The Red Pepperoni

842 W Main St, Madison
(812) 274-0111

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+61 photos
+60 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This was some of the best pizza I've had in a long long time. The spices and herbs were perfectly balanced, plenty of topping and just the right amount of cheese. My wife and I ordered the three-topping lunch special which came with a garden salad (or bread sticks) and a drink. Great deal.

The food and service were so good, we were back for lunch the next day.
My cousin and I dined in on Sunday Aug. 3, 2025 for dinner. We shared the toasted ravioli and each had the amazing chicken parmesan. Our server was awesome but I'm afraid we didn't get her name. Y'all were very busy & while our appetizer came out quickly the entree's didn't but that was alright! She and I have both been in the food service business before...we get it! Our awesome server did choose to give us a discount for our long wait, which was...
We are from out of town and decided to go here for dinner. Very reasonable, great environment, you can sit inside or out. This was some of the most delicious pizzas we have had from a small business. We sat outside on the patio, and our sever came out to us. Great staff, so friendly and prompt. If you're in the area swing in for a pizza, you won't be disappointed.

Parking: Sits on the corner and has very limited parking, it appears you can park...

More Reviews