GOODFELLA'S Brick Oven Pizza & Pasta Restaurant - McCordsville
9641 Olio Rd, McCordsville
(317) 336-6666
Customers' Favorites
Bread and Seasoned Olive Oil
Italian Bread with Dipping
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fettuccine Alfredo
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Chicken Parm Pizza
Meat Lovers Piza
Garlic Bread
Caesar Salad
Featured items
Traditional Pizza
Shredded mozz and pizza sauce.
Mozz' n Carrozza
Marinara sauce.
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine and Alfredo sauce.
Smokin' Goodfella Pizza
Smoked mozzarella, basil, sausage, roasted peppers, red pepper cream sauce, and caramelized onions.
Chopped Antipasto Salad
Balsamic and oil, red peppers, olives, onions, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Sandwiches
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Thinly sliced beef, sauteed with onion, and topped with provolone cheese and fries.
Grilled Chicken Caesar
Caesar dressing, chicken, and romaine lettuce.
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Mozzarella, fries, creamy Italian dressing, lettuce, onion, and tomato.
Robs Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Mozzarella, chicken, lettuce, sauce, and fries.
Italian Beef Sandwich
Honey Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Provolone, fries, honey dijon, lettuce, and tomato.
Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
Mozzarella, fries, meatball, and sauce.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Mozzarella, chicken, lettuce, sauce, and fries.
The Goodfella Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, fries, roasted peppers, tomato, lettuce, prosciutto, and salami.
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
Mozzarella, breaded eggplant, and marinara sauce.
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, breaded chicken, and marinara.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Caesar dressing, chicken, and romaine lettuce.
Italian Classic Wrap
Shredded mozzarella, fries, lettuce, onion, roasted peppers, and tomato.
Goodfella Burger
Fries, lettuce, onion, and tomato.
Blackened Chicken Philly Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Pizzas
Traditional Pizza
Shredded mozz and pizza sauce.
Old World Pizza
Fresh mozzarella and pizza sauce.
Gourmet Pizza
Smokin' Goodfella Pizza
Smoked mozzarella, basil, sausage, roasted peppers, red pepper cream sauce, and caramelized onions.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, sausage, prosciutto, pepperoni, and meatball.
Margherita Style Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, pizza sauce, olive oil, and basil.
The Goodfella Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, sausage, roasted peppers, pizza sauce, and fresh garlic.
The Works Pizza
Fresh mozzarella and pizza sauce.
Alfredo Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, shredded mozz, and alfredo sauce.
Hawaiian Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, prosciutto, pineapple, and caramelized onions.
Pizza alla Vodka Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, prosciutto, peas, and mushroom.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, chicken cutlet, and buffalo sauce.
Pizza Bianca
Fresh mozzarella and prosciutto.
Sally Pie Pizza
Cheddar cheese, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan cheese, potatoes, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and chicken.
Quattro Formaggi Pizza
Fontina cheese, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan cheese, provolone cheese, and pizza sauce.
Cheese Stix Pizza
Shredded mozz and garlic butter.
Chicken Parm Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, and chicken cutlet.
Vegetable Delight Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, pizza sauce, onions, mushroom, and fresh broccoli.
Quattro Stagioni Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, mushroom, black olives, artichoke hearts, and pizza sauce.
Sauteed Shrimp Pizza
Shredded mozz, shrimp, plum tomato sauce, and pecorino romano cheese.
Eggplant Parm Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, and fried eggplant.
Baked Clams Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, alfredo sauce, pecorino romano cheese, provolone, and sauteed clams.
Salads
Chopped Antipasto Salad
Balsamic and oil, red peppers, olives, onions, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Bleu cheese, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Side Salad
Red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Side Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce combined with our freshly made Caesar dressing, gourmet croutons and Caesar blend cheese.
Side Antipasto Salad
Balsamic and oil, red peppers, olives, onions, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Caesar Salad
Caesar, croutons, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, and red cabbage.
BBQ Salmon Salad
Raspberry, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons. Raspberry dressing.
Tuscany Salad
Lemon herb, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Garden Salad
Red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Dinner Pasta
Fettuccine Alfredo
Fettuccine and Alfredo sauce.
Lasagna Pasta
Ground beef, sausage, fresh ricotta cheese, and topped with homemade mozzarella and marinara sauce.
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Spaghetti, marinara, and meatball.
