The Red Pepperoni

842 W Main St, Madison
(812) 274-0111

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joey Reed

This was some of the best pizza I've had in a long long time. The spices and herbs were perfectly balanced, plenty of topping and just the right amount of cheese. My wife and I ordered the three-topping lunch special which came with a garden salad (or bread sticks) and a drink. Great deal.

The food and service were so good, we were back for lunch the next day.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jimmie Eaton

They forgot half my order

Food: 4

Service: 3

Alishatravels4life

We chose sandwiches for lunch. Meatball sub, Stromboli, Italian sub, calzone. The beer choices was 5 star! Reasonable price. $51 for 4 people lunch. Nice! We sat outside which was perfect. Nice people.

Bridgett Kile Sams

My cousin and I dined in on Sunday Aug. 3, 2025 for dinner. We shared the toasted ravioli and each had the amazing chicken parmesan. Our server was awesome but I'm afraid we didn't get her name. Y'all were very busy & while our appetizer came out quickly the entree's didn't but that was alright! She and I have both been in the food service business before...we get it! Our awesome server did choose to give us a discount for our long wait, which was very kind. We appreciated it! So thank you for amazing food, awesome service and extra kindness to some gals visiting your beautiful city!

O8669ZXstevens

Pizza: we had Pepperoni, Cheese, Buffalo Chicken, Supreme and Piggy Mac (I think that is what it was called). We also had bread sticks. If I was to rate it the pizza was 6.5/10

Linerguy

Forget the few naysayers; this place is fantastic. We stopped by on a Sunday for an early dinner, and they were having a special...any large pizza for $16. We ordered the Sicilian.....absolutely killer, and one of the best tasting pizzas we've ever had. Fresh, hot, spicy (sounds like a good date)...everything about it was perfect. Service was friendly and quick; no complaints at all.

KY_EMT54109

Parking is a nightmare but it’s definitely worth it. Cool little place with great food. Literally can’t complain about the lunch special. Great price for the amount of food you get. Definitely will stop again when I’m in Madison again.

Cindy Bell

This place is amazing!!! The spinach artichoke dip rocks! Great service! We will be back!

samisosacooper

Small establishment with tables and booths in the seating area. Right on the west end of Main Street near a few shops. The pizza and crust was great. (I love the crust) They offer a lunch special during the week and also personal pizzas are in the menu. The only one, of 3 eateries, that had Dr. Pepper!

Bryan Leniski

Variety of interesting pizza recipes. Handmade pizza. Great beer list!! Service is super friendly.

Antiquelover2

A couple of dirty tables was the first thing we saw upon entering the restaurant. (no, it wasn't that busy) Had the pizza lunch special which was good. Not great pizza, but good. Friendly, efficient waitress. Marinara sauce was good. A young man finally came in (I guess he was the busser) and just wiped the tables. No type of antibacterial spray or whatever restaurants normally use - just a wet rag he used on several tables. Didn't do a really good job cleaning. Nothing really special to go back for. It was just ok.

Tamara Gideon

Great service.
Pizza was good.
Fantastic beer selection.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Dan B

Great pizza and friendly staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul Fusko

Such a great pizza. I got the Mac daddy. It could not had been better!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mac Daddy

Monte Roth

Perfect personal pizzas for my wife and I.
Delicious and a perfect crust!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Craft Beer Selection, Great Pizza, Specialty Pizza

Loading...