El Compadre

1608 Wilkins Way, Mitchell
(812) 849-0340

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Dixie Carter

Menu had lots of options that I haven't seen at other Mexican restaurants. Looking forward to my leftovers for another meal tomorrow! Our server was great, very attentive.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Moore

My wife and I enjoyed the food. This is your typical Mexican restaurant menu. It's not a large restaurant and not easily seen from 37. But the servi was great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tiffany Collingsworth

I order from here alot and am usually very satisfied.Tonight I'm really disappointed.My fries were soggy and cold couldn't even eat them had to throw them away.My fish sandwich was lukewarm.I asked for onions on my sandwich and got charged a 1.00 for a handful of onions if even that.You can buy a whole onion for a dollar.If a person orders food from you they should be able to choose what they like on their sandwich.

Tonia Cagle

Waited at least 30 minutes to receive food while anther couple came in and was severed food before us. We ordered pulled pork sandwich and fries and 2 bean burritos. Tired of waiting i ask for a check for our drinks. Then our food magically appeared. Told the waiter it would be separate checks and received bill for both orders on one ticket. I will not be back. Never had this poor of service anywhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Kristen

The food is good, not the best, but still good. Our waiter Jorge (George) was so nice and helpful, despite being super busy. He made our whole night, with his humour and helpfulness!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

David

I ask for just lettuce and nothing else and what do they do put lettuce and everything i said to not put can't follow simple requests

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Kennedy Seitz

The service and food I received today both were terrible, I was forgotten about when I called to place my order, and had to call back, the lady running the cash register was very impatient (there were 3 tables with customers), and the food was awful. My husbands quesadilla was soggy to the point of dripping, he took about 3 bites from it before gagging. My refried beans had wilted lettuce mixed in with it, and the rice tasted like there was cleaning chemicals in it. We typically enjoy El compadre but the last couple of times we have gone there have been terrible and the Mitchell El Compadre has lost our business.

Mark Jabaay

We were very pleased with both the food and the service.

Mike Kukman

Always Good!

Alpha Panda

Will NEVER return! Woooooow! Stay away!!!

evie spurling

We love El Compadre! Never disappoints!! Excellent service! Check it out yourself!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marty

Terrible service!!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Juan Lopez

Excellent service.. and plenty of truck parking

Parking: Big enough to park my truck and trailer

Recommended dishes: Taco, Cheese Dip, Fries

Katie Ward

The food was delicious, fresh, and piping hot. Even though we live out of town, I will come back just for this restaurant. The serving sizes were enough to feed me for a couple of days and the price was comparatively low.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Reuben Montgomery

Don’t waste your money on the cheese dip! They give you very little cheese and on top of that they water it down. Cheese came out bubbly and very thin, watery. After it had set and cooled off for a good moment the cheese did not film over like normal Mexican cheese does and remained very thin. It appears they are adding water to the cheese to make it go further!

This was the best location as far as the food quality and taste goes compared to the other two locations I have tried to date, which was Bedford and French Lick.. Except for the cheese dip.

Highly recommend the Authentic Mexican Guacamole, this was so fresh and tasted wonderful! Price is a bit steep for the amount you get. Portion size was too small compared to price.

Salsa was good and was better than most Mexican locations when it came to flavor although it was puréed into salsa juice. If you like a little bit of tomatoes tiny or bigger chunks, then you will be disappointed. You literally could almost drink it.

I was learning on giving them a 3 star review as the food was better than their other locations but I’m not because when I asked what they were doing to the cheese they acted like that was the way it was supposed to be. One of the reasons you go to Mexican Restaurants is for good quality cheese.

Staff were friendly and service was good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Loading...