Papa Johns Pizza
2860 IN-37, Mitchell
(812) 992-2900
Customers' Favorites
Create Your Own Pizza Medium
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Large Supreme Pizza
Chocolate Brownie
Buffalo Sauce
Pick a Sides
Cheesesticks
Knots
Photos
+27 photos
+26 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I've never had an issue with service or employees. I think it is expensive not a lot of menu items our deals. Some facts about the carryout or delivery only there is a drive through window, and though the delivery fee in my opinion is a little high but it is about the only restaurant in Mitchell that does delivery. If you order online most of the time you can better coupons or deal then by ordering over phone or carryout
Pizza, breadsticks, and Oreo bites were great as always! I've spent hundreds, if not, in the thousands at this location specifically. They are always friendly and super quick with my food. This was the only time I did not get my food in the amount of time that Papa Track said it would be done. But 1 of 50+ times is pretty darn good! ? Keep it up Mitchell PJ!
Papa John's was on the ball tonight. Amazing service and our food, all custom orders, was perfect. The pink-haired girl has a great future if she keeps her very pleasant attitude. Its contagious.
You May Also Like
Arby's - 3159 IN-37
![]()
Fast Food
Chicago's Pizza - 3221 IN-37
![]()
Pizza, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian