Browse menus, reviews and photos of the best places to eat near Mitchell.
Bakery · $
915 West Main Street, Mitchell
“We stopped in right before they closed and was greeted with a smile and a welcome. We got some wonderful doughnuts at a great price and they were amazing. We will be back.”
Chinese · $
1503 Wilkins Way, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Came from out of town this weekend and a local said to try this place. We’re pretty cautious about Chinese food places due to just inconsistency of whether it would make us sick or not. Or whether it’s a clean place or not. This place did not disappoint, crab Rangoon was actually full filling. Orange chicken actually had orange taste and shrimp and sour shrimp was crispy. Owner was also very friendly and hospitable as we did dine in with my three young kids”
Cafe · $
505 West Main Street, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Good food,good service I recommend”
Coffee Roasteries · $
1228 West Warren Street, Mitchell
“Well managed business producing excellent products! This coffee is on another level!”
Wineries · $$
6058 Lawrenceport Road, Mitchell
“Awesome drive in country in Mitchell,IN. Had a great wine tasting and enjoyed Mrs Wilson's story about the wines and their winery. It is well worth the time and drive to visit. Thank you for your hospitality.”
Pizza · $
3221 IN-37, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Perfection, Best Around🙌🏼💕 Always Fresh and Hott! 5 Stars Great Manager❣️”
Mexican · $
1608 Wilkins Way, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“My spouse and I visited from out of town for lunch. I just have to say that I am so glad I chose this place. The food was fast, hot and DELICIOUS. The waitress was very friendly and the place seemed very clean. I am sad theres not a location at home but excited I have a place to visit when I come back. Definitely recommend”
Ice Cream Shop · $
2478 IN-60, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Absolutely fabulous place for ice cream and shakes... and pup cups!! After an adventurous day we wanted to end it with a sweet treat and that landed us here. I was shocked to see that they had black cherry hard ice cream!!! It was creamy and sweet and reminded me of growing up in upstate NY and going to the Stewart's Shoppe 45 minutes from home get black cherry ice cream!! My better half had a chocolate malt and he loved it, said it was perfect! This is definitely the place to get ice cream and when we are back in the area we will certainly stop in again!”
Pizza · $
3614 IN-37, Mitchell
“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”
Pizza · $
2860 IN-37, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Bad experience this past weekend between the app not working and getting a messed up order! Apparently the manager Zach is a stand up guy! He reached out privately to offer a free pizza. We will try again! In the past we’ve had good service!”
Fast Food · $
3159 IN-37, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“The experience was crappy went through the drive-through they messed up our order and then because they didn’t give us a receipt they were not replace our food”
Fast Food · $
1504 Wilkins Way, Mitchell
“A worker took extra time and precaution to make a cantina bowl for my daughter with health issues and to make sure there was no cross contamination. It was truly appreciated!”
Sandwich Shop · $
3593 IN-37, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“I've ordered 15 footlong sandwiches in the last 2 weeks. I drive from out-of-town because the 2 Subways near me don't accept coupons, which is the only reason I would go to a Subway these days. I've interacted with 4 different workers and they have all been pleasant. All of the sandwiches were made correctly and ready when I arrived.”
Fast Food · $
2880 IN-37, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Downloaded the Wendy’s app in hopes making the ordering process faster, as I was running late for my son‘s nap time. Unfortunately, the delivery app used my location and somehow I ended up ordering in another state. I didn’t catch this until I was already at the restaurant and we could not find my order in the system. My order had disappeared from the Wendy’s app, and I was having difficulty canceling my order and re-ordering. The management team went above and beyond. They went ahead and made my food and gave it to me, despite me not having paid or ordered at the right location. They gave me the resources to cancel my order and refund my money at another time. So thankful for the caring individuals who helped me today! Wish I could’ve caught names to give a proper thanks. Food was great, as you would expect any Wendy’s establishment to be. Highly recommend if you are stopping through the Mitchell area!🙂”
Fast Food · $
2918 IN-37, Mitchell
Customers’ favorites
“Food was fresh and good but the person taking my order was lost. Never will I understand why you would put someone in the Drive thru if they don't understand the menu or the mobile app.”
