Papa Jay's BBQ

6379 IN-16, Monticello
(574) 278-6030

Recent Reviews

Morgan

Fantastic BBQ!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Half Rack, Pulled Pork, Rib Plates

NayNay2mylittleones

First time visiting was today. Very tasty pulled pork was delicious. Mac and cheese was good, my preference would be cheese melted but it was good.

Deb Randolph

First time visiting was today. Very tasty pulled pork was delicious. Mac and cheese was good, my preference would be cheese melted but it was good.

Tamara Bode

Drove over an hour each way to get ribs. Closed on Saturday even though it said was open here. Super disappointed. It looked like no one had been around for a while.

gordon brownlee

Fast and friendly, good ribs

Christopher Sommers

First time we have been able to swing through around lunch time for fantastic ribs and pulled pork! This did not disappoint. Give this place a try next time you are going through Buffalo Indiana! The sides are sweet potatoes and green beans today. Well worth the money.

Zachary McIntosh

Can confirm that the food is smackin'. You can't beat it.

Matthew Dillon

Holy **** I heard it was good fair prices and fast…it’s outstandingly delicious cheaper then McDonald’s and hot and waiting . Thank you Jay and Heather

Travis Poisel

The best pulled pork sandwiches I've ever had. Everything on the smoker looks amazing. Will definitely make special trips to this spot.

Chris Farley Wells

The food is delicious and the owners are great people!!

Abbie Layne

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!. Pulled pork was so tender and juicy!. Ribs were too die for!

payton brewer

Food is smackin. I promise.

Jeff Berger

Good ribs.

Kim Thorpe

I got a 1/2 slab of ribs today to try. They were very good and tender. The sauce on the side was also fantastic. i will definitely be back. Great job!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

David Corbin Rockenbaugh

Delicious barbecue. The sides are terrific!

Load More