half a pizza left over. We'll definitely be back!
Joe Durham
We got the " Dragon" pizza. .....it was Amazing. Has a good spice that punches but has so many flavors that balance it. They will definitely be a stop for us whenever we go to Madison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
GaryS849
Not much sauce and what was on the pizza didn’t have much taste. Crust was overdone on the bottom. Far from the best pizza I have ever had. Great atmosphere I just expected more.
Bethany
Ordered a VEGAN pizza only to be served a entirely NON vegan pizza and didn't realize until the real pizza came out later after the non-vegan pizza had been consumed...I'm deeply confused by how this happened when we were given a number for our table and the woman who took the (vegan) order delivered the pizza to the table...?Regardless of anything, I understand human error but don't offer a vegan option if you don't care enough to actually deliver what you offer and when the front is brought to your awareness, no compensation is offered. It makes one paranoid when you can't trust businesses to give you what they actually offer and have an entire vegan menu.Dietary restrictions: They have an entire vegan menu but it seems you must repeatedly ask and confirm it's really vegan.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Emma Goodrich (Genie)
I didn’t want pizza, then saw this place & knew it was a must. Superb selection for diverse taste, fits any craving. The pepperoni honey breadsticks are phenomenal, all local & handcrafted goodness awaits.
This place is great! A huge variety of pizzas with uncommon pizza toppings. I really enjoy visiting this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was in town for a quick mini vacation and stopped in here for a bite. We chose the chicken bacon ranch pizza and breadsticks. Food was delicious. Definitely homemade not boxed. People were friendly and prices decent. If I were feeling more adventurous,I would have tried one of the uncommon and unique offerings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The family played some of the pizza themed games and all had a great time while we waited for our ? . We got the fire sticks & pepperoni sticks. The dough was ?. We got the lemon chicken and pesto Gorgonzola pizzas (I don’t remember the names) on gluten free and I couldn’t stop eating. So good. I’d love to come back and try the vegan options.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free & Dairy Free options. Taste good!Kid-friendliness: Games and pizza - kids happy!Wheelchair accessibility: Father is in a motorized chair, got in and seated with no issues.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything, Pepperoni Sticks
Dietary restrictions: Large vegan menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I placed a very large order for a work lunch, and Pizza Uncommon did an AMAZING job at tackling it and getting it to us in a good amount of time. The pizzas are amazing, the wings are delicious, the breadsticks are killer, the desserts are almost sinfully good, and on top of the amazing service, you cannot go wrong with Uncommon! Thank you all so much!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got the Taco Pizza with Doritos. It was very special and filling. Young man at the register did a great job and the rest of the staff was very friendly. Would highly recommend if you want to try something different besides the same old stuff.Kid-friendliness: Have puzzles and board games for the kiddos.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gave me food poisoning
This pizza is absolutely amazing and fresh!! The crust is delicious light and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything
I like their pizzas, but I don't think they know what they're doing there. They've messed up my take out order the last three times I've been there. I don't think I'm going to order from them again.
Saw a horse eating a man beside the
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
I'd heard quite a buzz about this little pizza place in Madison from other friends in IN (as their first location is in the college town of West Lafayette). So a vegan friend from Cincinnati and I decided to meet up in this picturesque river town for a day of shopping. We started off with lunch at Pizza Uncommon.Pizza Uncommon is located on the corner of Main St. Street parking is widely available and we found spots right away on a Sat at lunchtime. The dining room is fairly spacious but can be a bit tricky to maneuver when they're busy - since you order at the counter rather than have table service.They have an extensive vegan menu that includes a variety of bread sticks, pizzas, and desserts. The vegan "meats and cheese" are made by Be-Hive in Nashville (delicious!).We decided on the vegan pepperoni bread sticks with garlic sauce and a medium garden pizza. The sticks were amazing but the pizza was a bit soggy - could've been from all the veggies. We ate our fill and had half a pizza left over. We'll definitely be back!
We got the " Dragon" pizza. .....it was Amazing. Has a good spice that punches but has so many flavors that balance it. They will definitely be a stop for us whenever we go to Madison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Not much sauce and what was on the pizza didn’t have much taste. Crust was overdone on the bottom. Far from the best pizza I have ever had. Great atmosphere I just expected more.
Ordered a VEGAN pizza only to be served a entirely NON vegan pizza and didn't realize until the real pizza came out later after the non-vegan pizza had been consumed...I'm deeply confused by how this happened when we were given a number for our table and the woman who took the (vegan) order delivered the pizza to the table...?Regardless of anything, I understand human error but don't offer a vegan option if you don't care enough to actually deliver what you offer and when the front is brought to your awareness, no compensation is offered. It makes one paranoid when you can't trust businesses to give you what they actually offer and have an entire vegan menu.Dietary restrictions: They have an entire vegan menu but it seems you must repeatedly ask and confirm it's really vegan.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
I didn’t want pizza, then saw this place & knew it was a must. Superb selection for diverse taste, fits any craving. The pepperoni honey breadsticks are phenomenal, all local & handcrafted goodness awaits.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Everything