Linguini and Baby Clams
Linguine, baby clams, and little neck clams.
Fresh Cheese Ravioli
Sauce and cheese ravioli.
Chicken Goodfella
Rigatoni alla Vodka
Rigatoni, peas, prosciutto and vodka sauce.
Baked Ziti
Ziti sauce ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Angel Hair with Chicken and Peppers
Capellini plum tomato sauce chicken roasted peppers and hot peppers.
Chicken Balsamico
With angel hair pasta.
Shrimped Romulus with Lobster Sauce
Served with angel hair pasta.
Spaghetti and Sausage
Sauce and sausage.
Stuffed Penne with Chicken and Artichokes
Pasta Pomodoro
Capellini, plum tomato, garlic, and white wine.
Ravioli with Spinach and Sauces
Plum tomato, garlic, white wine, sausage, and spinach.
Rigatoni with Salted Vegetables
Sauteed vegetables with garlic white wine sauce.
Dinner Entrees
Shrimp Marinara with Pasta (Hot or Spicy)
A generous portion of salted shrimp in a marinara sauce with plum tomatoes fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil served over a bed of linguine.
Grilled Salmon with Apricot Glaze
Served with salted spinach and roasted potatoes.
Chicken Marsala
Chicken mushroom and marsala.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Chicken mozzarella and marinara.
Eggplant Parmigiana
Eggplant mozzarella and marinara.
Veal Parmigiana
Veal mozzarella and marinara.
Wood Fired Pork Chops with Apricot Glaze
Two 8 ounces centered cut pork chops, wood-fired to perfection and topped with apricot glaze, served with salted vegetables.
Goodfellas Creamy House Risotto Dinner
Chicken Francese
Chicken egg batter lemon and butter.
Blackened Tilapia
Blackened pan-seared tilapia fillet topped with mango salsa, served with a choice of roasted vegetables or house risotto.
Pan Seared Basa
Parmesan-crusted pan-seared basa fillet served with a choice of roasted vegetables or house risotto and side-up chipotle peppers cream sauce.
Chicken Piccata
Frutti di Mare with Pasta
Description shrimp, clams, and calamari salted with fresh basil, olive oil, garlic, and marinara sauce, served over a generous bed of linguine.
Mussel Marinara with Pasta
Served with a generous bed of linguine. One pound of cultured mussels salted with garlic, cherry wine, and plum tomato.
Veal Milanese
Roasted potatoes sauteed spinach veal and bruschetta.
Appetizers
Mozz' n Carrozza
Marinara sauce.
Breadsticks with Cheese
Marinara sauce.
Bread Stix
Marinara sauce.
Cheese Stix
Marinara sauce.
Garlic Bread
Sample Platter
Carozza, chicken fingers, garlic bread, fried ravioli, and buffalo wings.
Buffalo Wing
Celery and blue cheese.
Fried Ravioli
Fried Calamari
Fresh lemon and marinara sauce.
Beer Battered Fried Mushrooms
Served with your choice of ranch or spicy ranch dressing.
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Creamy spinach and artichoke dip baked to perfection and served with garlic.
Chicken Fingers (5 pcs)
Honey mustard.
Bruschetta
Diced tomatoes, onions, herbs, and garlic, marinated with extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar, served with grilled garlic toast.
Stuffed Mushrooms
Beautiful stuffed mushroom always freshly prepared, stuffed with breath seasoning and pecorino romano cheese, and topped with grated provolone cheese.
Calamari
Mozz, Tomatoes & Basil
Red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Mussels Appetizer
Mussels Marinara
A pound of cultured mussels, salted with garlic cherry wine and plumed tomato stripes.
Sides
Side Fries
Side Meatballs (3 pcs)
Side Pasta with Marinara
Sauteed Spinach
Side Pasta
Marinara.
Side Sausage (2 pcs)
House Risotto
Provolone.
Side Salted Veggies
Take Out Soda
Soda (2 lts)
Lemonade
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Bottle Water
Mr. Pibb
Nestea
San Benedetto
Cafe
Tea
Milk
Colombian
Soups
Bread
Pasta Fagioli
Lobster Bisque
Half-Loaf
Desserts
Tiramisu
Cannoli
Cheesecake
Chocolate Thunder
Spumoni Bomba Gelato
Black Forest
Kids Menu
Cheese Ravioli
Marinara.
