An Udder Sensation

138 S Main St, Monticello
(574) 240-1477

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Old Fashioned Vanilla Raspberry Rhapsody
Single Waffle Cones
Superman Ice Cream
Peppermint Stick
Rainbow Sherbet
Birthday Cake
Cup Cone
Sundaes

Menu

Cones
Wafer Cone
Cup Cone
Sugar Cone
Waffle Cone

Sundae
Original Vanilla Ice Cream
Chocolate syrup whipped cream.
The Fred Vanilla Ice Cream
Peanut butter and nuts.
Thrashers Woods Graham Cracker
Vanilla ice cream chocolate syrup and marshmallow fluff topped with a graham cracker.
Day and Knight
Butter pecan, banana, and chocolate syrup.
Udder Nutter
Peanut butter cup, chocolate syrup, and nutter butter cookie.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+27 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+26 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Absolutely wonderful location to experience the charm of a quaint downtown and enjoy a sweet treat while making memories. The owner created a welcoming atmosphere where you can enjoy your ice cream and enjoy a fun family game during your visit.
March 2025
Best ice cream in Monticello! This little shop is so fun and always has creative & delicious flavors! It’s always clean, always friendly service, and a fun sitting area filled with games to play after eating your ice cream.
March 2025
Flavors come and go. Some seasonal and some at random it seems. It is some of the best ice cream around. Earl Gray tea ice cream, fat Elvis, exhausted parent, and so many more flavors. Cash, card, and Venmo accepted. Plenty of games. Checkers, connect four, and others.

Parking: Park as close as you can get along the curb. Usually spots are available but I don't get around there during peak hours either
August 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Le Petit Cafe Monticello - 138 S Main St
Salad, Soup
Cazadores Mexican Restaurant - 111 N Main St
Mexican, Vegetarian
Janet's Intown Lounge - 213 N Main St
Bar & Grill, Lounges, Bar

An Udder Sensation

138 S Main St, Monticello, IN 47960
(574) 240-1477