Bakery · $
2513 16th Street, Bedford · 9.04 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We love magic morning and so it only made sense to get our wedding cake there! They make the best strawberry cake, it is so soft and flavorful, literally perfect. We got a single tier strawberry heart cake with vanilla buttercream and also some of the same flavor cupcakes, plus chocolate cupcakes! I accidentally left the cake unattended on the kitchen counter and our cat stomped on the box and ruined it the day before the wedding, but we called and they were able to rush us another cake that day. THANK YOU MAGIC MORNING, you are the best!!!”
Diner · $
2501 8th Street, Bedford · 9.68 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I love eating here and the peolpe that run it do a great job . the food is great .”
Pizza · $
120 West Jefferson Street, Orleans · 4.96 miles
Customers’ favorites
“The atmosphere, the staff, the food and OMG, the frozen cider. A WONDERFUL place to stop. We met up with some friends from Mitchell and I asked them to take me there as I had tried a sip of the frozen cider. I am not a drinker by any means, but oh, Heaven on earth it was DELICIOUS! Definitely gonna be back again when I have a driver!!!!! 5+ 🌟”
Family · $
2547 IN-37, Paoli · 9.65 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My husband and I stopped at this place for breakfast and it was a 10 out of 10 ! Definitely recommend this place !”
Buffet · $
1521 James Avenue, Bedford · 9.25 miles
Customers’ favorites
“My favorite place to eat!!”
Ice Cream Shop · $
142 16th Street, Bedford · 8.86 miles
Customers’ favorites
“We've been going to Jiffy Treet for over 40 years. My hubby's ole college roommate is from Bedford, and he introduced us to Jiffy Treet. I highly recommend their Sloppy Joe's, Foot Long Sloppy Joe Dogs, and BBQs. I'm not a big ice cream eater, but I absolutely love their ice cream! We live a couple of hours away, but go to southern Indiana often, and we stop by on either the way down, or the way back, (sometimes both) when staying at the French Lick Resort. We stopped by almost 30 times in 2024, and again in 2025. The food never disappoints. It's all yummy! 😋 We've started carrying a cooler in our car just so I can bring home their homemade ice cream. My favorite ice cream on the menu is their JT Crunch. Some of my favorite hand dipped flavors of the month are: Big Red, German Chocolate Cake, and Gooey Butter Cake. I always get a single dip, but it always is generous and looks like a dip and a half. My favorite soft serve is their seasonal Persimmon ice cream. In our 40 plus years we have never had a bad meal from Jiffy Treet. We love it that they stay open until December, and open back up in either January or February. That allows us to spend more time at one of our favorite restaurants.”
Ice Cream Shop · $
255 West Washington Street, Orleans · 5.05 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Donuts were great, come to see them at Bedford parade”
American · $
919 15th Street, Bedford · 8.97 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great staff and management! Stopped in for a beer. Managed introduced himself and brought me by an appetizer to try. Great environment! We will definitely come back for dinner!”
Mexican · $
1529 L Street, Bedford · 8.91 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Best Mexican food in town!”
Bar & Grill · $
1300 7th Street, Bedford · 9.64 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Great bartenders, very friendly and polite.”
Pizza · $
2717 John A Williams Boulevard, Bedford · 8.89 miles
Customers’ favorites
“First time I've been inside of Bubba's. I decided to try their mac & cheese and pepperoni breadsticks. Both were absolutely delicious! The atmosphere inside looks a bit industrial but I was taking my food to go. Will be back again soon!”
Chinese · $
2625 16th St, Bedford · 9.13 miles
Customers’ favorites
“99 is my absolute favorite! wonderful prices and the best crab rangoon i’ve had. the staff is so friendly :)”
Mexican · $
134 South Maple Street, Orleans · 5 miles
Customers’ favorites
“Was on a work trip and stopped in for lunch. Very friendly and prompt service. The restaurant was clean with a great atmosphere. The food was delicious. If ever in the area again, I will be stopping back in.”
Bar · $
1220 5th Street, Bedford · 9.8 miles
Customers’ favorites
“really really good ppl and owners”
Bakery · $
1527 J Street, Bedford · 8.9 miles
Customers’ favorites
“I stop by and grab drinks all the time when I go to work!! 10/10”