Spaghetti Meatball
Marinara and spaghetti.
Chicken Fingers
Fries and honey mustard.
Kids Pizza
Shredded mozz and pizza sauce.
Mac n cheese
Waffle Fries
Kids Side Orders
Basket of Fries
Sally Chips
Kids Drinks
Milk
Soda
Sandwiches
Italian Classic Wrap
Shredded mozzarella, fries, lettuce, onion, roasted peppers, and tomato.
Honey Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Provolone, fries, honey dijon, lettuce, and tomato.
Blackened Chicken Philly Sandwich
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Mozzarella and chicken.
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
Provolone and grilled onion.
Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
Mozzarella, fries, meatball, and sauce.
Goodfella Burger
Fries, lettuce, onion, and tomato.
Italian Beef Sandwich
Ravioli with Spinach and Sauces
Chicago Style Beef Sandwich with Habanero Peppers
Angel Hair with Chicken and Peppers Sandwich
Capellini plum tomato sauce chicken roasted peppers and hot peppers.
Scampi Shrimp Sandwich
Served with a choice of pasta.
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Mozzarella, fries, creamy Italian dressing, lettuce, onion, and tomato.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Sandwich
Caesar dressing, chicken, and romaine lettuce.
The Goodfella Sandwich
Fresh mozzarella, fries, roasted peppers, tomato, lettuce, prosciutto, and salami.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap Sandwich
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
Mozzarella and eggplant.
Robs Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Mozzarella, chicken, lettuce, sauce, and fries.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Balsamico Sandwich
With angel hair pasta.
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Stuffed Penne with Chicken and Artichokes
Grilled Eggplant Sandwich
Mozzarella, sauce, eggplant, and roasted peppers.
Pizzas
Old World Pizza
Fresh mozzarella and pizza sauce.
Traditional Pizza
Shredded mozz and pizza sauce.
Gourmet Pizza
Smokin' Goodfella Pizza
Smoked mozzarella, basil, sausage, roasted peppers, red pepper cream sauce, and caramelized onions.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, sausage, prosciutto, pepperoni, and meatball.
Margherita Style Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, pizza sauce, olive oil, and basil.
The Goodfella Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, sausage, roasted peppers, pizza sauce, and fresh garlic.
Hawaiian Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, prosciutto, pineapple, and caramelized onions.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, chicken cutlet, and buffalo sauce.
Pizza Bianca
Fresh mozzarella and prosciutto.
Sally Pie Pizza
Cheddar cheese, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan cheese, potatoes, caramelized onions, mushrooms, and chicken.
Quattro Formaggi Pizza
Fontina cheese, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan cheese, provolone cheese, and pizza sauce.
Alfredo Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, shredded mozz, and alfredo sauce.
Quattro Stagioni Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, prosciutto, mushroom, black olives, artichoke hearts, and pizza sauce.
Vegetable Delight Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, pizza sauce, onions, mushroom, and fresh broccoli.
Chicken Parm Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, and chicken cutlet.
Cheese Stix Pizza
Shredded mozz and garlic butter.
The Works Pizza
Fresh mozzarella and pizza sauce.
Sauteed Shrimp Pizza
Shredded mozz, shrimp, plum tomato sauce, and pecorino romano cheese.
Pizza a la Vodka
Fresh mozzarella, vodka sauce, prosciutto, peas, and mushroom.
Eggplant Parm Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, pizza sauce, and fried eggplant.
Baked Clams Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, alfredo sauce, pecorino romano cheese, provolone, and sauteed clams.
Salads
Chopped Antipasto Salad
Balsamic and oil, red peppers, olives, onions, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Bleu cheese, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Side Salad
Red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Side Antipasto Salad
Balsamic and oil, red peppers, olives, onions, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Garden Salad
Red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
BBQ Salmon Salad
Raspberry, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons. Raspberry dressing.
Caesar Salad
Caesar, croutons, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, and red cabbage.
Side Caesar Salad
Caesar, croutons, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, and red cabbage.
Tuscany Salad
Lemon herb, red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Appetizers
Mozz' n Carrozza
Marinara sauce.
Breadsticks with Cheese
Marinara sauce.
Garlic Bread
Cheese Stix
Marinara sauce.
Sample Platter
Carozza, chicken fingers, garlic bread, fried ravioli, and buffalo wings.
Fried Ravioli
Buffalo Wing
Celery and blue cheese.
Bruschetta
Diced tomatoes, onions, herbs, and garlic, marinated with extra virgin olive oil and balsamic vinegar, served with grilled garlic toast.
Chicken Fingers (5 pcs)
Honey mustard.
Stuffed Mushrooms
Beautiful stuffed mushroom always freshly prepared, stuffed with breath seasoning and pecorino romano cheese, and topped with grated provolone cheese.
Breadsticks
Marinara sauce.
Beer Battered Fried Mushrooms
Served with your choice of ranch or spicy ranch dressing.
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Creamy spinach and artichoke dip baked to perfection and served with garlic.
Fried Calamari
Fresh lemon and marinara sauce.
Calamari
Mussels Marinara
A pound of cultured mussels, salted with garlic cherry wine and plumed tomato stripes.
Mozz, Tomatoes & Basil
Red leaf, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumber, carrots, red cabbage, and croutons.
Mozz Marinara
Mussels Appetizer
Lunch Pasta
Spaghetti and Meatballs Pasta
Rigatoni with Salted Vegetables Pasta
Baked Ziti Pasta
Ziti sauce ricotta cheese and mozzarella.
Goodfellas Lasagna Pasta
Rigatoni alla Vodka Pasta
Rigatoni, vodka sauce, peas and prosciutto.
Fresh Cheese Ravioli Pasta
Lunch Entrees
Grilled Salmon with Apricot Glaze
Served with salted spinach and roasted potatoes.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
Chicken Marsala
Chicken mushroom and marsala.
Eggplant Parmigiana
Eggplant mozzarella and marinara.
Chicken Balsamico
Capellini balsamico sauce chicken sun-dried tomatoes and mushrooms.
Chicken Francese
Chicken egg batter lemon and butter.
Veal Parmigiana
Veal mozzarella and marinara.
Veal Milanese
Roasted potatoes sauteed spinach veal and bruschetta.
Sides
Side Fries
Side Meatballs (3 pcs)
Side Sausage (2 pcs)
Side Pasta with Marinara
House Risotto
Provolone.
Side Pasta
Marinara.
Side Salted Veggies
Sauteed Spinach
Take Out Soda
Coke
Diet Coke
Lemonade
Sprite
Soda
Mr. Pibb
Nestea
Bottle Water
Cafe
Tea
Colombian
Milk
Soups
Bread
Pasta Fagioli
Lobster Bisque
Half-Loaf
Desserts
Cannoli
Chocolate Thunder
Cheesecake
Black Forest
Spumoni Bomba Gelato
Kids Menu
Cheese Ravioli
Marinara.
Spaghetti Meatball
Marinara and spaghetti.
Chicken Fingers
Fries and honey mustard.
Kids Pizza
Shredded mozz and pizza sauce.
Mac n cheese
Waffle Fries
Kids Side Orders
Basket of Fries
Sally Chips
Kids Drinks
Soda
Milk
Photos
+46 photos
+45 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
These guys are great, we’ve been regulars here for years and realized we’ve never written a review. The servers there are awesome! Shout out to Katie, Aubrey, and Stephanie you gals are amazing! <3 The tea couple A&J
October 2025
Picked up a pizza for carry out. Wasn’t familiar with the restaurant. Everything was good. Service was great.. The pizza fell just a little sort of what we were hoping for. 7 on a 1-10 scale, maybe.asked if breadsticks were rolled or cut. Was told they were rolled, but they didn’t seem so when we ate them. again, they were good, just expected something different.
September 2025
Wife and I have been here 2x now. Kind of a date night when the kids aren't home for dinner. The place is cozy, as we grabbed the same table in the bar area on both visits. Awesome calamari, we got it for an app both times. The first visit, I tried the lasagna and loved it. The second visit, I ordered a supreme pizza. We got a couple desserts to-go last time. Service was perfect both times. We will be back, and try something new here soon. If you are in the area, and wanna...
September 2024
You May Also Like
Happy Cuisine - 9657 Olio Rd
![]()
Asian, Asian Fusion, Fast Food, Sushi Bar, Chinese
Papa Johns Pizza - 9669 Olio Rd
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Fast Food
McDonald's - 9707 Olio Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Coffee & Tea, Burgers